150 likes | 280 Views
Coronal hard X-ray sources and associated decimetric/metric radio emissions. N. Vilmer D. Koutroumpa (Observatoire de Paris- LESIA) S.R Kane G. Hurford (Space Sciences Laboratory Berkeley). HXR in solar flares acceleration and propagation of energetic electrons interacting at the Sun
E N D
Coronal hard X-ray sources and associated decimetric/metric radio emissions N. Vilmer D. Koutroumpa (Observatoire de Paris- LESIA) S.R Kane G. Hurford (Space Sciences Laboratory Berkeley)
HXR in solar flares acceleration and propagation of energetic electrons • interacting at the Sun • Bulk of HXR emission from footpoints of flaring B loops by electrons accelerated • in the low corona (109-1010 cm-3) near the loop top • YOHKOH/HXT coronal above the loop top > 30 keV X-ray • sources in impulsive flares (Masuda, 1994; Masuda et al., 1998) • (< 6 events) • Compact above the loop top source together with double footpoint sources • 10’’ above the SXR loop apex • Relatively hard spectrum • Located at slightly higher altitudes at higher X-ray energies. • 1 event (Sato, 2001) without footpoints • Extended source above 30 keV at h> 5104km From Masuda et al 1998
Interpretation in the scheme of magnetic reconnection above (outside the bright soft X-ray loop) the loop top: • energization of electrons in the • reconnection site itself or • at the place where the downward hot plasma from the reconnection site collides with underlying closed B loops • Different types of interpretation for reconnection sites: • Loop with a cusp configuration (Masuda) • Emerging flux type configuration • Loop-loop reconnection cartoon from Masuda et al, 1998 • Here observations of coronal above the loop top HXR sources with • RHESSI and time evolution in the flare
GOES M2.5 AR 9893 AR 9893 N21 W81 large part behind the limb H 1310-1320-1332 N23 W88 SF AR 9893 < 1323- 1338 N19 W67 SF AR9901 H 8 days earlier Coronal HXR source from 13:07 UT
RHESSI images 12-25 keV • 10’’ above the limb • after 1307 UT
movie_trace+hessi1225.htmlmovie_trace+hessi2550.html Comparison of RHESSI images with TRACE images at 195 Å =flare plasma at 15 MK • TRACE and RHESSI 12-25 keV images before 13:07 UT • (no coronal HXR sources) • movie_trace+hessi1225_125500.html • TRACE and RHESSI 12-25 keV and 25-50 keV images • after 13:07 UT • (coronal HXR of the event sources with most of the time no footpoints Most energetic part )
Associated radio emissions?? 6-12 keV RHESSI • Gyrosynchrotron emission from energetic flare associated electrons in the cm/mm domain Observations at 3 from Bern Similarity between durations of 30 keV HXR and cm emissions from energetic electrons (as usually observed) 12-25 keV 25-50 keV 19.6 GHz 11.8 GHz 8.4 GHz
Coherent radio emissions in dm/m wavelengths Spectrum ETH Zürich Radio type III bursts e beams in the corona limited range (< 350 MHz) limited time range (30 s) NRH 327 MHz Flux at 3 in the flare region from the Nançay Radioheliograph + Images at 327 MHz NRH 236 MHz NRH 164 MHz
3-6 keV 6-12 keV 12-25 keV Limited duration of Associated dm emissions Consistent with the observations that 10 to 15 % of HXR producing electrons have no detectable emission at decimeter and longer wavelengths (e.g. Simnett and Benz, 1986).t 25-50 keV 327 MHz
NRH 327 MHz during 4 bursts Between 131120 and 131140 RHESSI 25-50 keV
NRH 327 MHz during 4 bursts Between 131120 and 131140 RHESSI 25-50 keV
In the most energetic part of the HXR event, coronal HXR sources with no (permanent) footpoints Coronal HXR sources (> 10’’ ) above the limb, displaced (above) the hot magnetic structures seen with TRACE 25-50 keV coronal sources above 12-25 keV sources Consistent with the previous (~ 6 ) observations with YOHKOH/HXT More dynamic behaviour: from TRACE observations, suggestion of loop-loop interactions between 2 loop systems with one system apparently connected to parts of the AR behind the limb . Appearance of the coronal sources and of the most energetic part of the event at the time of the interaction. No footpoints: most of the loop structures connected to parts behind the limb. Only the emission from the region close to the reconnection sites(s) but rather loop-loop reconnections. Summary/discussion
cm and HXR emission: gyrosynchrotron emission from electrons in low-lying B loops • Most of the event: no dm/m emissions • No electron access to high or open B field lines seen from the earth • Energetic electrons are only present in small scale loops as seen from the earth • After abrupt reformation of low lying B field lines through sequence of loop-loop interactions, the B field reconfiguration may extend over larger distances and reach overlying open field lines seen from the earth : • possible acceleration sites for radio emitting electrons • Radio dm/m emissions at the time of appearance of second component of 25-50 keV source indicating displacement of energy release site and possible electron access to new B lines. e-beams X-rays Simple 2D sketch More complex at 3D with several loop systems as suggested by TRACE