1 / 28

Using Equity Audit in NHS Lothian

Using Equity Audit in NHS Lothian. Dr Margaret Douglas Public Health Consultant Sheila Wilson Senior Health Policy Officer. A whole systems approach to addressing health inequalities in NHS Lothian. NHS Lothian Principles to address health inequalities.

deana
Download Presentation

Using Equity Audit in NHS Lothian

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Using Equity Audit in NHS Lothian Dr Margaret Douglas Public Health Consultant Sheila Wilson Senior Health Policy Officer

  2. A whole systems approach to addressing health inequalities in NHS Lothian

  3. NHS Lothian Principles to address health inequalities • Broad programme: both health determinants and health services • Identify and avoid unintended adverse effects of our services • Give priority to disadvantaged groups • Consult with/involve all groups • Interventions coherent, long term, at all levels, with evidence base • NHS needs to influence partners but also ensure our own work doesn’t disadvantage vulnerable groups

  4. Whole system approach • Three strands of work: • Partnership work to address determinants of inequality • Ensure mainstream services appropriate for all • Targeted initiatives

  5. Inequalities in access to healthcare • ‘Inverse care law’ • Physical access eg car ownership • Language barriers • Cultural barriers • Financial barriers • Previous experience • Different expectations

  6. Inequalities in access to healthcare • NHS by itself cant reduce the inequalities • But we must meet the needs of the people with greatest health needs • Aim for equal access, equal use and equal quality for equal need • Services may be • Universal / Targeted / Distributional

  7. Equity audits • Explore how well existing services meet needs of disadvantaged groups • Both quantitative data and qualitative methods • Aim to identify changes to improve access and/or outcomes for disadvantaged groups • Core public health work but with systematic approach and formal NHS Lothian policy

  8. Selection of topic areas • Is this a well defined service area? Complexity of patient pathway • Previous or ongoing work in this service area • Likely staff support in this service area • Fit with strategic priorities/links with other workstreams • Is data readily available? • What is the potential impact on health inequalities?

  9. Example 1:Physiotherapy self referral • Background: community physiotherapy services and routes of referral • Aim: to explore differences between GP and self referred patients

  10. Patient Pathway

  11. What are the research questions?What data could be used?What dimensions of inequality could the data be broken down by?

  12. Objectives of the equity audit • To describe self-referrals and other types of referral by age, sex, socioeconomic status and location • To describe self-referrals and other types of referral by type of discharge (Patient completed treatment, DNA, Did not complete etc.), age, sex, socio-economic status and location • To describe time from routine referral to start of treatment by type of referral age, sex, socio-economic status and location. • To describe clinical presentation (back pain etc.) by age, sex, socioeconomic status and location • To describe type of referral and clinical presentation by ethnic group (where number is sufficient)

  13. Data • Electronic patient record • Referral date between 1/4/07 and 31/7/10 • 20,522 referrals in 2 centres, which account for about 20% of Edinburgh CHP physio referrals • SIMD used to derive deprivation quintiles • Onomap software to assign ethnicity • What are the potential biases in these data?

  14. Physiotherapy - trend

  15. Physiotherapy Distribution within SIMD

  16. Physiotherapy - Waits Physiotherapy - Waits

  17. Physiotherapy Assessment – Self referral

  18. Physiotherapy Assessment – GP referral

  19. Not Completing Treatment

  20. Findings • What do the data tell us? • What questions are not answered? • What would you like to do next? • What recommendations would you make?

  21. Example 2Head and neck cancer • Context – Cancer Patient Experience Service Improvement Programme • Aim: to explore differences in access and outcome by deprivation, age and gender

  22. Data Source and Issues • SCAN database • Timing • Data • Completeness • Analyses

  23. Data completeness

  24. H&N Incidence

  25. H&N Deaths

  26. Interventions

  27. Findings and issues • What recommendations could you make? • Communications issues

  28. Criteria for success • Clear focus and purpose • Engagement and support of service (including ability and capacity to respond to ongoing queries, willingness to engage with findings) • Data - availability and quality • Patient pathway with quality indicators • Real issues may be outside NHS services • More nuanced inequalities may need qualitative approach

More Related