1 / 28

Can any target be useful?

Can any target be useful?. Deming Alliance 3 rd June 2013. Todays targets:. New people to the group to learn at least three new and useful ideas! Longer term attendees to positively reflect on at least two different concepts for them!

dmitri
Download Presentation

Can any target be useful?

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Can any target be useful? Deming Alliance 3rd June 2013

  2. Todays targets: • New people to the group to learn at least three new and useful ideas! • Longer term attendees to positively reflect on at least two different concepts for them! • For all to contribute positively at least once each today!

  3. Baselining the meeting • Who thinks alltargets are: Good? … Bad? • Who thinks sometargets are: Good …. Bad? • Who thinks Arbitrarytargets are Good …. Bad? • WT Pay for achieving Arbtargets are Good .. Bad? • Who thinks Facts of life targets are Good ….. Bad? • Who has no idea at all?

  4. Performance measures • If todays targets as agreed are potentially going to fail to be achieved: • Fudge the process to make it look OK, or, • Do something to make it happen, such as • Change your mind twice, that is accept the new idea at first, then, • Go back to your original idea, so you have considered two new ideas • Alter the measures, such that outcomes and targets are separated and failure gets forgotten

  5. Useful targets!

  6. Targets • For those who said all targets are bad, have any of you changed your mind?

  7. Useful targets • Deming Facts of life targets: • To achieve more income than expenditure…. i.e. Long term profit…. • “…management by numerical goal is an attempt to manage without knowledge of what to do, and in fact is usually management by fear.”“Out of the Crisis” 1982 – Ch.2 -Principles for Transformation-, page 76 • To achieve enough income to survive …. Food, clothes, home? Maslow’s basics • Others?

  8. Some other Deming quotes “Certainly we want good results, but management by results is not the way to get good results…work on the causes of results”“The New Economics” 1994 – Ch. 2 -The Heavy Losses-, page 33 “But he that would run his company on visible figures alone will in time have neither company nor figures”“Out of the Crisis” 1982 – Ch. 3 -Diseases and Obstacles-, page 121 “the most important figures that one needs for management are unknown or unknowable”“Out of the Crisis” 1982 – Ch. 3 -Diseases and Obstacles-, page 121 “It is wrong to suppose that if you can’t measure it, you can’t manage it – a costly myth”The New Economics” 1994 – Ch. 2 -The Heavy Losses-, page 35

  9. Reversing target thinking • Our target for next year is to reduce reportable and serious accidents by 15% • Current rate = 331 • Rewording: • We intend to injure 281 employees either seriously or to such an extent that it becomes a reportable incident!

  10. Fire Brigade Target • We still have the same amount of employees as when 700 people used to die from fires each year, now only 180 die from fires, so we will reduce employment! • Rewording? • Our aim from a review is to reduce the service cost, if there is an increase of fire deaths, after a new trend confirms that has happened, we will increase budgets to employ more staff.

  11. Unhelpful lack of target • Having increased pot-hole fixing by a factor of eight per day …. • “To fix all potholes!” • Why is this unhelpful ? • “Meet the customers demands!” • Why is this a problem?

  12. Scenario one • A real life target in 1993 • Background • A developing CI department in a traditional council • All departments had to have business plans • All people had performance plans, with linked performance pay and an unaffordable sprint to unaffordability (anyone heard of Hays?) • Targets MUST be set • HMMMM!!

  13. A really useful Arbitrary Target? • The plan had to include: What we did, who we did it for, how often and for how much… • The system required ‘stretch targets’ • YIPPEE! • Soooo… • After some thought we agreed on: • To achieve at least 200 improvements a year. • THOUGHTS?

  14. Positivity? How? • Well… first of all our current numeric of improvements was over 200 a year, so it should be possible … and • Every quarter we had to publish our performance against the target, with illustrations of what they included … and • That gave us the opportunity to show-case the positive outcomes on a continuous basis

  15. Positivity? How? • We logged all the improvements, ascribing what, where, who involved… the whole department became aware of the art of the possible… we had a record of positive change! • Work expanded, security improved (did I mention Compulsory Competitive Tendering?) • Costs reduced, productivity improved, customers liked us .. far more than contractors

  16. Positivity? • A conservative council expanded its Direct Labour organisation … “What would Maggie say?” • Costs reduced, profits reduced, value to the council improved …. Why?? • Client reports became positive, “85% of emergency work was completed before we could raise the works order” • The department cemented as a team …

  17. Gameplay • Two linked government targets: • To reduce all highway accidents leading to death or serious injury by 60% by 2008 • To increase the speed of travel in urban areas by 5% by 2008 • What happens? What is the gameplay?

  18. Scenario two

  19. Utility spending -1 Situation • A nationalised industry in 1980’s • Profitability assured –> disregard efficiency • Unwritten rule: End FY spend 95 - 102% • ‘Or Else!’ penalties a cultural norm • ‘Spend it or lose it’ (swept to CFO) • No surprise that section heads met de facto target; very few risked disgrace.

  20. Utility spending -2 How did business respond? • Belts tight Qtrs 1-3…mad rush in Q4 • £ profile ignored seasonality of need • Contract spans set to FY; = less effective • Stifled innovation (except in Q4!).

  21. Utility spending -3 Effect on business sustainability • Unreal budgets; grew less practical, flexible • Investment planning was strangled, except at board level • Little care for Voice of Customer or VoProcess • Bids for £ outside budget generally rejected • Workforce planning was not adopted

  22. Motivating sales -1 Situation • ‘Sales’ = influencing, not tangible products • Uniform activity & volume targets imposed • Opportunity sometimes far short of target • Any shortfall guaranteed –ve consequences: • - loss of patronage, privilege and pride.

  23. Motivating sales -2 How did business respond? • Tension record-keeping and bull***t, outright lies, bullying • Fear at all levels, so little trust • Hiding spare or windfall capacity • Inter-team cooperation was rare • Jealousy, sneaky tricks including poaching • Only backing ‘sure bets’.

  24. Motivating sales -3 Effect on business sustainability • A substantial empire built on false figures • Leaders unable to distinguish fact from fiction • Poor business intelligence = opportunities • Nil forecasting ability = avoid shocks • Whole of sales may have been a net loss • How would they have known?

  25. Other examples of Targets? • Five minute presentations from the floor? • Learning points today • Use of English…. Some targets are useful? • All …. Is a very powerful word! • Baseline check?

  26. Baselining the meeting • Who thinks alltargets are: Good? … Bad? • Who thinks sometargets are: Good …. Bad? • Who thinks Arbitrarytargets are Good …. Bad? • WT Pay for achieving Arbtargets are Good .. Bad? • Who thinks Facts of life targets are Good ….. Bad? • Who has no idea at all?

  27. Todays targets: Were they met? • New people to the group to learn at least three new and useful ideas! • Longer term attendees to positively reflect on at least two different concepts for them! • For all to contribute positively at least once each today!

  28. Next steps • Sound-bites for the web-site and LinkedIn? • Paper for the web-site or LinkedIn? • Restart A5 booklets? • Go to Lunch?

More Related