Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools

1. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper National School Public Relations Association For copies of this presentation go to www.JohnDraper.org

2. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org Grandson, son, father . . . My father was a Methodist minister . . .

3. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org Results from the latest PDK/Gallup Poll showed little change from recent years

4. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org What grade do you give to your oldest child’s school? A/B 77%

5. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org What grade do you give to your local schools? A/B 49%

6. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org What grade do you give to the nation’s schools? A/B 18%

7. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org So what’s the problem?My community thinks our schools are doing pretty good!Why rock the boat!?!

8. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org There are always more people ‘out there’ and they think your schools are bad!

9. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org This public myth allows any group of elected officials to act badly toward all public schools!

10. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org Nation-wide support must start with school leaders in the local districts—do not compare yours to any other school or district!

11. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org “Despite resources that are unmatched anywhere in the world, we've let our grades slip, our schools crumble, our teacher quality fall short, and other nations outpace us.” President Barack Obama March 11, 2009

12. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org Crucial Conversations The Talk, the Truth and the Crucial Conversation on . . . • Dropouts/Graduation Rate • Achievement Gap • Charter Schools • Pay for Performance • SAT Tests • International Testing

13. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org The Talk Too many of our high schools are dropout factories—and little progress is being made to improve the graduation rate.

14. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org The Truth Schools and school districts are making changes that are making a difference—graduation rates are rising!

15. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org The Crucial Conversation How do we identify struggling students early, embed remediation, remove time constraints, and provide the multiple options needed for every child to graduate?

16. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org The Talk Public schools are not closing the achievement gap.

17. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org The Truth Gaps still exist in most schools, but there is some evidence that they are narrowing!

18. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org The Crucial Conversation Poverty is the greatest common factor among low-achieving children. We have a Poverty-Learning Gap! How do we negate the ill effects of poverty, dysfunctional families, and unsafe communities?

19. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org The Talk Charter schools do a better job educating kids than regular public schools.

20. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org The Truth There is no research that charter schools as a group are more effective than regular schools.

21. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org The Crucial Conversation Almost two-thirds of the public supports charter schools—but they don’t know why! Choice is a new American Value!How can we bring this flexibility to all public schools?

22. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org The Talk Kids suffer because poor teachers make the same pay as good teachers.

23. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org The Truth There is no research supporting increased student achievement with performance pay.

24. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org The Crucial Conversation Three out of four Americans support merit pay for teachers—it’s part of the American dream. How do we develop an affordable system that rewards excellence, but maintains the team spirit required for successful learning communities?

25. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org The Talk ACT/SAT test scores are declining and have been for decades!

26. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org The Truth Average ACT/SAT scores have declined . . . but every subgroup of test takers has increased scores! Simpson’s Testing Paradox

27. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org The Crucial Conversation Average scores on SAT tests will show declines as more students take the tests. ‘Every child a graduate’ will mean lower average scores!

28. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org The Talk America’s schools are falling behind on International Tests when compared with other countries.

29. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org The Truth Our schools have never scored well on International Testing! In reality we have “fallen up” to about average . . . which is very good!

30. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org The USA Consistently Ranks best in the world on Global Competitiveness Index There are some measures we don’t want to win! We don’t want to be the Fattest or the Skinniest Nation in the World.

31. International Test ScoresAre NOT a Valid Predictor of National Success!(Catching Up or Leading the Way? by Yong Zhao) USA High QUALITY OF LIFE Low Low TEST SCORES High

32. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org What’s Happening? • US is becoming more urban, grayer, browner, debtor nation (Fertilizer, Pills and Magnetic Strips by Gene Glass) • Urban--fertilizer and families • Grayer--medicine and voters • Browner--baby boomers and children • Debtor--savings and credit cards • Arizona and Florida are the trend leaders

33. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org Why Does the Urban Myth of Failing Public Schools Refuse to Die?! • Only man-made object large enough to be seen from outer space? • Beware of Halloween candy—apples with . . . • Made to Stick—by Chip and Dan Heath

34. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org A priest and a nun rode together to a 3-day spiritual retreat . . . What makes the joke funny?

35. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org The TLC Formula • Think and Talk about what you believe and why you believe it • Learn to use Language that reframes the issues • Connect your Community to your students using stories

36. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org Belief is Contagious . . .Spread Yours Around!

37. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org Think and Talk About What You Believe • Every child deserves a quality education regardless of parents or location • Standardized tests are just one measure of learning—creativity, self-discipline, persistence, imagination, enthusiasm are equally important!

38. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org Think and Talk About What You Believe • All children can learn—but at different rates with different strengths • The overwhelming majority of educators are good people who care about children

39. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org The TLC Formula • Think and Talk about what you believe and why you believe it • Learn to use Language that reframes the issues • Connect your Community to your students using stories

40. Godless, government schools Selfish, union employees Leaving little children behind Caring, community schools Sincere, dedicated professionals Every Child Every Chance Learn to Use Language that Reframes!

41. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org We have the “Curse of Knowledge” • We know the many wonderful things that happen in our schools! • We need an IEP for that new ODD, ADHD, LD boy, ASAP! • You don’t know what it is like NOT to know what you know!

42. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org Twinkle, Twinkle Little Star

43. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer

44. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org The TLC Formula • Think and Talk about what you believe and why you believe it • Learn to use Language that reframes the issues • Connect your Community to your students using stories

45. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org When you share stories . . . You overcome the Curse of Knowledge! You communicate the importance of public schools without confrontation! What are your school’s success stories? What stories touch your heart?

47. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org Finding the stories . . . • Each grading period students get a “Successory” form to thank a someone who supported their success • Make the form in duplicate, one for the Successory and one for office • Office draws a Successory winner for a gift certificate to local restaurant • Local school selects top 4 or 5 to send to Superintendent for sharing with Board

48. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org

49. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org

50. Crucial Conversations About America’s Schools Dr. John Draper johndraper.org Commit to do 4 Things • Shift your attention to the positive • Stop bad-mouthing one another in public • Share one positive story per week with your personal network • Monitor your progress (Adapted from Schools Cannot Do It Alone by Jamie Vollmer)