1 / 8

Fair Compromise in a Morally Complex World

Fair Compromise in a Morally Complex World. Assigned Amount (Per Capita) =.  Global GHG Cap Commit. Period. = Reduced Baseline Emission Intensity  Ex Post GDP. Global GHG Cap Commit. Period. = Grandfathering  GDP Growth  R%. Assigned Amounts as Natural Resource. Apéritif.

carla-wynn
Download Presentation

Fair Compromise in a Morally Complex World

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Fair Compromise in a Morally Complex World

  2. Assigned Amount(Per Capita) =  Global GHG Cap Commit. Period =Reduced Baseline Emission Intensity Ex Post GDP Global GHG Cap Commit. Period = Grandfathering  GDP Growth  R% Assigned Amounts as Natural Resource Apéritif. • Transfers are resource transfers not to be compared with develop. assistance • Resource Interpretation is not tied to ex ante determination of AAs; e.g.

  3. Per Capita Grandfathering 1995 population shares 1995 energy emission shares Economies in USA LDCs India Transition USA India 5% Rest of Rest of 6% 4% EU 7% 21% 16% Annex I non-Annex I 7% 9% 10% MENA China Economies LDCs 5% 14% in Transition 22% 17% China MENA EU Rest of Rest of 21% 6% 13% Annex I non-Annex I 9% 10% Annex I: 22% non-Annex I: 78% Annex I: 61% non-Annex I: 39% Le Repas. Distributing a ‘Cake’ in a Morally Ambiguous Context

  4. + wPC PCk wGF GFk GFk= k’sGrandfathering share PCk= k’s Per Capita share A ‘Mixed’ Compromise Solution Ck= Compromise share of Party k Ck= wGF + wPC = 1

  5. Social Preference Score Weightings I

  6. Social Preference Score Weightings II

  7. Per Capita Grandfathering ¾ ¼ USA Economies in 9% Transition India 9% 13% EU LDCs 8% 18% Rest of Annex I 9% MENA Rest of China 5% non-Annex I 20% 10% Non-Annex I: 78%Annex I: 22% Non-Annex I: 39%Annex I: 61% Preference Score Annex I: 31% non-Annex I: 69%

  8. PP-Principle Polluter Pays Principle Digestif ‘Back to the Present’ PA-Principle Polluter Acts Principle PAF-Principle Polluter Acts First Principle

More Related