1 / 41

Life After the Perfect Storm — Selling Privately Owned Businesses in Today’s Market

Life After the Perfect Storm — Selling Privately Owned Businesses in Today’s Market. Bill Eastwood Doering & Eastwood, Ltd May 16, 2003. Overview -- Long Term M&A Market.

Download Presentation

Life After the Perfect Storm — Selling Privately Owned Businesses in Today’s Market

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Life After the Perfect Storm — Selling Privately Owned Businesses in Today’s Market Bill Eastwood Doering & Eastwood, Ltd May 16, 2003

  2. Overview -- Long Term M&A Market • The U.S. M&A Market Peaked in Terms of Transaction Value in 1999 at $1.4 Trillion, After Eight Consecutive Years of Unprecedented Growth •  Virtually All of the Drivers of M&A Activity Were Operating During the Latter Half of the 1990s Source: Mergerstat Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  3. Overview -- Long Term M&A Market  Middle Market M&A Activity May Be Somewhat More Resilient Than Large Deal Activity Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  4. The Perfect Storm -- Obvious Parts November 2000 — November 2002 • Poor Earnings • Rapidly Falling Stock Prices • No Longer Currency for Acquisitions • Recession/Slow Growth Economy • Excess Capacity • Geo-political Events • 9/11 • Iraq • Korea Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  5. The Perfect Storm -- Obvious Parts November 2000 — November 2002 • Loss of Credibility in Financial Statements and Corporate Management • Attitude That Acquisitions Do Not Increase Stockholder Value • World Com — MCI • Tyco — CIT • ATT — TCI Cable • Qwest — U.S. West • Lucent — Ascend • AOL — Time Warner Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  6. The Perfect Storm -- Less Obvious Parts November 2000 — November 2002 • Falling Interest Rates and Stock Prices Make Returns From Proceeds of a Business Sale Much Less Attractive • Entrepreneurs Evaluating Sale of Business Need Proceeds to Last the Remainder of Their Life • In 1999 Projecting 15% Stock Returns and 7.5% Fixed Income Returns, Lifestyle and Income Level Needs Were Much Easier to Satisfy Than In 2002 With Negative Stock Market Returns and 1% Money Market Rates • For Private Equity Funds, the Public Market Is No Longer a Reliable Exit Strategy Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  7. The Perfect Storm -- Less Obvious Parts November 2000 — November 2002 • Banks’ Risk Tolerance For Acquisition Financing Reduced • Average Equity Requirements to Obtain Financing Increased From 25% to 40-50% of the Purchase Price • Most Private Equity Acquisition Criteria Is Based on Return on Equity (“ROE”) of 25-35% Example: Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  8. The Perfect Storm -- Less Obvious Parts November 2000 — November 2002 Source: Leveraged Buyouts Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  9. The Perfect Storm -- Less Obvious Parts November 2000 — November 2002 • For a Private Equity Group with a 25% Hurdle Rate, Reduced Bank Financing Make the ROE Below the Threshold, Now a Deal is Not Doable Without Price Adjustments or Owner Financing EBIT = Earnings Before Interest and Taxes Interest at 7.5% PBT = Profit Before Tax PAT = Profit After Tax at 37% Tax Rate ROE = Return on Equity = PAT/Equity EBITDA = Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation and Amortization Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  10. The Perfect Storm -- Less Obvious Parts November 2000 - November 2002 • Owners’ Failure to Accept Current Value of Business • During 1998-2000, Owner Had an Offer or a Friend in the Business Had an Offer 8-10 Times EBIT • Today’s Market 5-7 Times EBIT for Owner’s Industry • With Earnings Down 10%, Owner’s Business Only Worth 60% of Perceived Prior Value • Even Though Business Fundamentally Continues to Degenerate, Owner Waits Until the Market Returns to Prior Valuation Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  11. The Perfect Storm -- Less Obvious Parts November 2000 - November 2002 • Principal Types Of Businesses Sold During the Perfect Storm • Outstanding Business With a Competitive Advantage and a Growth Story • Businesses in Industries That Benefited From Consolidation (Costs and Pricing Power) • Banks • Cable Television • Oil and Gas • Distress — Must Sell Business Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  12. The Perfect Storm -- Less Obvious Parts November 2000 - November 2002 • Owners Who Accepted Realistic Prices • Buyers Stretch to Make Transaction Attractive, Often Including Seller Paper • Doering and Eastwood, Ltd. Is a Member of IMAP (“International Network of M&A Partners”), Which Completed 217 Transactions With Total Value in Excess of $4 Billion in 2002 Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  13. What Is Happening After The Perfect Storm • The Good News • Private Equity Firms Have Hundreds of Billions in Equity Capital • Financial Times in April 2 Article Estimates That the Largest 450 Private Equity Firms Had Over $250 Billion in Committed Funds • Assuming a 40% Equity Requirement, Capacity to Complete $650 Billion in Acquisitions • Private Equity Groups Acquire Questdex Phone Directory Business for $5 Billion+ • Increased Role in Middle Market Transactions • Pressure to Invest or Return Proceeds to Investors • Interest Rates Are at All Time Lows • Prices Are More Reasonable Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  14. What Is Happening After The Perfect Storm • The Good News • Strategic Buyers Are Acquiring Companies in Their Industry • First Data Announces $7 Billion Acquisition of Concord — Both in Credit Card Merchant Processors • Comcast Cable Acquires AT&T Cable Properties • Numerous Regional Bank Mergers • Acquisition Discussions Increasing Dramatically Between Potential Buyers and Sellers (Source: Business Week, April 21 P.82-83) • Large Companies Are Looking at Smaller Company Add-ons to Grow Without Huge Risks Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  15. What Is Happening After The Perfect Storm • The Good News • Private Business Owners Have Become More Realistic in Value Expectations • Aging Baby Boomer Population Is Under Increasing Time Pressure to Sell and Enjoy Retirement • Banks and Financial Institutions Are Cautiously Increasing Commitment to Buyout Loans • Buyers and Sellers Are Becoming Flexible and Creative - Seller Financing, Retained Equity, Earnouts Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  16. What Is Happening After The Perfect Storm • The Bad News • Perfect Storm Conditions Continue in Varying Degrees • Tenuous Economy • Rising Unemployment and “Spent Out” Consumers • Continued Accounting and Management Credibility Issues (Healthsouth) • Poor Potential Returns to Sellers With Business Sales Proceeds • Buyers VERY CAUTIOUS Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  17. What Is Happening After The Perfect Storm • Slight Increase in the Deal Closings in the Middle Market • Ability to Sell Varies Greatly Depending Upon Company and Industry • Committed Sellers Are Succeeding By: • Maintaining or Growing Earnings • Managing Their Business Well • Flexibility in Deal Terms Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  18. Value of Privately Owned Businesses • Types of Valuation • Fair Market Value -- Estates, Gifts, Disputes • Market Value -- What the Business Will Bring If Sold • Real Market Value Determined When Offers Are Received • Most Valuations Are Earnings Multiple Based (Example 5 Times EBIT) Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  19. Value of Privately Owned Businesses • Specialized Industries May Have Different Valuation Rules of Thumb • Computer Software — Multiple of Sales • Banks — Multiple of Book Value • Cable Companies — Price Per Subscriber Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  20. Value of Privately Owned Businesses • Market Valuation Approaches: • Highest Value —“Strategic” or Investment Value • Median Value —“Stand Alone” Value • Lowest Value — Liquidation Value • Market Comparable — Used for This Presentation • Recasting Earnings • EBIT Multiple — Most Common Measuring Rod; 3 to 7 Times EBIT — 6 to 12 Price Earnings Multiple Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  21. Value of Privately Owned Businesses • Factors That Differentiate a 3 Multiple Business From a 7 (an “A” Business From a “C” Business): • Industry • Size • Growth in Sales • Earnings — Growth and Consistency • Balance Sheet Strength • Perceived Competitive Advantage — Brands, Patents, Technology, Costs • Margin As Percent of Sales • Strength and Continuity of Management Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  22. Value of Privately Owned Businesses • Exceptions to the 3 to 7 EBIT Rule: • Each Buyer Will Have a Different Criteria for Valuation • Examples: • Private Equity Firms Evaluate Based on Projected ROE • Food Brand Purchaser May Project Savings in Costs From Adding a Brand to Its Existing Distribution System • Cable Company Computes Savings From Purchase of Programs Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  23. Value of Privately Owned BusinessesQuantitative Study By IMAPA 59 Member Middle Market Intermediary Group With Offices in 25 Countries Proprietary vs. Non-Proprietary Manufacturers — NAFTA Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  24. Value of Privately Owned BusinessesQuantitative Study By IMAP Multiples of EBIT — 2002 Transactions Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  25. When Should A Business Be Sold? • With Expert’s Assistance, Objectively Analyze Business’s Sales Prospects • When the Business Is Performing Well • When There Are Good Prospective Buyers Within a Reasonable Time • When the Owner Is Committed to Spending the Time and Money to Market the Business Properly Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  26. When Should A Business Be Sold? • When the Condition of Financial Records Is Sound • Are the Statements Audited? • Possibility of Restatement in Due Diligence • When Contingent Liabilities Are Limited and Estimable • Warranty Claims • Environmental • Employee Issues • Litigation Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  27. Who Are The Buyers? • Strategic Buyers • A Buyer in the Same Business As the Seller (May Also Be an Extension of Existing Business) • Examples: • First Data Buys Concord Credit Card and ATM Processing • Wells Fargo Acquires First National Bank of Lincoln Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  28. Who Are The Buyers? • Financial Buyers — (“Private Equity Funds & Leverage Buyout Groups”) • Use Equity Provided by Institutions, Pension Funds, Insurance Companies and Other Investors • Borrow Money to Increase the Return • Examples: • Carlyle and Welsh Carson Acquire QwestDex (Telephone Directory) • Texas Pacific Acquires Burger King Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  29. Who Are The Buyers? • Funds Raised Over $800 Billion From 1997-2002 • Hundreds of Billions Left for Investment • Thousands of Buyout Funds With Billions in Capital Can Generally Borrow 1-2 Times Equity to Buy a Company Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  30. Who Are The Buyers? • Many Different Types of Buyout Funds • Each Has a Profile of Types of Investments Pursued by Size and Industry • Some Look to Consolidate a Niche Industry • Example — Hicks, Muse Radio Stations • Almost All Have a Limited Ownership Time Horizon (5 Years Average) to Sell the Company • Most Encourage Management to Own Part of the Company (5% — 20%) Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  31. Who Are The Buyers? • Look for 25% — 35% Return on Equity • Have Different Minimum EBIT Thresholds • Some Acquire Only Very Large Companies • KKR • Hicks, Muse • $5 Million, $2 Million (Most Common), $1 Million • Most Consider Even Smaller “Add-ons” That Complement an Existing Business Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  32. Who Are The Buyers? • Private Investors • Local Entrepreneur Buys Printing Business Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  33. Financing Sources • Strategic Buyer — Cash Flow From Operations; Existing Bank Lines; or Project Specific Financing • Private Equity Funds: • Equity 30-50% • Loans — Banks and Other Financial Institutions • Asset Based Loans • Revolver — Accounts Receivable, Inventory • Term Loan — Fixed Assets • Cash Flow Based Loans • Mezzanine Debt • Seller Financing Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  34. Structure of the Deal Affects Value • C Corporation With Value Substantially in Excess of Equity Brings Less Than Comparable Company (Subchapter S, LLC) That Can Sell Assets Without “Double Taxation” in Middle Market Transactions • Licenses, Leases, Inherited Liabilities and Other Contracts Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  35. Structure of the Deal Affects Value • Currency • Cash Is King • Seller Financing Brings Higher Price • With Bank Financing More Difficult and More Expensive to Obtain, Importance of Seller Financing Is Increasing — Particularly on Deals Valued Under $20 Million • Stock Swap — Tax Deferral and Liquidity Consideration, Negative Stock Market Risks Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  36. The Marketing Process • Prepare Business for Sale • Dressing Up Prior to Sales Effort • Maintain Management Continuity • Utilize Pass Through Entity (Sub S, LLC) • Identify and Resolve Litigation, Intellectual Property, Environmental and Other Contingent Liabilities • Determine Reliance on Key Customers or Suppliers • Identify Personnel Issues • Obtain Audited Financial Statements Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  37. The Marketing Process • Offering for Sale • The Team Is Critical – Lawyer, Accountant, Trusted Financial Adviser, and Investment Banker • Determine Advisability of a Merger and Acquisition Professional • Business Value Less Than $1 Million, Usually Not Advisable • Business With Less Than One-half Million EBIT • If M&A Professional Desirable, Evaluation and Choice Is Critical Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  38. The Marketing Process • Communication Among Team Members Critical • Be Aware of Deal Snipers Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  39. The Marketing Process • Business Sales Strategy • Prepare a Business Summary or Offering Memorandum and Teaser • Identify Potential Buyers • Open Negotiation Process: • With One Purchaser at a Time • To a Few Prospects (“Selective Marketing”) • With a Controlled Auction to All Qualified Prospects Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  40. The Marketing Process • Major Legal Documentation • Confidentiality Agreement • Letter Of Intent • Due Diligence • Definitive Agreement and Closing • Management Must Concentrate on Running the Business Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

  41. Conclusions • Successful Businesses Are Marketable • A Marathon, Not a Sprint • Seller Must Be Realistic About Price and Timing • Having a Trusted Team Critical • Do Not Ignore Running the Business. If Business Falters, All Other Work Is Wasted Doering & Eastwood, Ltd

More Related