110 likes | 215 Views
Combining marketed coursebooks and teacher-developed materials: reasons, possibilities and implications. Darío Luis Banegas D.L.Banegas@warwick.ac.uk. My CAR-CLIL project. A secondary school in southern Argentina How to incorporate curricular content in the EFL lesson ?
E N D
Combining marketed coursebooks and teacher-developed materials: reasons, possibilities and implications Darío Luis Banegas D.L.Banegas@warwick.ac.uk
My CAR-CLIL project • A secondaryschool in southern Argentina • Howtoincorporate curricular content in the EFL lesson? • Language-driven CLIL • Teachers’ principlesforevaluating, adapting and developingmaterials.
Teachers’ perceptions • Context-free curriculum • Lack of systematicy in topic treatment • Unchallenging activities (TASK) • Mismatch between language ability and cognitive challenge • Good for planning • Good for structuring grammar and vocabulary input
Students’ perceptions • Demotivating topics • Predictable • The book as a straitjacket • Unchallenging activities • Poor listening and speaking opportunities • Good for grammar and vocabulary learning
Students’ voices Student 1:Lo que hicimos la clase pasada fue más dinámico, más aporte nuestro. [What we did the last lesson was more dynamic, with more contributions from us.] Student2:Claro y además a los profesores aunque no les guste no se pueden salir de eso. Nostienenquedareso. [True and besides the teachers, even if they don’t like it, they can’t teach outside the coursebook. They have to teach us that.]
Darío: ¿Cómo la vieron a A. enseñando con este material? [How did you find A. teaching with her materials?] Student 1:Y hace al maestro mucho más participativo porque sino agarra el libro, te dice lo que hay que hacer y cada uno con su libro.[And that makes the teacher much more participatory because otherwise she just grabs the book, she tells you what to do and each of us does it individually.]
Teacher-developedmaterials: principles • Negotiation of topics, sources and activities • Authentic audio-visual sources • Shortness • Comprehensible input • Content relevance and complexity • Transferability potential
Students’ feedback • Different • Responding to their needs and context • Complex • Encourage students’ and teacher’s participation • No good for learning new grammar
Students’ suggestions • A coursebook for grammar learning. • Teacher’s materials for engaging topics and skills work through authentic sources. • A combination for more dynamic and participatory lessons.
Thank you! D.L.Banegas@warwick.ac.uk