1 / 18

Assessing Student Leadership: Research with a few unexpected perks

Assessing Student Leadership: Research with a few unexpected perks. Alexis Kanda-Olmstead Office of Student Leadership, Involvement & Community Engagement Colorado State University March 27, 2008. Presentation Outline. Assessment fears National and in-house leadership assessments

elin
Download Presentation

Assessing Student Leadership: Research with a few unexpected perks

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Assessing Student Leadership: Research with a few unexpected perks Alexis Kanda-Olmstead Office of Student Leadership, Involvement & Community Engagement Colorado State University March 27, 2008

  2. Presentation Outline • Assessment fears • National and in-house leadership assessments • Key findings • Unexpected perks

  3. Assessment Fears • Fear of the Unknown • Research • Statistics • Oh my! • Fear of the Known • Time commitment • Results and their implications

  4. National Leadership Assessment Multi-Institutional Study of Leadership (MSL) • Purpose – To examine student leadership values (outcomes) at both the institutional (CSU) and national levels with specific attention to the environmental factors that influence leadership development in college students. • 55 campuses participated • 63,000 students completed the survey (37% return rate)

  5. Working Definition of Leadershipfor the MSL “Leadership is a relational process of people together attempting to accomplishchange or make a difference to benefit the common good.” - Susan Komives, Nance Lucas, & Timothy McMahon Exploring Leadership: For College Students Who Want to Make a Difference (1998)

  6. Framework of the MSL Theoretical Framework: Social Change Model of Leadership Development (HERI, 1996) Conceptual Framework: I-E-O College Impact Model (Inputs-Environment-Outcomes) (Astin, 1993, 2001)

  7. The Social Change Model of Leadership Development

  8. MSL Key Findings • Pre-college experience matters • Leadership shows moderate gender differences • Openness to change is greater for marginalized students • Service and internship experiences develop student leadership • Racial and ethnic groups differ

  9. MSL Key Findings (Continued) • Mentoring develops leadership outcomes and leadership efficacy • Depthof involvement is better than breadth of involvement • Discussions about socio-cultural issues are powerful leadership development experiences

  10. In-House Leadership Assessment • Alumni Leadership Development Survey • Purpose: Investigate long-term affect of leadership programs/classes on CSU alumni • Method: Student Voice survey based on outcomes identified by the leadership program administrators • Student Leadership Assessment • Purpose: Research the leadership development of CSU students enrolled in academic leadership classes • Method: Student Voice survey based on Kouzes and Posner’s Student Leadership Practices Inventory (SLPI)

  11. In-House Leadership Assessment • Leadership Resources Inventory • Purpose: Catalog leadership programs/activities across campus to eliminate redundancy • Method: Student Voice survey based on leadership outcomes determined by a CSU faculty and staff work group (Leadership Education Advisory Board) • PLP CAS Standards Assessment • Purpose: Benchmark survey for the President’s Leadership Program • Method: In-class paper survey based on 2003 CAS standards for leadership programs

  12. Key Findings:Alumni Leadership Development Survey • Collaboration skills • Understanding group dynamics • Teambuilding • Enhanced self-esteem • Leadership development • Intellectual growth • Exploring career choices • Learning healthy behaviors • Developing spiritual awareness • Leading change • Assessing org effectiveness Highest Mean Scores Lowest Mean Scores

  13. Key Findings:Student Leadership Assessment Gender Differences • “I describe a compelling image of what our future could be like.” • 81% of males • 51% of females • “I support the decisions that people make on their own.” • 86% of females • 72% of males • “I challenge people to try out innovative approaches to their work.” • 63% of males • 44% of females

  14. Key Findings:Leadership Resources Inventory • 69% of the respondents offer academic/curricular leadership development opportunities • 64% of the respondents offer co-curricular leadership development opportunities • 80% of the respondents offer leadership development opportunities through student employment • There is a lot of leadership development going on across campus.

  15. Key Findings:PLP CAS Standards Assessment • Students selected “Agree” to “Strongly Agree” for 17 of the 20 statements related to the CAS standards. • Lowest scores were in the following areas: • Clarification of career choices and options • Importance of a healthy lifestyle • Critical thinking skills

  16. Benefits • Results are more credible • Opportunity to network with experts in the field • Professional development • Someone else designs the instrument and analyzes the data • Focused on your research questions/areas of interest • Opportunity to network with colleagues across campus • Control of the data and its dissemination National Leadership Assessment In-House Leadership Assessment

  17. Challenges • Labor intensive • Cost • Difficult to correct mistakes • Bureaucratic hoops • Validity • Reliability • Expectation that you do something • Political hoops National Leadership Assessment In-House Leadership Assessment

  18. Unexpected Perks

More Related