360 likes | 573 Views
Dairy marketing. James Dunn Pennsylvania State University. Overview. 9.2 million cows in U.S. 9,600 liters/cow – 21,346 lbs. Number of Dairy Farms 51,481 (avg 179 cows) About 7,400 in PA (19,585 lbs./cow/yr) Population of USA – 312 mil. Milk markets are very regulated
E N D
Dairy marketing James Dunn Pennsylvania State University
Overview • 9.2 million cows in U.S. • 9,600 liters/cow – 21,346 lbs. • Number of Dairy Farms 51,481 (avg 179 cows) • About 7,400 in PA (19,585 lbs./cow/yr) • Population of USA – 312 mil.
Milk markets are very regulated Except New Zealand, everyone is regulated for prices Policies vary Some work better than others Goals of policy important
Common Policy Instruments • Classified pricing – different price according to use • Price supports – artificially keep price high • Quotas – restrict production – not here, but often discussed and in Farm Bill talks • Export subsidies • Import restrictions • Minimum retail prices – PA Milk Marketing Board • Maximum retail prices • Component prices – price depends on butterfat
United States • Classified pricing & pooling – 4 classes • Support prices – not supportive • Tariffs & import quotas • Some export subsidies • Component pricing – butterfat, protein, bacteria, other solids
Classified Pricing • Distortion depends on price difference – Canada is very distorting • Most cost paid by milk drinkers • Raise prices for inelastic demand
Price supports • Without supply control very expensive • With surplus must have subsidized exports which hurts farmers elsewhere • Dairy Cliff
Price Supports • Buy products at the equivalent of support price $9.40/cwt. (21.3 cents/kg.) • Three products cheese, butter, nonfat dry milk • Tilt is how prices of various products are adjusted to keep purchases moderate – usually NFDM too high
Production quotas • Very distorting - Canada • Cheap for government • Keeps farms from expanding • Proposed new regulations have supply controls
Export Subsidies • Expensive • Hurt farmers elsewhere
Component pricing • Helps efficiency • Improves quality • Very good if tied to markets
Import protection • Necessary with price supports • GATT problems
Spatial Price differentials • Assumes deficit milk hauled from Midwest • Adds premium to Class I Midwest price • About $2.45/cwt. in PA (Mt. Holly Springs) • Less in western PA • More in Southeastern PA
2012 avg. = $20.03 Est 2013 avg = $21.38 Est 2014 = $21.14
Fluid Processors • Dean Foods – result of merger between Suiza and Dean – largest player in fluid market – about 35% • No national brand – lots of local brands • Two processors have most of Boston market – Dean – 80% ?
Why Are Farm Numbers Consolidating? • Production efficiency • Rate of return on capital • Economies of scale • Investment strategies • Retirements • Rising affluence in society • Management, skill levels! • True in all of agriculture
Productivity and Farm Consolidation • Productivity advances relentlessly • Fewer cows are needed • Farms get bigger • 100 year trend • Some farmers are always struggling • Need to have some jobs outside of agriculture available
Trade Policy • Dairy Export Enhancement Program • Designed to keep products competitive where we have EU competition • Import restrictions – can’t hold prices up with lots of cheap imports • NAFTA – supposed to get access to Mexico and Canada – slow coming
Exporters of Dairy Products 1995-2008
Concluding comments • Milk pricing is complex • Government very involved • Prices are still about supply & demand