State of Education

1. State of Education

2. Urban vs. Suburban Graduation Rates 2005

3. Worst High School Graduation Rates of 50 Largest Cities Omaha, NE 55.1% Houston 54.6 Portland, OR 53.6 Las Vegas 53.1 San Antonio 51.9 Chicago 51.5 Tulsa 50.6 Jacksonville 50.2 Philadelphia 49.6 Miami 49.0 Oklahoma City 47.5 Denver 46.3 Milwaukee 46.1% Atlanta 46.1 Kansas City, MO 45.7 Oakland, CA 45.6 Los Angeles 45.3 New York 45.2 Dallas 44.4 Minneapolis, MN 43.7 Columbus 40.9 Baltimore 34.6 Cleveland 34.1 Indianapolis 30.5 GRAND PRIZE – Detroit 24.9% America’s Promise Alliance 2008

4. K-12 Education Cost vs. Achievement of 17-year-olds since 1970

5. Public School Enrollment vs. Public School Employment Since 1970

6. Tracking Graduation Rates http://apps.arcwebservices.com/edweekv3/default.jsp

7. Education Shapes Economics

8. UNEMPLOYMENT STATUS VS. EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND HS Diploma HS Graduate

9. The History of Retirement

10. History of Retirement Retirement: a complete and permanent withdrawal from paid labor. Historically, retirement has been solely for the rich, however, since 1880 there has been a steady increase in retirement rates. If the current retirement trend continues, 20 year olds today in the US, UK, France and Germany can expect to live 1/3 of their lives in retirement.

11. Union Pensions Union army veterans retired at a higher rate at all ages than the general public. Union pensions reflect a pure income effect on labor supply. In 1900, a 1% increase in pension benefits increased retirement rates by .73%.

12. % of Population Aged65 and Older Source: Evolution of Retirement, Costa.

13. Labor Force Participation Rates of Men Age 65 and Over US UK France Germany Source: Evolution of Retirement, Costa.

14. Why 65? “Age 65 is generally set as the threshold of old age since it is at this period of life that the rates for sickness and death begin to show a marked increase over those of the earlier years” -Issac Rubinow, 1916 “It is a commonplace fact that physical ability, mental alertness and cooperativeness tend to fail after a man is 65” -Federal Government before the Supreme Court, 1936

15. Age Discrimination Retirement rates increased from age discrimination at the beginning of the 20th century resulting from: Shorter workdays Scientific Management

16. Social Security and The New Deal Social Security was intended to provide benefits to retirees and unemployed Social Security was also intended to stimulate consumption -higher wages -reduced work hours -limitations on working ages for older and young workers All of the above modes of increasing consumption made their way into New Deal programs

17. Importance of Social Security Benefits to Those Aged 65+ 34% 35% 90% to 100% of Income Less than 50% of Income 50% to 90% of Income 31% Source: SSA 2005

18. Who We Support Today with Entitlement Spending Population currently over 65 Thousands

19. Population over 65 by 2025 Who We Will Support in the Future Population currently over 65 Thousands

20. Unfunded Entitlement Obligations In $trillions Includes Social Security and Medicare $46 trillion Addition of Medicare Part D Source: The White House, US Treasury

21. The Death of Pensions The Wave of Retiring Baby Boomers Will Affect Us All, Potentially Causing:

22. The Goodyear Model Strike new deal with union (USW here, UAW for GM/Ford/Chrysler Agree to fund VEBA (Voluntary Employee Benefit Association) Trust Put in LESS than needed for full benefits Dilute current shareholders Strap company for cash Use excess earnings from pension Make unions relevant

23. PBGC Took More Risk at Exactly the Wrong Time “The Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation (PBGC) announced February 18 [2008] that it has adopted a new diversified investment policy, which includes investing heavier in equities and alternative investments, to help ensure the federal insurance program can meet its long-term obligations to America’s retirees.”

24. PBGC Took More Risk at Exactly the Wrong Time …said PBGC Director Charles Millard in a release. “The new investment policy adopted by the PBGC Board of Directors will better manage our invested assets. Although it should generate higher returns, it also offers lower risk through broader diversification. This strategy gives the Corporation a 57% likelihood of full funding within ten years, compared to 19% under the previous policy.” Moved equities from 28% of portfolio to 45% PBGC Diversifies Investment Policies, Melanie Waddell, Investment News, February 20, 2008

25. Video Can You Afford to Retire?

26. BREAK

27. www.dilbert.com

28. The State of the States

29. State Pension Funding Levels 2008 Source: Pew Center, The Trillion Dollar Gap, February 2010

30. Estimated State Government OPEB Funding Source: Pew Center, The Trillion Dollar Gap, February 2010

31. Scorecard For States

32. Comparing Pension & OPEB Funding and Liabilities

33. Bargaining With Public Employees After Wagner Act (private unionization), public employees petitioned for same right, they were denied by FDR JFK signed executive order #10988, which allowed collective bargaining by public employees – setting up current failure of system

34. State and Local Government Revenues Source: Internal Revenue Service

35. Income and Sales Tax Dropped, but Almost Back Source: Rockefeller Institute, State Revenue Report; February, 2011

36. State Budget Gaps Source: CBO & Pew Center

37. The “State” of California www.lao.ca.gov

38. What States Are Doing About It

39. Tax Receipts Will Decline Most taxes come from levies on three things: Income (personal and corporate) Consumption (sales, vehicle, fuel, etc.) Assets (property, inventory, etc.) All three main areas are in decline Article #31, DOT

40. So States Are Raising Rates Revenue Increases Have Helped to Lessen Cuts to Services Several states facing large budget shortfalls have averted deep cuts in vital services by enacting temporary or permanent revenue increases. In late 2007 and 2008, some ten states enacted tax increases, closed loopholes, restricted tax credits, or implemented other revenue-raising measures. Major packages were enacted in Maryland, Michigan, and New York. Since the recession began, over 30 states have raised taxes, sometimes quite significantly. Increases have been enacted or are under consideration in personal income, business, sales, and excise taxes. Major state revenue packages have been enacted in California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Hawaii, Nevada, New York, North Carolina, Washington and Wisconsin, among other states. Center on Budget Policy & Priorities, 8/4/10

41. Money Flows, But at What Cost? Source: Rockefeller Institute, State Revenue Report; February, 2011

42. A Helping Hand From Uncle Sam More subsidies paid to states (California’s current budget ASSUMES $7 billion) Federal guarantee program for municipal bonds, linked to a “fiscal responsibility plan”

43. The Federal Government

44. Taxes and the Rich Source: IRS, Statistics of Income, 2008

45. 2006 Federal Tax Schedule 35% 33% 28% 25% 15% 10% $7,550 S $15,100 M $30,650 S $61,300 M $74,200 S $123,700 M $154,800 S $188,450 M $336,550 S $336,550 M

46. Top Federal Individual Income Tax Rates 1913 - 2010 Percentage Source: IRS

47. Federal Tax Schedule: 1980 vs. 2006 Marginal Rates for Single Taxpayer (1980 Tax Brackets adjusted for inflation) $7,550 S $15,100 M $30,650 S $61,300 M $74,200 S $123,700 M $154,800 S $188,450 M $336,550 S $336,550 M Source: IRS (Inflation Adjustments made by HS Dent using BLS data)

48. What the Future Holds

49. Total United States Debt Government $14Trn Financial $17Trn Corporate $11Trn Consumer $14Trn Total: $56 Trn ! Source: Federal Reserve Flow of Funds Report

50. Household Debt as % of Disposable Income, 1946-2009