400 likes | 1.46k Views
Regionalism in Asia. April 27, 2006 Regional Anatomy I Ken JIMBO. Mid-term Report. Select One from following Five Topics on ‘ Regionalism ’ ‘ Regionalism and Regionalization in Asia (or in certain region) ’ ‘ Open-Regionalism ’ vs. ‘ Bilateral Networks ’ : Comparative Analysis
E N D
Regionalism in Asia April 27, 2006 Regional Anatomy I Ken JIMBO
Mid-term Report • Select One from following Five Topics on ‘Regionalism’ • ‘Regionalism and Regionalization in Asia (or in certain region)’ • ‘Open-Regionalism’ vs. ‘Bilateral Networks’: Comparative Analysis • Rise of FTA/EPA in World Economy • Economic Integration and Regionalism • Security Interdependence and Regionalism • Socio-Cultural Interaction and Regionalism • Essay Guidance • Essay Length: 1200 words (minimum) ⇒ academic format • Essay Deadline: 31st March, 2006 • Software: Microsoft Word (Attached File) • To be Submitted to: kenj@sfc.keio.ac.jp
Review 1)Three Waves of Regionalism • The First Wave (1950-60s) • Between small and medium States • Failure in achieving economic development • The Second Wave (1980-90s) • ‘Open Regionalism’‘Inclusive (nested) Mechanism’ • Stunted Progress (early marginalization) • The Third Wave (2000s-?) • Bundle of ‘bilateral networks’ • Regional endorsement of ‘ad-hoc mechanisms’
Review 2)Rise of the Third Wave of Regionalism? Level of Cooperation/ Integration Third Wave Regionalism ? Second Wave Regionalism Timelines
Review 3)Globalism / Regionalism / Bilateralism and the ‘Recursion’ of the Region Economic Sphere Security Sphere Global FrameworkGATT / IMF UN / Multinational Mega-Regionalism APEC ARF / OSCE Regionalism EU / ASEAN +3 EU / ASEAN Coalition Multilateral FTAs Anti-Terrorism Bilateralism Bilateral FTAs Bilateral Alliance
Evolution of Regional Integration State Integration Degree of Integration Economic Union EU Common Market euro(2002) F Affairs &Defense C. Economic Policies C. Market & Infra FTA(1958- ) BENELUX Tariff U (’55) Free Trade Area: FTA MERCOSUR Tariff Union NAFTA Free Inv. & Service C.Economic Policies C. Tariff Custom Union(‘86- ) AFTA Free Inv. & Services FTA(1989- ) FTA(1992- ) ASEAN-6(’67) ASEAN-10(’99) + China (2010?) USA+Canada(’92) +Mexico(’94) B&A + P&U(’95) EEC-6(’58) EU-12(’86) EU-15(’95) EU-27 ? FTAA-34 ? (2005?) ASEAN=21% 54% 21% 62% East Asia=40% ------ INTRA-REGIONAL TRADE SHARE (%) OUT OF TOTAL TRADE -------- Source: Kakazu + TY
Regionalism in AsiaGeneral Perspective • Cultural Diversity • Language • Religion • Historical Backgrounds • Pre-Modern Asia (-1840?) • China-centric (tributary) regional order • Modern Asia • Great power imperialism (1840-1945) • Greater East Asia Co-Prosperity Sphere (1920-1945)
Post-WWII and Asia • Decolonization and Nation Building • Sovereignty and Nation Building • Economic Re-construction • Cold War Fragmentation • China Civil War (1947-49) • Korean War (1950-53) • Vietnam War (1965-74)
Post-Cold War ExperienceEurope and Asia Compared • In Europe, both the security (NATO) and economic structures (EEC→EC) created the basis for subsequent institutionalization of intra-European ties • Many of America’s Asian allies had far stronger ties across the Pacific than they had among themselves
Cold War Structure and Asia • Alliance Structure • Europe: NATO • Asia: Bilateral Alliances (San Francisco System) plus SEATO and ANZUS • Threat Perception • Europe: USSR + Eastern Europe • Asia: USSR / China / North Korea / North Vietnam
