240 likes | 263 Views
Truman, Hirohito, and the Bomb. Background. August 6, 1945 an American B-29 bomber, the Enola Gay, dropped an atomic bomb on Hiroshima , Japan. – 70,000 people died August 9, 1945 another atomic bomb was dropped on Nagasaki . – 60,000 died. Intentional Bombing of Civilians.
E N D
Background • August 6, 1945 an American B-29 bomber, the Enola Gay, dropped an atomic bomb on Hiroshima, Japan. – 70,000 people died • August 9, 1945 another atomic bomb was dropped on Nagasaki. – 60,000 died
Intentional Bombing of Civilians • Germany, Japan, America, and the British had all intentionally bombed civilians • Over 100,000 Japanese had died from American bombs on Tokyo • Why are atomic bombs a different situation??? • Unknown short and long term effects
Truman: “The Most Terrible Bomb” • President Roosevelt starts Manhattan Project • General Groves in command • J. Robert Oppenheimer is head scientist
Roosevelt Dies • President Roosevelt dies on April 12, 1945 • Harry Truman becomes President and finally learns about the bomb
Germany Surrenders • The bomb was not ready when Germany unconditionally surrendered on May 7, 1945 • Truman authorizes the Interim Committee to make recommendations regarding the use of the bomb
Interim Committee • Committee recommends using the bomb when ready. • Is against giving Japan a warning or demonstrating the bomb • Desired to shock the Japanese into surrender • The target would be a war factory surrounded by workers’ houses • Used as a warning to the Soviets
Truman Meets Advisors • Truman’s question • Expected casualties for a land invasion of Japan? • Estimated 200,000 American casualties possible 50,000 deaths
Potsdam Meeting • Truman, Churchill and Stalin meet in mid July of 1945 • Truman wants the Soviets to join war against the Japanese. • During the meeting, Truman gets message that bomb was successfully tested
Truman decides • 2 bombs were ready and 2 more on the way • Hiroshima and Nagasaki chosen because normal bombing has already destroyed several other cities. • These were not major industrial cities
Scientists Oppose • Small group of scientists who worked on the Manhattan project circulated a petition to oppose nuclear bombs. They were afraid of a post war nuclear arms race with the Soviet Union.
July 26, 1945 (my birthdate, but not the same year) • The Allies called for the “unconditional surrender of Japan” • Japan must also form a new government • What about the Emperor? • No mention of an atomic bomb, or the Soviets entering the war • Japan would face “prompt and utter destruction”
Japan’s Situation • Navy almost completely destroyed • Best pilots killed • Armies scattered and isolated • Shortages of food and oil • American bombs killed over 200,000 • Soldiers die by suicide charges • Kamikaze pilots
What to do? What to do? • Prime Minister Suzuki looks to end war • Many government and military leaders oppose surrender • Plans were made to protect against an American land invasion • Japanese hoped they could force America to end war on terms more beneficial to Japan
Emperor Hirohito • Hirohito was a sacred figure in Japanese society. • Stayed away from making any decisions regarding war • By early 1945, Hirohito had believed war should end
Make a decision!!! • August 6 Hiroshima is bombed • Japan doesn’t surrender • August 9 Nagasaki bombed and Soviets declare war against Japan • Japanese leaders agree on only 1 thing – The Emperor must remain at all costs • Prime Minister asks the Emperor what to do- Japan must surrender
Finally • Suzuki send surrender notice to Allies stating that the Emperor must remain • America accepts surrender but that Hirohito must submit authority to supreme commander of occupying forces (General Douglas MacArthur)
Other choices?? • Truman defended his decision to use the atomic bombs arguing that it saved American lives. • However, Truman’s advisors seemed to focus on only 2 choices – atomic bombs or land invasion • Were there other options???
Option #1 • Continue the conventional bombings and blockade • Truman could have relied on continuing to bomb Japanese cities combined with a blockade to wear down the Japanese
Option #2 • Demonstrate the atomic bomb • Truman could have shown Japanese leaders just how destructive the bomb really is
Option #3 • Wait for the Russians • Truman could have waited for Russians to declare war and invade. • Invasion and occupation by both Russians and American would have more effect on Japan than atomic bomb
Option #4 • Negotiate Peace • Truman could have discussed peace terms instead of refusing to consider anything but unconditional surrender
Option #5 • Keep the Emperor • The Japanese leaders might have decided to surrender if Truman assured them that America would not abolish the position of emperor or put Hirohito on trial for war crimes
Option # 6 • Use the atomic bombs