370 likes | 400 Views
Dive into the energy sector with focused insights on Halliburton & Valero. Business, financial, and valuation analyses for informed investment decisions. Sector performance, recommendations & risk factors discussed.
E N D
ENERGY SECTOR Mike Essig Brian Geiser Chris Gagnon
TABLE OF CONTENTS SECTOR OVERVIEW HALLIBURTON VALERO ENERGY CORPORATION PATTERSON UTI ENTERPRISE PRODUCTS PARTNERS L.P. RECOMMENDATION
Sector Weights ENERGY SECTOR ALLOCATION • Sector Weights • Currently 5.61% of the S&P 500 • SIM Portfolio Weight of 6.68% • Overweight by 1.07% • Industries • Energy Equipment and Services • Oil, Gas, and Consumable Fuels • SIM Portfolio • Halliburton (HAL): 2.24% of portfolio • Enterprise Products Partners LP (EPD): 1.09% of portfolio • Valero Energy Corp (VLO): 3.34% of portfolio
Sector Return TTM RETURN ENERGY SECTOR RETURN • Three Month Price Change • -5.88% • Three Month Dividends Reinvested at Index • -5.17% • TTM Price Change • -0.1669% • TTM Dividends Reinvested at Index • 2.81% • Business Cycle • Energy Sector performs best in the late stages of the business cycle • Macro Analysis • Drilling productivity is forecasted to increase with increased supply from the U.S. and other nations THREE MONTH RETURN Source: Bloomberg
Sector Recommendation ENERGY SECTOR STOCK RECOMMENDATION • Keep Sector Overweighted • Change previous recommendation from neutral to overweight • Sector as a whole is underperforming BUT • Certain stocks are outperforming their benchmark and the S&P 500 • Risks to Overweight • Decline in oil prices • Currently entering the late stage of economic expansion • Potential for overproduction from U.S. and other countries will force decline in WTI and Brent BUY HOLD SELL
Business Analysis • Founded in 1919 • Multinational company that provides services and products for the energy sector • Operates in over 70 countries, over 50,000 employees, and owns hundreds of subsidiaries • Second largest company in it’s industry (Schlumberger)
Business Analysis • Operates in the Energy Equipment and Services Industry • Two Segments: • Completion and Production • Drilling and Evaluation • 14 Product Service Lines • Completion and Production larger: 63% of revenue • Competitive Advantage: New technology for evaluation and drilling; Most horsepower for pressure pumping (fracking) • Over 50% of revenue was earned in the United States
Financial Analysis • Since 2015, revenue has been on the rise • Growth Drivers: • Rising oil prices • Large increase in drilling in North America, Latin America, and the Middle East • Increase in pressure pumping capital expenditures (largest in market)
Financial Analysis HAL vs WTI 1 Year Historical Graph
Valuation Analysis • Expensive historically • Higher than average industry growth predicted
Valuation Analysis • 10 Year DCF • Current Price: $46.94 • Target Price: $ 60.68 • Implied Upside: 29.3%
Valuation Analysis • Growth: • Increase in Pressure Pumping services • More wells drilled than completed • Increase in Revenue per Rig • Increase in Completion BUY • Risks to Recommendation: • Oil price movement • Political instability • Government Regulation • Disasters and Accidents that cause fines and loss of capital • Alternative Energy
Business Overview • The Valero Energy Corporation (VLO), is an international manufacturer and marketer of transportation fuels and other petrochemical products. • 15 petroleum refineries with a combined throughput capacity of approximately 3.1 million barrels per day • 11 ethanol plants with a combined production capacity of approximately 1.45 billion gallons per year. • As of January 1, 2017 VLO operates with three business segments • Refining: $90,657MM (96.5%) • Ethanol $3,500MM (3.7%) • VLO Energy Partners, LP (VLP) $452MM (0.5%)
Business Analysis • Refiner Segment Drivers • Demand for Oil • Gasoline & Distillate Margins • Throughput Volumes • Biofuel Credit Cost • Ethanol Segment Drivers • Ethanol Prices • Corn Prices • Co-product Prices • Production Volumes • VLP Segment Drivers • Increased Throughput Volume
Financial Analysis • Revenue and Margins • YOY growth mostly negative • Gross Margin mixed • Operating Margin Mixed • Return Metrics • ROA 9.2%; above mean • ROE: 19.3%; at mean • ROIC: 14.6%; below mean • Debt Metrics • Trend positively compared to peers • Debt/EV, Debt/EBITDA on low end of peers • EBITDA & EBIT to Interest Expense high in class
DCF Analysis • ASSUMPTIONS • Discount Rate • 11.25% • Volatile Stock Price • Cyclical sales • Growth Rate • 3.00% • Conservative rate • Reflect volatility in sales
Valuation Analysis • Implied Price by EV • Resulted in higher valuations • $99.03-$130.18 mean range • Implied Price by Market • Moderate valuations • $82.52-$101.97 mean range
Recommendation • Recommendation: HOLD • Historical stock performance has been positive • Potential downside only -5.96% • 03/30/18 to 04/16/18 VLO increased from $92.27 to $105.49 • Risks and Concerns • Change in supply & demand of oil • Fluctuations in oil prices • Volatile refining margins • Compliance with & changes in environmental laws • Lack of sustainable competitive advantage
PATTERSON UTI • Patterson-UTI (PTEN) is an oil drilling company headquartered in Houston, Texas formed from the merger of Patterson Energy and UTI Energy in 2001. • The company specializes primarily in on-shore contract drilling and pressure pumping in the United States and Canada, especially in the Permian, Appalachian, and Mid-Con Basins. • Along with its drilling and pumping services, Patterson-UTI is a provider of drilling rental equipment and technology. • Fracking has been critical for revenues*** Patterson-UTI Contract Drilling Directional Drilling Pressure Pumping
PTEN Business Analysis IT’S ALL ABOUT THE https://www.statista.com/statistics/326762/revenue-of-top-energy-services-and-equipment-land-drilling-companies-global/ http://www.macrotrends.net/1369/crude-oil-price-history-chart https://www.vanguardngr.com/2018/04/oil-prices-rise-due-lower-u-s-drilling-activity/
Financial Analysis Morningstar
Enterprise Products Partners specializes in the gathering, treating, processing, transportation and storage of crude oil, natural gas, and petrochemical products • The company operates throughout North America • Marine transportation services are provided primarily in the United States • “Master Limited Partnership” - No corporate income tax paid Stock Rating Current Stock Price: $24.46 Target Price: $20.45 Target Price Change: -16.4% Dividend Yield: 6.63% Recommendation: SELL Key Statistics 52 Week Price Range: $23.10-$29.51 Market Capitalization: $55.936B Diluted Shares Outstanding: 2.16B Beta: 1.07 2017 Revenue: $29.2B 2017 Net Income: $2.8B 2017 EPS: $1.30 EPD Onshore NG Pipelines & Services NGL Pipelines and Services Onshore CO Pipelines & Services Offshore Pipelines & Services Petrochemical
EPD Business Analysis [Projected] [Projected]
Financial Analysis Morningstar
Operating Margin Concerns (again…) Troubling Decrease
Portfolio Recommendation • SECTOR WEIGHTING • Remain overweight in Energy Sector • BUY 100 bps of Halliburton • HOLD Valero Energy Corporation • SELL 109 bps of Enterprise Products