200 likes | 302 Views
Current Methodologies for Testing Degradability of Agricultural Mulches and Future Approaches. Douglas G. Hayes Dept. Biosystems Engr. and Soil Sci. University of Tennessee Knoxville, TN 37996-4531. SCRI PLANNING MEETING: SPECIALTY CROPS / DEGRADABLE MATERIALS October 30, 2008
E N D
Current Methodologies for Testing Degradability of Agricultural Mulches and Future Approaches Douglas G. Hayes Dept. Biosystems Engr. and Soil Sci. University of Tennessee Knoxville, TN 37996-4531 SCRI PLANNING MEETING: SPECIALTY CROPS / DEGRADABLE MATERIALS October 30, 2008 University of Wisconsin, River Falls
Goals for Testing • Comparison of material props of mulches • Evidence of degradation • Quantitative data of degradation time course • Comparison of materials, procedures • Comparison to the literature • Understanding of underlying degradation mechanism, relationships between • Physical changes • Chemical changes • Protective performance of mulch / cover
Systems for Testing R.J. Muller, 2003
Quantities to be Measured • Physical • Structural integrity • Mechanical strength • Location of cleavage sites • Chemical • Loss of mass • Change of average molecular weight (MW) • Distribution of MW • Identifying functional groups being cleaved; underlying kinetic mechanism
I. Physical Testing • Color • Light Transmission • Scanning Electron Microscopy, SEM • Differential Scanning Calorimetry, DSC • Glass Transition Temperature, Tg • Melting Point Temperature, Tm • Gel Content • Tensile Strength, Elongation, Strain Energy • Weight g m-2, thickness • Dynamic Rheology: G’ and G” moduli • Surface Area by ??
Color Change Darkening • Colorimeter = Simple measurement • Workup: recovery of mulch, removal of excess soil • 3 filters ~response similar to eye, • (Spectrophotometer: amount of light reflected or transmitted at each wavelength) • Color Change Parameter: • DE = [ (L-L0)2 + (a-a0) 2 + (b-b0) 2]0.5 • L = brightness • a = red • b = yellow • Color change may represent • Adsorption of soil • degradation Yellowing Kijchavengkul et al, 2008
Light Transmission (%T) • Workup = same as for colorimetry • Spectrophotometry, 400-700 nm, Transmission • Depicts changes in openness between fibers • As % T Increases, weed formation is more probable • Decrease of %T with time: soil adsorption? Kijchavengkul et al, 2008
SEM b) SB PLA Control at 500X SEM of 20S3 (Promot MZM + Molasses) at 500X • Qualitative information on soil adsorption, fiber degradation • Wadsworth et al, unpublished, 2008
Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC) (ASTM D-3418) • -60oC 160oC @ 10oC/min • Tm peak broadens upon degradation when x-linking occurs • Gel formation: Xg = 1-exp(k Dtn) (Avrami Eq) -Increase of Xg ~ cross-linking (X-ray diffraction can support; Alt: ASTM D-2765) T for transition to amorphous • Tm Kijchavengkul et al, 2008
Tensile Strength (Strength at Breakage), Elongation (under Load at Breakage) and Strain Energy (ASTM D 882) Increase of Brittleness Kijchavengkul et al, 2008 Ho et al. 1999
Tensile Strength (Strength at Breakage), Elongation (under Load at Breakage) and Strain Energy (ASTM D 882) • Samples stored in dessicators at a fixed, common, relative humidity for ~48 hr • Sample swatches should be made both in the direction parallel and perpendicular to extrusion • Breakage ~ physical disintegration into fragments Kijchavengkul et al, 2008 Ho et al. 1999
II. Chemical Testing • Size Exclusion Chromatography (SEC) = Gel Permeation Chromatography (GPC) • FTIR Spectroscopy • NMR Spectroscopy • MALDI-TOF Mass Spectroscopy • Gas Chromatography-Mass Spec (GC/MS) (of residuals in soil or water) • CO2 formation / O2 consumption
GPC Analysis of Ricinoleyl / w-Pentadecanoic acyl Co-Polymers Kelly and Hayes, 2006
GPC • Workup: Dissolve mulch in solvent (CHCl3; Ionic Liquid?) • Dilute w/ mobile phase (THF) • Often, multiple columns linked in series • RI or light scattering detector (via static LS) Mw • Chromatogram Mn, PDI; area per mass of net Ho et al, 1999
GPC Calibration of Star Polymers Typically, Polystyrene or Polyethylene glycol standards used Kelly and Hayes, 2006
FTIR-Attenuated Total Reflectance (-ATR) • Loss of intensity at 1710 cm-1 (C=O stretching) and 1270 cm-1 (C-O stretching chain scission of ester group Kijchavengkul et al, 2008
1H-NMR Kelly and Hayes, 2006 Useful for low-MW oligo’s
MALDI Ricinoleic acid + Pentaerythritol Useful for low-MW oligo’s, co-polymer Kelly and Hayes, 2006
Use of Chemical and Physical Data • Physical and chemical data compared: how are structural disintegration and lowering of MW interrelated? • Phys and chem data compared to performance as a protective agent • Phys and chem data compared to environmental changes in the field (T, sunlight, r.h., etc.)
References • Ho, KL, et al, J Environ Poly Degr 7, 167 & 173 (1999) • Kelly, AR, Hayes, DG, J Appl Poly Sci 101:1646-1656 (2006) • Kijchavengkul, T., et al., Chemosphere 71: 942 & 1607 (2008) • Muller, RJ, in: Biopolymers, Volume 10, General Aspects and Special Appli cations, A. Steinbuchel, ed. Weinheim, Germany: Wiley, 2003.