How to Effectively Referee a Ph.D. Thesis - Enago Academy

1. HowtoEffectivelyRefereeaPh.D.Thesis Enago Academy is here to answer all your questions related to academic research and publishing.

2. ENAGO ACADEMY Enago Academy offers comprehensive and up-to-date resources for researchers, publishers, editors, and students to learn and share their experience about research and publishing. Enago Academy also conducts workshops primarily for ESL authors, early-stage researchers, and graduate students. Our advanced workshop modules cater to the needs of researchers who want to know more about the issues pertinent to successful publication.

3. ENAGO Enago is the trusted name in author services for the global research community. Since 2005, we have worked with researchers in more than 125 countries improving the communication of their research and helping them to achieve success in publication. We have offices in Tokyo, Seoul, Beijing, Shanghai, Istanbul, and New York. Enago operates globally with regional teams supporting researchers locally. Enago is the preferred partner for many leading universities and research organizations worldwide. In addition, we also collaborate with prominent publishers and societies to overcome regional challenges.

4. 10/12/2018 How to Effectively Referee a Ph.D. Thesis - EnagoAcademy HowtoEffectivelyRefereeaPh.D.Thesis Lastupdated Oct 8, 2018 Arefereeissomeonewhohasbeengiventheresponsibilityofevaluatingthesuitabilityofadoctoralthesisand the candidate for the award of a Ph.D. degree. This degree is the highest degree that an individual can attain academically.Therefore,itconsistsofagoodamountoforiginalresearchpresentedintheformofathesisor dissertation.Theuniversitygrantingthedegreeusestheevaluationoftherefereeasaqualitychecktoassessthe suitabilityofthecandidatefortheawardofaPh.D.Thus,itistheresponsibilityoftherefereetoevaluatethe thesisandthecandidatewell. WhyaGoodEvaluationbyRefereesMatters Ph.D.degreerequirementsmayvaryacrossuniversities.However,mostrequirePh.D.studentstodefendathesis beforereferees.Thethesisiskrstevaluatedbythereferee,followedbyadefensethatmaybeopenorclosedto thegeneralaudience.Thepurposeofthisevaluationistoevaluatethestudent’ssubjectknowledgeandalsotheir researchcapabilities.Ph.D.holderspursuecareersinacademia,government,andindustry.Allsuchjobsrequirea  greatamountofskillandresponsibility.Theimportanceandsensitivityofresearchconductedinkeldssuchas medicalandbiomedicalsciencesalsorequiretheexpertiseofhighlyskilledresearchers.Inadditiontoteaching, https://www.enago.com/academy/how-to-referee-a-phd-thesis-effectively/

