1 / 14

Selling Your Soul for Science

Selling Your Soul for Science. Notes on Being an NSF GK-12 Fellow By Ted Pavlic Wednesday, May 30, 2007. Agenda. About: Definitions, Mission, Topics Fellowship Benefits and Requirements Conclusions: Reflections, Pros, and Cons Questions. Some Definitions.

forest
Download Presentation

Selling Your Soul for Science

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Selling Your Soul for Science Notes on Being an NSF GK-12 Fellow By Ted Pavlic Wednesday, May 30, 2007

  2. Agenda • About: Definitions, Mission, Topics • Fellowship Benefits and Requirements • Conclusions: Reflections, Pros, and Cons • Questions

  3. Some Definitions • NSF: National Science Foundation • GK-12: Graduate Teaching Fellows in K-12 Education • GRFP: Graduate Research Fellowship Program • STEM: Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics • CPS: Columbus Public Schools • NCLB: No Child Left Behind (“nickel-be”)* • EOY: End Of Year • PI: Principal Investigator • PC: Program Coordinator *Reference to Nicholas Nickleby, Charles Dickens novel & 2002 Douglas McGrath movie (see also: Hard Times).

  4. Synopsis from NSF* • Provides funding to STEM graduate students to . . . • acquire additional skills to prepare for 21st century careers • improve communication, teaching, collaboration, and team building skills • enrich STEM learning and instruction in K-12 schools • gain a deeper understanding of own STEM research • Encourages universities to add inquiry-based learning to STEM graduate programs • Strengthened and sustained partnerships in STEM between universities and local school districts *Summarized from http://www.nsf.gov/funding/pgm_summ.jsp?pims_id=5472.

  5. Scientific Inquiry* Repackaging of scientific method for use in teaching • Motivate students to ask a question • Develop hypotheses • Test them • Draw conclusions • Show that process should continue possibly forever *Image taken from http://acept.asu.edu/courses/phs110/si/chapter1/main.html.

  6. OSU GK-12 • Collaboration with CPS • Focus on 3rd, 4th, and 5th grade students • 9-11 year old students • Each fellow paired with two teachers • Usually different schools • Usually different grades • Huge testing pressures • NCLB • NSF reporting • Job is NOT to teach students!

  7. Topics to Teach • Grade 3 • Earth Science: Properties/composition of rocks and soils • Life Science: Animal life cycles, morphological classification, habitat, adaptations • Grade 4 • Matter: Physical and chemical properties • Life Science: Plant life cycle, parts, adaptations, habitat • Earth Science: Water, weather, geological processes • Grade 5 • Earth Science: Solar system • Life Science: Food chains, webs • Physical Science: Electricity, energy, light/sound waves • Design Process: positive and negative impacts of technology • Common Elements • Observation, Measuring, Classification • Communication • Technology and Careers

  8. Concrete Fellowship Benefits • Bona fide NSF fellowship • Looks great on a CV • 12-month NSF GRFP level stipend (e.g., $2500/month) • 12-month tuition • Administered by OSU • Fewer applicants = Better award chances • Delivery via OSU payroll = Funded graduate student health insurance subsidy (note: after tax deduction) • 1099 Income • No social security or PERS (+?) • File estimated taxes quarterly (-) • Easy to milk/exploit social service aspect • Looks great on CV • Social do-gooders attract public attention (for personal gain)

  9. Fellowship Time Requirements • Time Requirements • 10 hours per week in classroom • 5+ hours per week for lesson planning and development • 1 hour biweekly meeting of fellows and PI’s • 2 half-day focus meetings (January and May) • 1 hour EOY summary of experience (e.g., right now) • ~4 half-day training meetings as trainees (June) • ~2 half-day training meetings as trainers (June) • Adviser requirements • Adviser must visit classroom once per semester • Adviser must meet with PC at EOY

  10. Fellowship Deliverables • On-line Course: Human Research(once for 2-3 hours) • On-line NSF EOY survey(once for 0.5 hour) • Pre-test and post-test data (one per quarter) • Lesson plans: MS Word chemistry-lab format (one per week (ish)) • Biweekly reports: one page form (one every two weeks) • Presentations: focus meetings and EOY summary (three total) • Possible additional tracking information

  11. Heart of Educational Darkness* • Classroom control • NCLB always an obstacle (spinning out of control) • Testing pressures are huge • Schedules/resources frequently change • Teacher expertise in wrong areas • Homework not an option • Schools serve as foster parents • Cannot count on parent involvement • Inquiry-based teaching incompatible with testing requirements • Program mission: avoid teaching to test • Program performance measures: test • NSF reporting (contradictory) • NCLB requires high test scores • How to teach vocabulary and inquiry? *Reference to Joseph Conrad’s The Heart of Darkness(see also F. F. Coppola’s 1979 Apocalypse Now).

  12. Pros and Cons • Pros • Interface with graduate students from other fields • Financially attractive • Learn about inner-city public schools • Expand content knowledge to surprising extent • Cons • Can be a major time burden • Can lead to an attenuated sense of personal efficacy • Future • Continuously improving fellowship experience • Web resources getting better • PI’s and PC sincerely want to make program a success

  13. Conclusions (“Selling Your Soul for Science”) • Investment • Time • Energy • Returns • Cash / CV • Expanded content knowledge • Expanded awareness • Impact on teachers’ future lessons • Hopefully plant seeds of citizen scientists

  14. Questions? • For more information . . . • NSF GK-12 Website: http://www.nsfgk12.org/ • OSU GK-12 Website: http://gk-12.osu.edu/ • OSU GK-12 Program Coordinator • Mary Allison Timby (“Mary Allison”) • (614) 688-0501 • mtimby@chemistry.ohio-state.edu • Ted Pavlic: pavlic.3@osu.edu

More Related