160 likes | 316 Views
What does Security have to do with Errors in Healthcare?. Jim Williams Presented to CORBAmed at the June 1998 meeting of the OMG in Orlando. Public Awareness, Conferences, and Policy. 100 million Americans touched by medical error Enhancing patient safety and reducing errors in healthcare
E N D
What does Security have to do with Errors in Healthcare? Jim Williams Presented to CORBAmed at the June 1998 meeting of the OMG in Orlando
Public Awareness, Conferences, and Policy • 100 million Americans touched by medical error • Enhancing patient safety and reducing errors in healthcare The Annenberg Center Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations American Association for the Advancement of Science Department of Veterans Affairs The National Patient Safety Foundation • President’s Commission on Healthcare Quality • ... an unacceptable level of errors
Scope and Organization • (Background) • Sound information handling applied to healthcare • The error-handling objective • Error-handling roles • Technical requirements • Sound information handling applied to HIPAA • Conclusions and Implications for CORBA security • Key references
The Error Handling Objective initial falsely input certified error input chronological history of certified inputs and warranted outputs falsely warranted revocations outputs (discovery) restoration
Structure of Sound Information Handling revocations Input Application Certification Processing warranted outputs ? error reports Basis Tracking and basis descriptions Error Handling ? invalidating inputs
Technical Requirements (1 of 3) Assertions and instructions are cast in stable form • Their meaning doesn't depend on context Integrity-validation checks are performed on inputs • Checking for adverse drug interactions • (Size of problem: 120,000 deaths/year) • Approaching universal availability Integrity validators must themselves be validated ?
Technical Requirements (2 of 3) Pre-existing basis for resolving error reports • Auditing of physician and patient activities • Automated clinical pathways Antecedent causes of confirmed errors are investigated • Investigative path can be arbitrarily long • If all patient errors are modeled, the root cause of errors in healthcare is illness ?
Technical Requirements (3 of 3) Error retractions minimize damage, halt error propagation • It’s the right thing to do • It reduces malpractice risk Error retractions propagate with higher priority than errors ?
Conclusions Rapid progress in dealing with healthcare errors Theory of sound information handling empirically validated HIPAA requirements support sound information handling and the control of errors in healthcare
What CORBA Security Needs toSupport Error Handling Flexible role-based access control for integrity validation Generalized access mediation • Can’t reject an entire patient record because one blood test was taken on April 31 Auditing for basis information • Application-based data generation • Query the sources of a result for cause of error • Query known uses of a resource for error retraction Warranting of outputs • Security attributes for data quality
Additional Reading • NPSF bibliography • Williams, Sound Information Handling: Application to Errors in Medicine • Williams and LaPadula, Modeling External Consistency of Automated Systems • Lucian L. Leape, Error in Medicine