E N D
1. Analysis and Design of RF CMOS Attenuators
Hakan Dogan, Robert G. Meyer and Ali M. Niknejad
Berkeley Wireless Research Center
University of California, Berkeley
3. Motivation Motivation: Precise gain control is required for many RF applications at the RF front end or at Intermediate Frequencies.
Cable modem tuner, fiber receivers
IS-95 CDMA mobile receiver
Instrumentation (Testing equipment, function generators, oscilloscopes)
Terrestrial Receivers (Satellite Radio)
Important Design Parameters
Insertion Loss: Minimum achievable attenuation
S11 & S22 : Adequate matching to source & load impedances
Bandwidth: Maximum achievable bandwidth for a given technology
Distortion: IIP2 & IIP3 performance
4. System Example: Cable TV tuner Variable gain element is present in both the up-converter and down-converter
Wide band systems require highly linear building blocks
High linearity VGAs consume large amounts of power
Replacing VGAs with on-chip attenuators will relax the design specs and lower power dissipation
5. Attenuator vs. VGA Any attenuation before the constant gain amplifier will add to its linearity
20-25dBm IIP3 commercial VGAs consume 70-100mA from 3.3V supply
High linearity attenuator (25dBm) with a medium linearity (10dBm) amplifier can be achieved with 15-20mA
High 1dB compression point of the attenuator will allow larger input swing
6. Attenuator Topologies What limits performance in terms of design parameters e.g. insertion loss, bandwidth, distortion etc. ?
How do the two topologies compare in terms of performance?
What can we achieve with the latest CMOS technologies?
Is linearity the performance bottleneck?
7. Minimum Insertion Loss The loss at the output when a device is inserted in the signal path
Shunt devices are off, RS matches to RM+Rl
Increasing device sizes for the series transistor decreases the insertion loss
Data is generated using ST 0.13µ digital CMOS process with 1.2V supply voltage
8. Maximum Attenuation
9. Impedance Matching
10. Frequency Limitations For high attenuation multiple stage attenuator design is advantageous
Conductive substrate will limit max. attenuation at high frequencies
Pi or T double stage is sufficient for applications up to 5GHz
Design choice will be based on distortion performance by trading off bandwidth with linearity
11. Distortion: Device Equation Collapses to (1) for strong inversion in linear region and to (2) for weak inversion
Models the transition region of moderate inversion with acceptable accuracy
12. Distortion Performance (1) Increasing attenuation causes larger swing across the series device
Distortion degrades with attenuation
Higher attenuation means larger input drive, linearity should improve
Simulated at 100MHz and 2.5GHz
13. Distortion degrades as the parallel device starts conducting
Series devices matches to 50O at max. attenuation (Vctrl~Vth), limits distortion degradation
Worst case distortion is better than the ? configuration
Simulated at 100MHz
14. Shunt R forces the series devices to turn off at high attenuation
Distortion improves at high attenuation as the series devices completely turn off
Simulated at 100MHz
15. Attenuator Block Diagram Dummy attenuator is used in a DC feedback loop for impedance matching
Vctrl varies the series resistance for attenuation
Feedback amplifier forces shunt device resistance to match to Rs & Rl
Same control voltages are applied to RF attenuator
16. Linearity Improvement Un-identical cascaded stages
1st stage is highly linear at 12dB attenuation
Limits the signal to the 2nd stage, improving its linearity
Asymmetric topology requires separate feedback loop for input and output matching
17. Attenuation Range Vctrl2 is offset from Vctrl1 to achieve a smooth attenuation curve
18. Design Schematic
19. Chip Photo Dimensions:
700x1000 µm2
Process:
0.13-µm bulk CMOS from ST Microelectronics
Chip was probed for testing.
20. Measurement Results (I)
21. Measurement Results (II)
22. Design Comparison
23. Conclusion CMOS attenuator circuits have been analyzed for attenuation range, frequency and distortion performance
Intermodulation distortion equations have been derived using a simple CMOS model
An improved distortion attenuator design has been presented
The design performance has been verified through testing