250 likes | 462 Views
Distal Protection: PRIDE, CAPTIVE Symbiot III, AiMI . Dr James Cotton MD MRCP Heart and Lung Centre Wolverhampton. Pathology. History (SVG trials). 30 Day MACE. Abciximab. Guardwire. Filterwire EX. Guardwire. Possible methods for embolic protection. Distal Protection UK 2003.
E N D
Distal Protection:PRIDE, CAPTIVE Symbiot III, AiMI Dr James Cotton MD MRCP Heart and Lung Centre Wolverhampton
History (SVG trials) 30 Day MACE Abciximab Guardwire Filterwire EX Guardwire
Distal Protection UK 2003 • Distal Protection 345 (0.65%) • Thrombectomy 347 (0.65%) (inc. percusurg)
Pride/Captive • Both started as superiority trials • After FDA approval for guardwire and filterwire, changed to non-inferiority trials.
PRIDE PRotection during saphenous vein graft Intervention to prevent Distal Embolisation
PRIDE Triactiv N=313 SVG Lesion >3.0<5.0 mm Any Length n=631 Guardwire n=236 Filterwire n=83 Total n=318 10 endpoint - MACE at 30 days 20 endpoint - Efficacy (final TIMI 3 flow) - Safety
CAPTIVE Cardioshield Application Protects during Transluminal Intervention of Vein grafts by reducing Emboli
Total N=1011 Randomised N=847 Non inferiority N=652 Superiority N=197 Cardioshield N=96 No protection N=101 Cardioshield N=334 Guardwire N=318 Inclusion – Lesion <50 mm 10 endpoint: 30 day MACE
CAPTIVE: Primary end point at 30 days, non-inferiority analysis
SYMBIOT III • Symbiot PTFE coated nitinol self expanding stent vs BMS in SVG lesions • Up to 2 lesions • Lesion length <41mm • Stent length < 51mm • Primary endpoint: • Reduction of % DS of at • least10% at 8/12 angio compared to BMS • (Symbiot II – • 7% restenosis at 6/12)
SYMBIOT III Randomised N=400 BMS 199 Symbiot 201 Angiographic 8/12 FU 128 150
SYMBIOT IIIPrimary endpoint P=0.12 %DS
BMS Symbiot SYMBIOT III P=0.04 P=0.43
The AIMI Study AngioJet Rheolytic Thrombectomy In Patients Undergoing Primary Angioplasty for Acute Myocardial Infarction
AIMI - Hypothesis • Effective removal of coronary thrombus prior to definitive angioplasty and stenting may reduce distal embolization of thrombus, which could improve myocardial perfusion and salvage. • Rheolytic thrombectomy with the AngioJet System during PCI for all STEMI will reduce final infarct size.
Study Design STEMI < 12 hoursAnterior MILarge Inferior MIN=480 CATH LABCoronary AngiographyRandomization Rheolytic Thrombectomyfollowed by definitive PCIN=240 Primary PCIN=240 Resting Tc-99m sestamibi scan at 14-28 days (N=197 AJ/205 Control)MACEClinical Follow up at 6 months
AIMI - endpoints • Primary: • Infarct size at 14-28 days, by Tc-99m sestamibi SPECT imaging • Secondary: • TIMI flow grade, TIMI blush grade, TIMI frame count (corrected) • ST-segment resolution • MACE (death, new Q wave MI, stroke, TLR) • EF (SPECT)
Final Infarct size (10 endpoint) P=0.58 P<0.02 P<0.006
AIMI - MACE P<0.01 P<0.02
Conclusions: • Triactiv device is non inferior to current distal protection standards • Cardioshield device is yet to be proven • Symbiot stent is not superior to BMS in SVG`s • At present rheolytic thrombectomy cannot be recommended in acute infarct angioplasty