1 / 28

Medico-legal Update: What’s new and what’s on the horizon.

The human brain is an amazing thing. It starts working at the moment of birth and only stops when you have to speak in public. Medico-legal Update: What’s new and what’s on the horizon. Julian Woolfson LLM FRCOG April 2007.

adrina
Download Presentation

Medico-legal Update: What’s new and what’s on the horizon.

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. The human brain is an amazing thing. It starts working at the moment of birth and only stops when you have to speak in public

  2. Medico-legal Update:What’s new and what’s on the horizon. Julian Woolfson LLM FRCOG April 2007

  3. The Regulation of Health Professionals in the 21st Century: the White Paper on Professional Regulation. • Acting as an Expert Witness: GMC draft for consultation. • RCOG Guidelines on VBAC and the management of perineal tears. and, finally, • A message from the taxman.

  4. The Regulation of Health Professionals in the 21st Century: the White Paper on Professional Regulation

  5. Largely accepts the recommendations made in Good doctors, safer patients and in the response to the Shipman report, though with changes and clarifications in key areas. • A move from the criminal standard of proof to the lower civil standard in fitness-to-practise cases. Sliding scale, with stronger evidence needed in the most serious cases, so the standard would be virtually indistinguishable from the criminal standard were a doctor’s livelihood to be threatened; • The make-up and role of the GMC. • Revalidation/fitness to practise assessment by means of Relicensure and, for specialists including GPs, Recertification;

  6. A regional network of GMC Affiliates • A three-board model covering undergraduate education, postgraduate education and continuing professional development. PMETB to continue as a separate legal entity; • Changes to the nature and amount of information held by the GMC on individual doctors. • Commissioning and piloting 360-degree feedback; • the introduction of an appraisal process with a summative component (looking back at performance against specific standards);

  7. Standards for each area of specialist recertification, (for which the costs would be recovered either through a direct payment to the relevant Royal College or through fees to the GMC, depending on the circumstances); • A rehabilitative and supporting emphasis to professional regulation; • Continuous professional development and life-long learning.

  8. Will anything change? • Little or no relevance to the vast majority of doctors, who already practice to a very high standard:

  9. For every time that Harold Shipman and Beverley Allitt are mentioned, we must recall the hundreds of thousands of extraordinary individuals who dedicate themselves impeccably to their patients every day. Most health professionals meet high standards routinely and have a lifelong appetite to be even better. That professionalism is an unquantifiable asset to our society, which rules, regulations and systems must support, not inhibit. Patricia Hewitt Foreword to the White Paper

  10. But what about the tiny minority who don’t …. Will they now change their ways and do what they are asked to do ?

  11. Patricia Hewitt (if only) The medical profession (not likely)

  12. Or will they stick their necks out and remain on the outside?

  13. Will anything change? • With the exception of 360-degree appraisal, little evidence to support many of the proposed changes to regulation. • There is likely to be increased scrutiny, through availability of more detailed information held on doctors. May be a help or a hindrance in Clinical Governance

  14. Someone has to pay for the increased governance activity, but who? • The White Paper recognises that the Royal Medical Colleges do, after all, have an important role in providing education, settingstandards and assessing competence.

  15. Which is where we started, millions of £££ ago…

  16. PMETB, NPEU, CHi, GMC and others demonstrating effective communication

  17. Acting as an Expert Witness: GMC draft for consultation Raising Concerns “If you become aware that patients or others are being placed at risk of death or serious harm, you should report your concerns, to the appropriate person or organisation without delay. If the information giving rise to your concerns is covered by legal professional privilege (legal advice or litigation privilege) you can still report that you have concerns and about whom, though you must explain that you came by your concerns in privileged circumstances and so cannot lawfully disclose the documents or their substance”.

  18. “Documents exchanged between parties in litigation (thereby waiving legal privilege) remain confidential, and disclosure of these documents or their substance may be in contempt of court. As with documents that are legally privileged, you can report that you have concerns, and about whom, without disclosing the documents or their substance. It will then be for the person or organisation to investigate as they see fit.”

  19. “You should exercise caution if asked to enter into contracts that require you to remain silent about details of cases settled out of court, which are not legal privileged but are confidential. Signing a contract which may require silence will, in those exceptional cases where patients may be at risk, put you in the difficult position of having to break that contract in order to satisfy your professional, ethical obligations”

  20. A group of Medical Experts maintaining silence.

  21. RCOG Guidelines on VBAC and the management of perineal tears:Helpful in defining the standard of care

  22. And finally, a message from the taxman:

  23. HEALTH PROFESSIONALS— VATABLE SERVICES FROM 1ST MAY 2007Please refer to the full text of VAT Notice 701/57 Health Professionals January 2007, available from Latest Updates on the VAT section at www.hmrc.gov.uk. • Charges made by Health Professionals are VATable if the primary purpose of the service is not the protection, maintenance or restoration of the health of the person concerned or are outside of the profession in which you are registered or are otherwise specifically exempted or outside the scope of VAT. • VATable charges specifically include the following: • Medico-Legal medicals and reports • Expert witness testimony and allowances (unless in respect of giving only professional evidence to the High Court under Supreme Court Act 1981)

  24. The End (Of Medical and Legal Practice as we know them?)

More Related