5. 10/12/2018 How to Effectively Referee a Ph.D. Thesis - EnagoAcademy university professors also have to mentor the next generation of researchers. Therefore, to ensure that candidatestakingupthesepositionsarecompetentenoughforthejob,itisessentialforarefereetoevaluate responsibly. HelpfulTipsandQuestionsforReferees Yourjobasarefereeisveryimportant.YoushouldfollowguidelinesforexaminingPh.D.thesesiftheuniversity hasany.Youshouldaimtoreturnthereviewassoonaspossible.Thisisimportantbecausetheremaybemore thanonepersoninvolvedinevaluatingthethesisanddelayswouldmakeschedulingdifkcult.Thestudentwould alsowanttomoveaheadandpursueajobquickly. Tohelpyouwithagoodandfairreview,youcantrytoanswerquestionsaboutreviewcriteria,like: Istheworkoriginal? Doesitalsobuildonpreviouswork? Areallthereferencescomplete,current,andaccurate? Doesitaddtotheexistingknowledgeinthatkeld? Weretheexperimentsdoneusingpropercontrols? Werethedataanalyzedusingwidelyacceptedstatisticaltechniques? Doesthestudentadmitanystudyweaknesses? Aretheresultsgivenwithenoughdetail? Aretheconclusionsjustiked? Istheworkpresentedclearlyandwithouterrors? Doesthestudenthaveagoodunderstandingoftheworkdone? Hasthestudentevaluatedhis/herworkcritically? YoushouldrecommendthePh.D.degreeonlyifyoucananswer“yes”tonearlyallofthesequestions.Theaward mayalsodependonminorcorrectionstothethesis.Itisalsoabsolutelyfairtoaskthestudenttorevisethethesis andretaketheexamiftheanswertoseveralofthesequestionsis“no.”Itmayalsobefairtorejectthethesisifyou answer“no”tomostofthequestions.Yourdecisionhastheabilitytomakeabigimpactonthestudent,university, andalsotheresearchcommunityingeneral. ThingstoKeepinMind Makesurethatyougivethestudentcriticalandspecikcfeedback.Donotjustsaythatthethesiswasgoodorbad. Youshouldmentionthegoodthingsaboutthethesisandspecifythingsthatthestudentcouldrevise(e.g.,useof bettercontrolsforaparticularexperiment).Goodfeedbackcanalsohelpthestudentimprovetheircapabilitiesas aresearcher. Learnmoreaboutrefereeinstructions,andkndoutaboutexaminerreportsusedbyleadinguniversities. DoyouthinkrefereesreviewaPh.D.thesisfairly?DoesaPh.D.degreehelptoensureyourresearchcapabilities? Douniversitiesgiverefereessufkcientguidelinestoevaluatetheses?Pleaseshareyourthoughtsinthecomments  s ectionbelow. https://www.enago.com/academy/how-to-referee-a-phd-thesis-effectively/

6. 10/12/2018 REFERENCES: How to Effectively Referee a Ph.D. Thesis - EnagoAcademy https://www.topuniversities.com/blog/what-phd https://www.auckland.ac.nz/en/about/the-university/how-university-works/policy-and- administration/teaching-and-learning/postgraduate-research/examinations/guidelines-template.html https://www.i-med.ac.at/studium/formulare/phd/Instructions-for-PhD-thesis-reviewers.pdf https://www.auckland.ac.nz/en/about/the-university/how-university-works/policy-and- administration/teaching-and-learning/postgraduate-research/examinations/examinersoftheses.html https://www.cs.ut.ee/sites/default/kles/cs/instructions_0.pdf https://www.ucd.ie/registry/assessment/staff_info/guidelines_for_PhD_examiners.pdf https://www.mcgill.ca/gps/kles/gps/phd_examiner_report_gps.pdf  https://www.enago.com/academy/how-to-referee-a-phd-thesis-effectively/

7. 10/12/2018 This article was originally published at Enago Academy by Enago Editing services which provides scientific editing and manuscript editing services to researchers, authors and Phd students. For more information contact - - orders@enago.com.  Ethicalissues REPORTING RESEARCH PUBLISHING RESEARCH IMPORTANT LINKS OUR SERVICES ABOUTUS EnglishEditingContactUs GLOBAL ENAGO Language& Grammar Selecting Journals PhDs & PostdocsServices GuestContributor Product & Service Copy Editing ReviewsServices AboutEnago Academy Journal Guidelines Submitting Manuscripts Substantive Editing Services Ask aQuestion! Manuscripts& Grants Understanding Reviews Publication Support Services Reference Management Understanding Ethics Proofreading Services Figures &Tables Enago Academy offers comprehensive and up-to-date resources for researchers, publishers, editors, and students to learn and sharetheirexperienceaboutresearchandpublishing. Enago AcademyalsoconductsworkshopsprimarilyforESLauthors,early- stageresearchers,andgraduatestudents.Ouradvancedworkshopmodulescatertotheneedsofresearcherswhowanttoknow moreabouttheissuespertinenttosuccessfulpublication.ReadMore Copyright © - ALL RIGHTS RESERVED | PrivacyPolicy | Terms & Conditions| ContactUs  https://www.enago.com/academy/how-to-referee-a-phd-thesis-effectively/