120 likes | 336 Views
Change Management. Lecture 4 What changes in organizations. Scale of Change. Not all change is the same magnitude First-order change: Incremental They maintain and develop the organization E.g. continuous and smaller changes to the structure of an organisation Second-order change:
E N D
Change Management Lecture 4 What changes in organizations
Scale of Change • Not all change is the same magnitude • First-order change: • Incremental • They maintain and develop the organization • E.g. continuous and smaller changes to the structure of an organisation • Second-order change: • Transformational • Fundamentally changes the way an organization functions • E.g. downsizing
Between First and Second Order Change • Mid-range changes • Overcomes inertia but is not revolutionary • Avoids the alarming (high stress) implications of large scale change • “tectonic change” • Destroy outdated elements but keep the good ones • Punctuated equilibrium • Long periods of stability followed by short bursts of change and instability
Nadler and Tushman Incremental Discontinuous Anticipatory Reactive Tuning Reorientation (frame bending) Adaptation Re-creation (frame breaking)
Latent energy • According to Frohman, not enough attention has been paid to the overall impact on organizations of small-scale changes and the role of personal initiatives • Technological leads are short-lived • What is most important is people who are able to identify relevant, innovative (local) organizational changes • Managers tend to want to go for the Big Bang theory of change and ignore front line performers • Vaill calls this unlocking the ‘latent energy’ of the organization
Local routines • Feldman • Routines are continuously changing b/c: • Past outcomes fall short of aspiration levels • Performance exceeds aspiration levels • Different people place their own interpretations and actions on how a routine should occur • Therefore, routines evolve over time and are not stable and rigid but flexible • Do we buy this argument? What are the implications?
Coping with hyper-competition • Strategies • Delayering • Networks/alliances • Outsourcing • Disaggregation • Empowerment • Flexible work groups • Short-term staffing • Reduction of internal and external boundaries • Questions • How prevalent are these practices? • Are some practices more prevalent than others? • Are old routines replaced, modified or co-exist?
Downsizing • Key points • Common – millions downsized every year • Does not necessarily lead to increased productivity (2 in every 3 cases) • Can be an excessively costly exercise ($7K per $30K employee) • Key challenges: • employee retention, survivor syndrome, communication, due diligence, cultural adjustment
Technological change There are a variety of new technologies being used, for example: • CRM, ERP, RFIDs, BPR, Six Sigma • Key challenges • Piloting, integration, timing, technology choice, communication, training,
Mergers and acquisitions • Key points • Many rationales for acquisitions • Usually to achieve growth and/or synergy • Key challenges • Cost savings, cultural adjustment, due diligence, employee retention, power structure, communication
Questions • How do you approach the paradox of change? • Is the risk of failing less risky than not changing? Is this a good assumption for all changes that you undertake? What criteria can you develop to assess this balance? • Traditional organizational practices • When should they be replaced? Retained? Modified? • Are you more open to transformational or incremental change? Why? • How aware have you been to sense-making routines? How might knowledge of sense-making assist you?
Nestle Case • List examples of first and second order change in the Nestle case. • B-L emphasizes the need for incremental change – is this what he has done? • Explore the differences and similarities between his views about change and yours