260 likes | 1.74k Views
The Influence of Culture & Socialization on Gender Roles. Margaret Mead in Papua New Guinea. Margaret Mead. One of the most famous anthropologists of the 20th century Preeminent speaker of women’s rights and a controversial author Nature or Nurture? PREDOMINANTLY NURTURE.
E N D
The Influence of Culture & Socialization on Gender Roles Margaret Mead in Papua New Guinea
Margaret Mead • One of the most famous • anthropologists of the 20th century • Preeminent speaker of women’s • rights and a controversial author • Nature or Nurture? • PREDOMINANTLY NURTURE
Margaret Mead • Traveled to Papua New Guinea • 1931 to determine the extent to • which gender roles were the • product of genes or culture • - Published her findings in her book Sex and Temperament in Three Primitive Societies
Mead’s Findings • - Found a different pattern of M/F behavior in each of the cultures she studied • All different from gender role expectations in the United States at that time. • 3 Major Tribes Studied • 1. Arapesh • 2. Mundugumor • 3. Tchambuli
Arapesh • - When Mead arrived in 1931, the people had no official • name for themselves. • - She called them Arapesh • - Arapesh = the tribe’s word for “person” • Found that both males and females were conditioned • to be cooperative, unaggressive and empathetic. • Both men and women behaved more like what we • would consider feminine behavior
Mundugumor • More Aggressive tribe living along the Yuat River • In Contrast to the Arapesh, the Mundgumor people • socialized their youth to be more “masculine” • - aggressive • - ruthless • - relatively unresponsive to needs of others
A Mundugumor mother holding her baby rather indifferent to her own child. Mundugumor
Tchambuli • Tchambuli contrasted previous two • Arapesh = “standardized females” • Mundugmor = “standardized males” • Tchambuli = opposite of “western idea of gender” • Female • Dominant • Impersonal • Aggressive • Male • Dependent • Submissive
Tchambuli A Tchambuli mother holding her child. Tchambuli women tend to take on the more “masculine” role in tribal society
Conclusions • According to Mead: human nature is flexible enough to rule out biological determination of gender roles • Gender roles are NOT fixed at birth • Individuals can be fairly easily socialized into the gender of the opposite sex You inherit your sex, but you learn your gender
Conclusions “Male and female personalities are socially produced.” • Margaret Mead • American Anthropologist