210 likes | 319 Views
Converting From Daily Fee to Private. PGA Orlando, 2011. Gary Dee Executive Vice President Heritage Golf Group. 6 Yrs: Apprentice (High End Private) 5 Yrs: Head Professional (Resort/DF) 3 Yrs: Gen. Manager (DF & High End Private) 4 Yrs: Exec. w/ PGA TOUR 17 Yrs: Exec. w/ CGG & HGG
E N D
Converting From Daily Fee to Private PGA Orlando, 2011
Gary DeeExecutive Vice PresidentHeritage Golf Group • 6 Yrs: Apprentice (High End Private) • 5 Yrs: Head Professional (Resort/DF) • 3 Yrs: Gen. Manager (DF & High End Private) • 4 Yrs: Exec. w/ PGA TOUR • 17 Yrs: Exec. w/ CGG & HGG • 1978 Elected to PGA Membership • Team Member Involved in Approx. 75 Clubs
Overview • Executive Summary • Key Considerations
Executive Summary • Conversions = Tricky Business • 3 Actual Case Studies • 2 w/Excellent Results • 1 Stalled (1/2 Pregnant)
Key Considerations • General • Market Analysis • Timeline for Conversion • Capital Improvements • Transition Plan • Membership Related • After the Conversion • Pitfalls to Avoid • P/L Comparison
General • Zoning • Restrictive Covenants • Developer Agreements • Statutory Restrictions
Market Analysis • Private Club Competition • Within 5 miles • Within 10 miles • Sales Potential • Price Points
Timeline for Conversion • How Long Will a Conversion take? • Will Improvements Need to be Added at Certain Membership Levels? • The Quicker the Better
Actual Legacy Conversion Process • Initiated Process in September, 2004 • Completed Conversion in June, 2006 • Total Elapsed Time: 21 Months • Went From 225 Members to 400 Members
Capital Improvements • Improvements Needed to be Competitive ? • Clubhouse • Locker Rooms • Golf Course • Careful Not to Overspend • Add Upgrades Only to the Level Necessary • Avoid the Natural Tendency to Make it “Too Nice” • Essential to Identify “Members Only” Space FOR SALE
Actual Legacy Club Improvements • Added New Men’s Locker Room • Expanded Ladies Locker Room • Expanded Clubhouse Grill Area • Added New Free Standing Golf Shop • Expanded Clubhouse Dining • Enhanced Practice Area; Bunkers; Greens • Total Upgrades Cost @ $3.2 M; 3 Phases
Transition Plan • How Many to Sell? • “Triggers” Along the Way • Blocks of User Times • “Phasing” of Times • For Improvements • Fully Private When? • Member Communication • Member Referral Programs • “Members Only” Space Essential
Membership Specific • Types of Memberships • Pricing • Initiation Fees • Monthly Dues • Accompanied GF Rate • Refund Rules • Resign List Procedures • Documents Needed • Application • Bylaws • Feature Sheets • FAQs
After the Conversion • Consider Complexity • Private Segment is No Picnic • Member Advisory Board • Bylaws • Marketing Materials • Potential for Litigation
Pitfalls to Avoid • ½ Pregnant • Serving Two “Masters” • Daily Fee Cutoff Point • The Blame Game • Over Upgrading • Delusions of Grandeur • Watch Private F/B Like a Hawk • Securities Violations for IF Uses
P/L Comparison • Improved Operating Results are Possible When Everything Works Right • The Next Slide Shows Actual Results
What if You Miss? • Selling Initiation Fees at $5 k Instead of $15 – $20 k • Dense Real Estate Surrounding but “House Poor” • Locker Rooms Not Added Prior • Sluggish Economy • Other Private Clubs Nearby • Now Serving Two Masters