770 likes | 1.1k Views
IRCCS Ospedale San Raffaele Milano Università Vita-Salute San Raffaele. Peri-operative cardiac protection. Tutorial in General Anesthesia, Milano, 28 Marzo 2009. Relatore: Dott. Giovanni Landoni. Cardioprotection & anaesthesia Volatile Anesthetics. b blockers “recommended”
E N D
IRCCS Ospedale San Raffaele Milano Università Vita-Salute San Raffaele Peri-operativecardiacprotection Tutorial in General Anesthesia, Milano, 28 Marzo 2009 Relatore: Dott. Giovanni Landoni
Cardioprotection & anaesthesiaVolatile Anesthetics • b blockers“recommended” • Statins “suggested” in selected pts • a2 agonists “may be considered” in selected pts • Ca++ antagonists “may be considered” in selected pts • Insulin “reasonable” in hyperglycaemic pts • Volatile Anesthetics “can be beneficial”
REDUCING PERIOPERATIVE MYOCARDIAL INFARCTION • EPIDURAL ANESTHESIA (non-cardiac surgery) • BETA BLOCKERS (non-cardiac surgery) ??!! • VOLATILE AGENTS (cardiac surgery) • LEVOSIMENDAN (cardiac surgery)
REDUCING PERIOPERATIVE MORTALITY AND MYOCARDIAL INFARCTION • VOLATILE AGENTS (cardiac surgery) • LEVOSIMENDAN (cardiac surgery)
REDUCING PERIOPERATIVE MORTALITY • FENOLDOPAM • PEXELIZUMAB (cardiac surgery) • DOPEXAMINE • EARLY ENTERAL NUTRITION (intestinal surgery) • INSULINE !!?? • STATINS
Anaesthesia and Outcome Volatile Anesthetics Could VOLATILE anaesthetics influence outcome? Could VOLATILE anaesthetics have non-anaesthetic properties?
Evidence? IMeta-analysis and/or large randomized studies II Randomized trials III Non-randomized prospective trials IV Retrospective studies V Case reports and Expert Opinion VI Animal / Laboratories Studies
META-ANALYSIS(cardiac anaesthesia) • 22 randomized studies (15 CPB-CABG; 6 OP-CABG; 1 mitral valve surgery) • 1922 patients (904 TIVA and 1018 DES or SEVO) • 16 studies administered volatile anesthetics throughout all the procedure (6 studies for 5-30 minutes)
Evidence! Mortality
Evidence! Mortality • 4/977=0.4% v 14/872=1.6% • NNT=84 • RRR=(1,6-0,4)/1,6=75% • OR: 0.31(0.12-0.80) • P=0.02
Mortality NNT=84 Treat 84 to save one
Evidence! Myocardial infarction
Evidence! Myocardial infarction • 24/979=2.4% v 45/874=5.1% • NNT=37 • RRR: (5.1-2.4)/5.1 = 53% • OR: 0.51(0.32-0.84) • p=0.008
Myocardial infarction NNT=37 Treat 37 to save one
Evidence! PEAK CARDIAC TROPONIN I WMD -2.35 ng/dL [-3.09,-1.60], p<0.00001
Evidence! INOTROPE USE IN ICU OR 0.47 [0.29, 0.76], p < 0.002
Evidence! Mechanical ventilation WMD -0.49 hours [-0.97,-0.02], p = 0.4
Evidence! ICU STAY WMD -7.10 hours [-11.47,-2.73], p < 0.001
Evidence! HOSPITAL STAY WMD -2.26 days [-3.83,-0.68], p = 0.005
Conclusions: Volatile Anesthetics in cardiac surgery Sevoflurane&Desflurane: ↓post cardiac surgery mortality Desflurane in CABG surgery: • ↓postoperative cTnI release • ↓postoperative inotropic support • ↓hospitalization +/- cardiopulmonary bypass Volatile Anesthetics Direct and indirect protection
A meta-analysis in noncardiac surgery Evidence? 6219 patients 2842 sevoflurane 609 desflurane 2768 propofol
4281 citations retrieved from database searches 3936 titles/abstracts excluded because non-relevant 344 studies assessed according to the selection criteria 265 studies excluded according to explicit exclusion criteria 35 duplicate reports 51 no TIVA group 75 cardiac surgery 46 retrospective 25 non randomised 21 paediatric 12 not available 79 Randomised Controlled Trials finally included in the systematic review Evidence? A meta-analysis in noncardiac surgery
Evidence? A meta-analysis in noncardiac surgery Total 79 Anesth analg 20 BJA 14 EJA 11 Acta anaesthesiol scand 8 Anaesthesia 5 J Anesth 4 Anesthesiology 3 Minerva anestesiol 2 Altri 13
Evidence? A meta-analysis in noncardiac surgery • 400 authors • 240 reviewers • 90 editors 0 deaths 0 myocardial infarctions
Have we forgotten about CARDIAC MORBIDITY and MORTALITY in noncardiac surgery?
SEVOFLURANE IN STENTING PROCEDURES: A RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED STUDY. METHODS 30 patients 20’ 16 SEVOFLURANE 0,5 MAC + oxygen/air 14 Oxygen/air PTCA+stenting Endpoint primario: TnI postprocedurale
SEVOFLURANE IN STENTING PROCEDURES: A RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED STUDY. RESULTS SEVOFLURANE TnI, median (25°-75° percentile) 0.15 (0-4.73) ng/dl PLACEBO TnI, median (25°-75° percentile) 0.14 (0-0.87) ng/dl vs P = 0,4 Landoni et al. JCVA 2008
Take home message • RCTs should confirm the promisingresults of volatile anesthetics in noncardiac surgery • Cardiac Troponin I couldbe anexcellent intermediate (surrogate?) outcome in cardiac and non-cardiac high risk surgical patients