370 likes | 385 Views
Explore historical narratives of archaeology, politics, and identity in the Middle East tied to Western colonial interventions and Orientalist representations. Uncover postcolonial critiques and the cultural impacts of misrepresentations through visual, literary, and architectural forms. Examining the Tanzimat Period and key figures like Osman Hamdi Bey sheds light on complex historical legacies.
E N D
Arch 1810. Under the Tower of Babel: Archaeology, Politics, and Identity in the Modern Middle East Spring 2010 Collecting, museums and orientalism in the Late Ottoman Empire: a view from the 19th century February 9, 2010
archaeology in the context of 19th century colonialism: archaeology as part of the industrialist interventions from the West, employing, exporting technologies and scientific methodologies. a way of systematically knowing the colonized landscape, surveying it, mapping it, studying its antiquities, ruins, its “antique” riches a way of acquiring objects for Western museums and supplying them with splendid collections serves a religious purpose as well discovery of places, cities, empires mentioned in the Biblical texts. Archaeology concretely legitimized the Biblical past. Very critical for European claim for Mesopotamian heritage. Lines up well with missionary activity.
Edward Said, Orientalism (1978) Orientalism: an episode in Western humanitistic thought
Jean-Léon Gérôme (1824 – 1904) Snake Charmer (1870) Oil on canvas
Jean-Léon Gérôme (1824 – 1904) Moorish Bath (1870) Oil on canvas
Grande piscine de Brousse. (The Great Pool of Bursa) Jean-Léon Gérôme,1885, Oil on canvas, 51x76cm, private collection
Orientalism: representational systems as apparatuses of (colonial) power visual, literary, architectural and so on ...
postcolonialism • exploring the cultural impact and nature of colonialist enterprises, • problematizing their primitivist, “othering” stance, symbolic violence, oppressive ideologies • misrepresentations of non-Western societies by colonial powers, • power practices operative in colonial lands in colonial histories • “a process of disengagement from the whole colonial syndrome” (Loomba) • critical reading of representational systems as appratuses of power
Tanzimat Period 1839-1876 • a period of rapid change and Ottoman attempts for industrialization and Westernization.
Izmir clock tower (1901) The clock itself was a gift of William II, German Emperor.
Abdul-Hamid II Collection- Photographs of the Empire 1880-1893 High school, Damascus / Sebah & Joaillier, Phot., Constantinople.
Group photograph of the students of the Mirgûn (Emirgân) middle school for girls / Abdullah Frères, Phot., Constantinople.
Abdul-Hamid II Collection- Photographs of the Empire 1880-1893 Galata Tower, Istanbul / Abdullah Frères, Phot., Constantinople. Library of Congress
Turkish post card from 1895 about the Kanûn-ı Esâsî of November 23, 1876, with the sultan Abdülhamid II, the Grand Vizier, the millets and Turkey receiving freedom; the flying angel show the motto: Liberty, Equality, Fraternity.
Osman Hamdi Bey (1842-1910) an Ottoman statesman, lawyer, archaeologist, painter, museum director
Osman Hamdi Bey in Oriental garb at the Vienna Universal Exposition 1873
Osman Hamdi Bey Discussion in front of the Mosque 1906 Osman Hamdi Bey Untitled
Osman Hamdi Bey Tortoise Trainer (1906), 223 x 117 cm Pera Museum, Istanbul
Osman Hamdi Bey Girl reading Qur’an (1880)
Other orientalisms Photographs of an Armenian–Iranian photographer: Antoin Sevruguin (1840-1933)
Heinrich Schleimann 1822-1890 Sophia Schliemann (née Engastromenos) wearing treasures recovered at Hisarlik.