630 likes | 643 Views
Cultural Changes. Scott Wright October 2012. “Change is the only constant” “Mudança é a única constante” ~ Heraclitus – Greek Philosopher. What is Cultural Intelligence?. CQ is the capability to function effectively across national, ethnic, and organizational cultures. (Ange and Dyne).
E N D
Cultural Changes Scott Wright October 2012
“Change is the only constant” “Mudança é a única constante” ~ Heraclitus – Greek Philosopher
What is Cultural Intelligence? CQ is the capability to function effectively across national, ethnic, and organizational cultures. (Ange and Dyne)
Why Cultural Intelligence? • 37-70% of international joint ventures fail because of cultural differences (International Joint Ventures: Theory and Practice, Yan and Luo) • 90% of leading executives from 68 countries named cross-cultural leadership as the top management challenge for this century (Economist Intelligence Unit, “CEO Briefing”)
Why Cultural Intelligence? • IBM study of 1,500 CEOs cited: Increased globalization leading to the need to lead across cultures as a challenge to future leaders. Source: IBM, Capitalizing on Complexity: Insights from the Global Chief Executive Officer Study
Hofstede’s Cultural Dimensions • Pesquisa feita com empregados da IBM • Tamanho da amostra 116,000 • 53 paises • Identified 5 dimensions: • Poder/Distancia • Individualismo • Masculinidade/Feminilidade • Incerteza/Evitar • Orientacao a longo prazo
Gapminder.org Video http://www.gapminder.org/videos/200-years-that-changed-the-world-bbc/
Power/Distance (Poder/Distancia) In high PD countries, you would probably only send reports to top management and have closed door meetings with a select few powerful leaders.
Power/Distance (Poder/Distancia) Brazil ___ US 40 China 80 India 77 World Average 53
Individualism (Individualismo) A marketing campaign that emphasized the benefits to the community would likely be well-received in a low IDV country.
Individualism (Individualismo) Brazil ___ US 91 China 20 India 48 World Average 40
Masculinity-Femininity (Masculinidade/Feminilidade) When opening a new office in a high MAS country, you might have better success if you appointed a male employee to lead the team.
Masculinity-Femininity (Masculinidade/Feminilidade) Brazil ___ US 62 China 53 India 56 World Average 47
Uncertainty/Avoidance (Incerteza/Evitar) When discussing a project with a high UAI country, make sure you investigate many options and then present a limited number of choices with very detailed information regarding risks.
Uncertainty/Avoidance (Incerteza/Evitar) Brazil ___ US 46 China 51 India 40 World Average 61
Long Term Orientation(Orientacao a longo prazo) Low LTO countries don’t value tradition as much as others and therefore are likely to be willing to be more innovative.
Long Term Orientation(Orientacao a longo prazo) Brazil ___ US 29 China 118 India 61 World Average 44
Change is difficult • Multiple studies have shown that 70% of the time, when significant change is needed: • People back away • Try but fail miserably • Stop, exhausted, after achieving half of what they want using twice the time and money
Mudança envolve três elementos Guia – intelecto Elefante - motivação A trilha - ambiente
Changes • Change at every level • Individual • Organizational • Societal • For anything to change, someone has to start acting differently.
Knowledge Does Not Change BehaviorConhecimento não altera o comportamento Overweight doctors – médicos obesos Divorced marriage counselors - conselheiros matrimoniais divorciados Corrupt police officers – policiais corruptos Depressed psychologists – Psicologos depressivos
The Rider Riders can think, plan and plot a course for a better future Riders love to contemplate & analyze but the analysis is usually directed at problems rather than bright spots Example - Malnutrition at a Vietnamese village
Decision Paralysis • Retirement options • For every 10 additional options, participation goes down by 2% • 6 jams vs. 24 jams • Shoppers who viewed only 6 jams were 10x more likely to buy • Speed dating • Young adults who met 8 other singles made more “matches” than those who met 20
Motivating the Elephant • Managers initially focus on strategy, structure, culture or systems which lead them to miss the most important issue • Behavior change happens in highly successful situations mostly by speaking to people’s feelings Source: John Kotter in “Heart of Change”
Motivating the Elephant • Most people think change happens in this order: • Analyze, think, change – generally unsuccessful • See, feel, change – is more successful You’re presented with evidence that makes you feel something – speaks to the elephant • Gloves (luvas)
Saving Energy Because the Neighbors Do A program of telling homeowners how their electricity use compared with their neighbors' had the effect of cutting energy consumption by 2%, the same as the impact of an 11% to 20% rate hike, says Hunt Allcott of MIT. The research shows that interventions not based on electricity prices can substantially and cheaply change consumer behavior, Allcott says.
Social vs Market Norms • Subjects asked to use a computer to drag circles from one side of the screen into a square for 5 minutes. • Rewards given for the task were • $5.00 moved 159 circles • $0.50 moved 101 circles • $0.00 moved ___ circles
Social vs Market Norms Senior Citizens Association asked lawyers to offer a discounted price of $30/hr – denied Lawyers then asked to help for free – accepted Daycare imposed fines for parents being late
2 groups asked to solve problem Offered $20 for best time or $5 for fastest 25% No reward structure Only measured for time
2 groups asked to solve problem Offered $20 for best time or $5 for fastest 25% No reward structure Only measured for time Took 3 ½ minutes longer
2 groups asked to solve problem with tacks out of box Offered $20 for best time Or $5 for fastest 25% No reward structure Only measured for time
2 groups asked to solve problem with tacks out of box Offered $20 for best time Or $5 for fastest 25% No reward structure Only measured for time This group was faster
Incentives • If-then rewards work really well for those sorts of tasks, where there is a simple set of rules and a clear destination to go to. • Rewards, tend to narrow our focus and concentrate the mind. • London School Economics looked at 51 studies of pay-for-performance plans – financial incentives can result in a negative impact on performance.
Optimism Bias • We’re more optimistic than realistic • 80% of us have it • Getting along with others • Driving ability • Honesty
Shrinking Change Financial advisors recommend paying down high-interest debt first Make the change small enough that people can easily feel an accomplishment
Shrinking Change Car wash frequent-buyer cards study 19% returned 8 times 34% returned 8 times
Shaping the Path • “Fundamental Attribution Error” • Psychologist Lee Ross • We tend to attribute people’s behavior to the way they are rather than to the situation they are in. • Person driving recklessly • Nurses distributing wrong pills • Errors dropped 47%