280 likes | 378 Views
Dive into the Achievement Goal Theory in sports, exploring mastery and ego orientations, motivational climates, and cognitive evaluation theory. Learn how goal orientation impacts motivation and success beliefs in athletes of all ages. Discover the influence of different factors on individual motivation and performance in sports.
E N D
Motivation in Sport September 12, 2002
Theory-Based Approaches to Motivation • Competence Motivation (Harter, 1978, 1981) • Expectancy-Value (Eccles & Harold, 1993) • Achievement Goal (Nicholls, 1984) • Cognitive Evaluation (Deci, 1975; Deci & Ryan, 1985) • Sport Commitment (Scanlan et al., 1993) • Attribution (Weiner, 1979)
Achievement Goal Theory (Nicholls, 1984) • Developmentally based • Key component = How does an individual define success? • Individuals have different orientations for success: mastery & ego
Mastery Orientation • Success = improvement • Focus is on improving ability • Self-referent • Premium is placed on learning • High interest/curiosity in task, appropriate level of challenge, & effort • Sometimes called Task Orientation
Ego Orientation • Success = being better than others; winning • Focuses on proving ability • Other-referent • Low interest, low curiosity, low challenge level • Sometimes called Social Comparison Orientation
Achievement Goal Theory • Goal orientation is not enough to determine motivation (the two are orthogonal) • 2nd key factor is a person’s perception of their ability (similarity with previous two theories) • Motivation = Goal + Perceived Orientation Ability
Interaction Effect • High Ego + High Perceived Ability = ???? • High Ego + Low Perceived Ability = ???? • High Mastery + High PA = ???? • High Mastery + Low PA = ????
Research on Achievement Goals:Beliefs of Academic Success • Mastery Beliefs for Success • Working hard, co-operation, interest in activity, trying different strategies • Ego Beliefs for Success • Being smart, knowing how to impress teacher, trying to do better than others
Beliefs for Success in Sport(Duda & Nicholls, 1989) • Mastery Beliefs • Hard work, motivation • Ego Beliefs • Talent/skill • Knowing how to cheat
Enjoyment in Sport (Duda & Nicholls, 1989) • Mastery = more enjoyment, regardless of outcome • Ego = less enjoyment, regardless of outcome
Task Difficulty (Nicholls, 1988) • Mastery Orientation • Select more challenging, appropriate tasks • Ego Orientation • Tend to select easier tasks
Other Factors Affected • Injury Rehabilitation • Belief of Sport’s Purpose • Belief in Legitimacy of Illicit Acts
Developmental Changes in Goal Orientation • 4-6 years • Don’t distinguish between effort & ability • 6-7 years • Concept of difficulty develops • 7-9 years • Effort is cause of outcomes
Developmental Changes in Goal Orientation • 9-10 years • Success = ability OR effort • 10-12 years • Ability & effort fully differentiated • Largest decline in youth sport participation--why???
Motivational Climate • How is a person’s achievement situation structured? • What kind of goals are encouraged? • Performance vs. Learning
Performance Climate Encourages ego orientation Success relates to others Learning Climate Encourages mastery orientation Success relates to previous abilities Motivational Climate
How Is Climate Designed? • What is the reward structure & FB? • How are practice sessions designed? • How is performance evaluated? • What is the reaction to failure? • Who is in charge of this?
Performance Climate • Concern is outcome-based • Autocratic • Increases in desire to use superficial learning techniques • Sport examples?
Learning Climate • Concern with deep learning • Allows for self-monitor/self-selection • Encourages challenging goals • If extrinsic rewards are a controlling factor, what do we choose to do?
Perceptions of Learning Climate(Nicholls, 1992; Ames, 1992) • Contributes to effort-related success beliefs • Enjoyment • Intrinsic Motivation • Anxiety Levels • Perceptions of Competence • Peer relationships
Optimal Setting • Extrinsic rewards? • Feedback schedules? • Personal choice/challenge • Attitude toward failure • Practice & repetitions • Self-testing • Goal orientation still will impact
Cognitive Evaluation Theory(Deci, 1975; Deci & Ryan, 1985) • Intrinsic Motivation • challenge, skill improvement, fun • Extrinsic Motivation • Social status, money, medals, approval • Used to understand relationship between IM & EM and the effects of external rewards on motivation in general
Cognitive Evaluation Theory • Assumes we have two basic needs: • Competence • Self-determination • Theory makes predications regarding how to facilitate these two needs • Many things can influence
Processes Affecting IM:Controlling Vs. Informational • Controlling = Individual’s locus of causality • Internal or External • If controlling aspect is high (external), then rewards are seen as controlling the behavior--are extrinsic • Behavior is then no longer self-determined • Old Man story
Processes Affecting IM:Controlling Vs. Informational • Informational = affects feelings of competence • Events providing positive information should be rewarding and increase IM • Effect will depend on meaning of reward to the athlete (Ex.: cash prize for top five places)