1 / 12

Hurricane Mitigation Plans

Hurricane Mitigation Plans. Michael A. Walters FCAS, MAAA CAS Catastrophe Seminar October 16, 2000. Topics of Discussion. Creating a mitigation/class plan in Florida Could have used a single model Did use multiple sources Deciding cost/effective class variables

darice
Download Presentation

Hurricane Mitigation Plans

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Hurricane Mitigation Plans Michael A. Walters FCAS, MAAA CAS Catastrophe Seminar October 16, 2000

  2. Topics of Discussion • Creating a mitigation/class plan in Florida • Could have used a single model • Did use multiple sources • Deciding cost/effective class variables • Standards and considerations • Selecting a base class • Adjusting to new base class

  3. Creating a mitigation/class plan • Florida hurricane is already separate • In Windpool (FWUA) wind coverage • Split out Other Wind • Goal: mitigation plan plus rate level • Identify true costs • Incentive for insureds to mitigate home • Transition plan: stagger premium increases • Payback in a few years of premium savings

  4. Could have used a single model • For base class, use single house in each zip code at base coverage • For each class, run model for single house by zip code • Track relationship to base by zip • Use mapping software to group similar zip code relationships • Publish relativities by zone or statewide

  5. Florida: did use multiple sources • Decide what variables to include • Survey sources for relativities • Use several zip codes around state • Delphi technique for outliers • Apply actuarial judgment • Peer review by engineering experts

  6. Decide rating variables • Roof - shape, covering, waterproof sheathing, pitch, overhang • Connections - straps, nailing (size,spacing) • Windows and Doors - shuttering, garage door size & bracing, glazing • House Features - stories, porches, construction • Environment - terrain, debris exposure

  7. Standards • Homogeneous • No clear subsets of large different loss potential • Reasonably related to loss hazard • Well Defined • Exhaustive and mutually exclusive • No ambiguity in placement • No manipulation by insureds • Practical • Reasonable cost to administer • Able to be tested by actual loss data

  8. Considerations • Prioritize items that insureds can change • Use results from mitigation programs • Combine categories to control number of classes • Measure interaction among variables • May need on-site survey by independent professionals

  9. Selecting/Adjusting Base Class • Base Class • Generally the prevailing condition • Discounts for other classes • Sample: gable roof, no shutters, no roof clips • Adjust Loss Costs to New Base • Estimate distributions of classes • Use class relativities to calculate off-balance

  10. Base Class Assumptions (italics) • Roof • Shape - gable unbraced, gable braced, hip, flat • Cover - Shingle, tile, slate, metal, poured concrete • Waterproof sheathing underlayment - No, yes • Pitch - <10d, 10-30, >30 degrees • Overhang - <16,16-36, >36 inches • Connections • Hurricane Clips - No, yes: at roof, at foundation • Sheathing Attachment - 6d nails, 8d nails

  11. Base Class Assumptions (italics) • Windows and Doors • Shuttering - None, ordinary, hurricane resistant (debris impact) • Glass patio doors - Yes, no • Garage doors - single-wide, double-wide; braced, unbraced • Laminated glass - No, yes

  12. Base Class Assumptions (italics) • House Features • Number of stories - one, >one • Porches/canopies/carports - Yes, no • Construction - frame, masonry: reinforced? • Year Built/Code Enforcement - before 1995/not enforced, other • Environment • Suburban light tree cover, dense • Other - waterfront, urban, rural

More Related