120 likes | 193 Views
2012 API Cooperative Testing Preliminary Report on Compressive Strength. Westminster, Colorado June 12, 2012. 2012 Protocol. Test Protocol in 2012 matched previous years: Cubes: 100F 8 hours 140F 8 hours 100F 24 hours UCA: 100F 8 hours 100F 24 hours Time to 50 and 500 psi
E N D
2012 API Cooperative Testing Preliminary Report on Compressive Strength Westminster, Colorado June 12, 2012
2012 Protocol • Test Protocol in 2012 matched previous years: • Cubes: • 100F 8 hours • 140F 8 hours • 100F 24 hours • UCA: • 100F 8 hours • 100F 24 hours • Time to 50 and 500 psi • Changes to protocol in 2012 • As in 2010, eliminated 20 minute pre-conditioning requirement • Eliminated the requirement to calculate cube density • Continue to request pictures of load frames utilized • Further analysis to be included in Final CS Report in New Orleans • CS results tied to load frame group: Manual vs Digital • Evaluation of UCA Transit Time • Service Companies and other vs. Cement Plants • Load frame verification using low strength Burst Disks at known failure values
Compressive Strength Comparison 2010 vs. 2012 (preliminary data)
2012 UCA and Cube CSsorted by value (preliminary data)
2000 to 2012 UCA vs Cubes Average Compressive Strength (preliminary data)
CV Comparison 2000 to 2012 (preliminary data)
2012 Preliminary Conclusions • High variability continues with 8 hr cube test. • Initial CVs for all test categories continues to creep up. • Historical relationships between cubes and UCA holds true. • Good response to request for load frame pictures will permit further analysis. • Let’s see what full data set reveals after more in depth analysis.
Thank you! Comments and Questions?