120 likes | 680 Views
Background. Biliary
E N D
1. Chronic Acalculous Cholecystitisthe Cariboo Memorial Hospital Experience Jeff Demetrick
Dan Brosseuk
2. Biliary type pain in the face of negative USS
Differential Diagnosis
False negative USS vs UGI pathology vs other pathology
Spectrum of investigations include: UGI series, endoscopy CT Scan, HIDA scan, IVP
Pts with strong clinical suspicion and no other pathology identified are offered the option of Conservative Management vs Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy
Previous investigators have predicated treatment options on the results of HIDA scan and CCK stimulated ejection fractions
3. Retrospective Chart Review and Telephone Survey
All pts operated on for Acalculous Cholecystitis at CMH April 1997 - Sept 2001 were reviewed
All surgeries performed by 2 surgeons
Telephone Survey by non-surgical staff to assess pt satisfaction
Where pt outcomes could not be fully assessed by Hospital and Office chart review - questioning was included in telephone survey
4. Demographics
755 cholecystectomies performed in study period
88 pts included in study (12% of cholecystectomies)
15 Male : 73 Female
Age range 19 - 78 (mean age 42 yrs)
69 pts (78%) performed as daycare
19 pts admitted with avg length of stay 2.8 days
Avg length of stay for all pts 1.3 days
5. Symptom duration
15 Acute (17%) - unremitting symptoms of less than 2 weeks duration
69 Chronic (78%)
4 Acute on Chronic (5%)
Other Investigations
36 gastroscopies, 12 had 2 or more USS 5 barium UGI, 2 HIDA scan, 1 CT scan, 3 colonoscopies, 1 IVP
Surgery Performed
71 Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy (81%)
12 Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy + cholangiogram (14%)
5 Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy + other procedure (6%)
1 posterior repair, 1 lysis of adhesions, 1 oophorectomy, 1 appendectomy, 1 foot ganglion
6. Pathology
61 Chronic Cholecystitis (69%)
10 Chronic Cholecystitis + cholelithiasis (11%)
2 Subacute Cholecystitis (2%)
1 Acute Cholecystitis (1%)
2 Acute on Chronic Cholecystitis (2%)
2 Cholesterolosis (2%)
1 Cholesterolosis + Chronic Cholecystitis (1%)
1 Thick Gallbladder wall (1%)
1 Sludge (1%)
7 Normal Gallbadder (8%)
7.
0 conversions to open procedure
0 intra-operative complications
Minor 9%
2 exacerbation of diarrhea
3 wound infections
1 nausea
1 port site bleed
1 port site hernia
Major 2%
1 post anesthetic Guillane Barre Syndrome
1 cystic duct stump leak
8. 7 pts lost to follow-up (91% available for follow-up)
36 (44%) very satisfied
42 (52%) satisfied
3 (4%) not satisfied
9. All 3 not satisfied had pathology: 3 chronic cholecystitis - 1 with stones
2 had complications - 1 port site hernia, 1 cystic duct stump leak
Of the 7 pts with Normal Pathology
3 very satisfied
3 satisfied
1 lost to followup
Both pts with Major Complications had pathological gallbladders
1 was satisfied and 1 not satisfied
10. Acalculous Cholecystitis is a pathological disease which can be accurately diagnosed clinically based on careful history and physical exam after excluding other pathology
Comparing our results to the literature (ie Chen et al - Surgery Oct 01) other diagnostic modalities such as HIDA-CCK do not increase diagnostic accuracy