210 likes | 892 Views
STAGED COLUMN DESIGN. K. M. Tanvir Ahmmed Lecturer, ChE, BUET. TYPES OF TRAY. Bubble cap tray : old Sieve tray : simple Valve tray : modern usage. BUBBLE CAP TRAY. BUBBLE CAP TRAY. Advantages flexible : operates satisfactorily at very high and low liquid flow rates. Disadvantages
E N D
STAGED COLUMN DESIGN K. M. Tanvir Ahmmed Lecturer, ChE, BUET
TYPES OF TRAY Bubble cap tray : old Sieve tray : simple Valve tray : modern usage
BUBBLE CAP TRAY • Advantages • flexible : operates satisfactorily at very high and low liquid flow rates • Disadvantages • high entrainment: requires higher tray spacing • significant liquid gradient • problems with coking, high fouling mixtures • expensive • Poor turndown performance
SIEVE TRAY (CONT’D) • Advantages • easy to manufacture • inexpensive • considerable design information is available • efficiency is good at design condition • very good in fouling applications • Disadvantages • turndown is poor (efficiency falls below the design condition) • not flexible
VALVE TRAY (CONT’D) • Advantages • better turndown ratio • more flexible • new industrial columns are more likely to have valve trays • Disadvantages • Higher pressure drop than sieve tray • 20% more expensive than sieve tray • more likely to foul or plug in case of dirty mixtures