120 likes | 253 Views
STATISTICS STATISTIQUE CANADA CANADA. An update on the development of Canada’s Market Basket Measure October 2001. Background. Canada has no official measure of poverty
E N D
STATISTICS STATISTIQUE CANADA CANADA An update on thedevelopment of Canada’s Market Basket MeasureOctober 2001
Background • Canada has no official measure of poverty • The Canadian Federal, Provincial and Territorial Ministers of Social Services asked a working group to develop an alternative to commonly used measures • Such a measure should be: • credible in its approach to poverty measurement • easy to understand • sensitive to geographic cost differences • reflect changes in costs rather than changes in income
General Approach • The basket is composed of goods and services to allow a family to • eat a nutritious diet • buy clothing for work and social occasions • house themselves in their community • satisfy basic transportation needs for work, school, shopping and participation in community activities • pay for other necessary expenses • Prices are based on a reference family of 2 adults and 2 children, and adjusted for other family sizes • The cost of the basket is compared to an MBM disposable income, i.e. income after tax minus “non-discretionary” expenditures
Food component Construction of the food component • Items and quantities were taken from Health Canada’s Nutritious Food Basket for a reference family of 2 adults and 2 children • Monthly pricing of food is already carried out for calculation of the Consumer Price Index • Preliminary estimates have been developed for 40 cities
Clothing component Construction of the food component • Items and quantities from the Acceptable Living Level list of clothing and footwear prepared by the Winnipeg Social Planning Council • Monthly pricing of clothing and footwear is already carried out for calculation of the Consumer Price Index • Preliminary estimates have been developed for 16 cities
Shelter component • Rent: average of median 2 bedroom unit and median 3 bedroom unit • utilities • other amenities Sources of data • Census of Population gives rent, as well as heat, electricity and water costs for very detailed geographic areas. Only units not in need of major repairs will be used • Inclusion of fridge, stove, washer, dryer varies across the country • LFS rent supplement provides provincial rates • The cost of purchasing the appliance comes from 2nd income decile spending, amoritized over the lifetime of the appliance
Transportation component • This covers basic transportation needs for work, school, shopping, and participation in community activities • There are two independent procedures for pricing transportation component: • Urban areas served by public transit - annual price of two adult monthly passes • All other areas - the amortized cost of a used vehicle, plus the annual cost of operating the vehicle
Other Expenses • A multiplier approach is used for other expenses • Actual expenditures by the 2nd income decile families • Express expenditues on other expenses as a fraction of expenditures on food, clothing and transportation • Cost of other expenses is that fraction times the basket cost of food, clothing and transportation
MBM Disposable Income • Income that families actually have to purchase MBM commodities • Subtract from total income • federal, provincial and territorial income taxes • employee portion of payroll taxes • union and professional dues • child care costs to allow both parents (or a lone parent) to work • child support payments made by non-custodial parents • out-of-pocket costs of medically prescribed drugs, dental and vision care • Total cost of MBM basket is compared with MBM disposable income to determine MBM low income status
Equivalence Scale • Components of the MBM are based on a reference family of 2 adults and 2 children • Baskets for other family sizes could be specified and priced, but it is easier to use an equivalence scale • MBM uses the same scale as Statistics Canada uses for the 0.5 median measure of low income • 1.0 for the first person • 0.4 for the second person, regardless of age • 0.4 for additonal adults (16+) • 0.3 for additional children
Updating the contents of the basket • Society’s idea of a reasonable standard of living evolves over time • Contents of the MBM should be reviewed on a five year cycle • MBM components and rates would be monitored • unusual behaviour could trigger an earlier review
Status of the MBM • Attempts have been made at estimating MBM components • Comparison with actual spending patterns • Food, shelter and transportation components look promising • Clothing basket specification needs more work • Some outstanding issues • geographic coverage • subsidized rent • CPI sample is designed to measure change, not level • Ongoing contact to refine specifications • No firm date for publication of results