1 / 33

Higher education is associated with attitudes towards

“College Major and Preferences: The Case of Religion” + “Education and Values: Family, Careers and Society” Miles Kimball Colter Mitchell Arland Thornton Linda Young-DeMarco University of Michigan.

elroy
Download Presentation

Higher education is associated with attitudes towards

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. “College Major and Preferences: The Case of Religion”+“Education and Values: Family, Careers and Society”Miles KimballColter MitchellArland ThorntonLinda Young-DeMarcoUniversity of Michigan All authors contributed substantially to this paper, and names are listed alphabetically to reflect the substantial contribution of each. Paper available at http://paa2006.princeton.edu/download.aspx?submissionId=60182

  2. Higher education is associated with attitudes towards • Individual achievement • Marriage and intergenerational relationships • Divorce, cohabitation, and childbearing • Careers, fulfillment, and community service • Religion

  3. Focus of Research • Causal Relationships • College Major Values

  4. Focus of Research • Causal Relationships • College Major Values

  5. Focus of Research • Reciprocal Causal Relationships • College Major Values

  6. Theory • Three Streams of Thought: • Science • Developmentalism • Postmodernism

  7. Science • Alternative authority structure • Alternative view of life and purpose • God not necessary for explaining life • Humans related to animals • Mind=Brain (neurological explanations of spiritual experience) • Little room in Physics for an immortal soul separate from the body.

  8. Developmentalism • Narrative of progress: • Individual over family • Materialism • Equality and Freedom

  9. Postmodernism • Rejection of absolute or universal standards • Epistemological doubt • Social and political power determines what counts as true and right.

  10. College Major

  11. Two Fundamental Hypotheses • Hypotheses 1: College major will influence values concerning family, careers, and society • Hypothesis 2: Values will influence the choice of college major

  12. College Major

  13. Monitoring the Future • High school seniors in the United States • The baseline interview takes place during senior year (Time 0) • Time 1 is one or two years after high school • Time 3 is five or six years after high school

  14. How Important Is… (4pt scale) • Family • Having a good marriage and family life • Being able to give my children better opportunities than I've had • Living close to parents and relatives • Career • Being successful in my line of work • Having lots of money • Being able to find steady work • Society • Working to correct social and economic inequalities • Making a contribution to society • Finding purpose and meaning in my life

  15. College Major Categories • Natural Science • Social Science • Humanities • Other/Undecided • No College • “Trades” (clerical, vocational/technical, business, education, and engineering)

  16. Controls • Year of initial survey (1976-1995) • Region • Gender • Parental education • Political preferences and beliefs • Religion

  17. Analyses • College Major Values

  18. Figure 1Measurement and Structural Effects Model of Personal Values

  19. Equations • Substantive equations • Measurement equations

  20. Table 3Predicting Time 3 Attitude from Time 1 Attitude and College Major at Time 1 LISREL Models (Z – ratios in parentheses) N=4173

  21. Analyses • Values College Major • College major stability • Choosing a new college major

  22. Table 4 Predicting the Stability of Time1 College Majors Through Time3 for the Time1 Attitude (Z-Ratios in Parentheses) N=4173

  23. Table 5Multinomial Logistic Regressions Predicting the Time3 College Major from the Time1 Attitude for Individuals in College at Time1 Who Indicated a Change in College Major by Time3(Trades is the Omitted Category) (Z-ratios in Parentheses) (N=888)

  24. Summary and Conclusions • College major changes values • Values affect college major choice • Strong causal nexus between values and major life decisions

  25. Table 3Predicting Time 3 Religiosity from Time 1 Religiosity and College Major at Time 1 LISREL Models (Z – ratios in parentheses)

  26. Table 4 Predicting the Stability of Time1 College Majors Through Time3 for the Time1 Religiosity (Z-Ratios in Parentheses)

  27. Table 5Multinomial Logistic Regressions Predicting the Time3 College Major from the Time1 Religiosity for Individuals in College at Time1 Who Indicated a Change in College Major by Time3 (Trades is the Omitted Category) (Z-ratios in Parentheses)

  28. Multipliers:Can these effects explain social change? • Many of these ideas affect everyone, regardless of major (or not attending college)—estimates of differences in effects are a lower bound on the overall size of the effects. • These are the effects after diminishing returns • Effects bigger in the past when the ideas were newer • Effects bigger in other countries where newer • The total social effects are cumulative over time • Colleges train the cultural elites (e.g., news and entertainment elites).

  29. Is this Economics as well as Sociology? • “Values” = Views about what people should do. • What people think they should do has a big effect on what they actually do. Thus, people’s views about what should be done are an important preference parameter. (Akerlof) • Religion clearly influences values in this sense and a great deal of evidence shows it affects choices. Thus it affects preferences.

  30. 3 Origin Questions What determines: • The available technology? • The structure of strategic interactions? • Preferences?

  31. Where do preferences come from? • Genes • Culture • From parents • From others

  32. Implications of Evolution for Social Theory • In steady state, it is as if each replicating entity has a utility function it is maximizing • Organisms • Humans • Animals • Plants • Design Plans • Genes • Ideas (Dawkin’s “Memes”) • Groups • Quantitatively, group selection requires equilibrium within the group. • Out of steady state, track population dynamics.

  33. Explaining Trends in Religiosity • More religious people have more children • Thus, in terms of transmission of religiosity from parents to children, there is selection pressure toward greater religiosity. • The only way religiosity will not trend upwards is if there is some other influence pulling religiosity down. • Simple regression to the mean? • Influence of schooling? • Influence of the media?

More Related