US-led Alliance System (Cold War) Warsaw Pact NATO European Theater (Regional Approach) Asian Theater (Bilateral Approach) Bilateral (Hub-Spokes) Alliances
Major Conflicts in Asia • Northeast Asia • Divided Korea • Divided China • Sino-USSR Confrontation • Southeast Asia • Sino-Vietnam Confrontation • Sino-India Confrontation • Internal Revolt (communism, fundamentalism)
Wake of ‘Regionalization’ in Asia • ‘De Facto’ Economic Integration • Japan’s Economic Success • Foreign aid, trade, investment and technology transfe • ‘Flying Geese’ Model (Kojima, 2001) • Production Networks • Fragmentation Model • Production Cycle Model (R. Vernon, 1966) • Benefit of export-oriented ‘late comer’ • ASEAN Integration (Political/Economic) • Bali Concord / TAC • AFTA / ASEAN 10 • ASEAN Community (economic/security/socio-cultural)
Flying Geese Model (1) Source: http://www.grips.ac.jp/module/prsp/FGeese.htm
Flying Geese Model (2) Source: http://www.grips.ac.jp/module/prsp/FGeese.htm
De Facto Economic Integration (1980) 319.1 207.9 409.1 276.7 615.9 428.5 366.9 72.8 198.0 366.6 239.1 Asia Europe 274.0 (unit:onehundredmilliondollars)
De Facto Economic Integration (2000) 1440.1 (4.5times) 645.1 (3.1times) 2140.9 (5.2times) 1333.1 (4.8times) 1645.9 (2.7times) 3114.2 (7.3times) 1973.1 (5.4times) 72.8 1249.2 (5.2times) 484.6 (4.0)times 1684.3 (4.6times) Asia 2193.1 (8.0times) (unit:onehundredmilliondollars)
ASEAN’s Regionalization Process • Chronology • 1967: Bangkok Declaration • 1971: Zone of Peace, Freedom, and Neutrality (ZOPFAN) • 1976: Treaty of Amity and Cooperation (TAC) • 1976: ASEAN Concord I • 1992: ASEAN Declaration on the South China Sea • 1995: Treaty on the Southeast Asia Nuclear Weapon-Free Zone • 1997: ASEAN Vision 2020 • 2003: ASEAN Concord II • ASEAN (Bali) Concord II and ASEAN Community • ASEAN Economic Community • ASEAN Security Community • ASEAN Socio-Cultural Community
ARF Process(Rise of Second Wave) Mechanism for Conflict Resolution Preventive Diplomacy (PD) Confidence Building (CBM)
Four Drivers of East Asian Linkages • Governments • In European regionalism, the focus on national governments is a given. Multinational governmental cooperation results in formal regional organizations. • In Asia, although governments have been key players, regional integration were not always driven by formal process. • Corporations • Regional trade, investment and cross-national production networks.
Four Drivers of East Asian Linkages (contd.) • Functional Cooperation • Ad-hoc Problem-oriented Bodies • Growing Middle-class Networks • Similar Life-style • Common Social Security Concerns • Middle Class Culture Sharing • “Standard Package” (car, TV, video, PC, cosmetics…etc)
Reference • T.J. Pempel, “Introduction: Emerging Webs of Regional Connectedness” T.J. Pempel ed., Remapping East Asia: The Construction of a Region (Cornell University Press, 2005) • Etel Solingen “East Asian Regional Institutions: Characteristics, Sources, Distinctiveness” T.J. Pempel Ed., op.cit. • Paul Evans, “Between Regionalism and Regionalization: Policy Networks and the Nascent East Asian Institutional Identity” T.J. Pempel ed., op.cit. • Edward Lincoln, East Asian Economic Regionalism (Brookings Institution Press, 2004) • Peter J. Katzenstein, World of Regions: Asia and Europe in the American Imperium (Cornell University Press, 2005) Ch.2,3,4 • Kiyoshi Kojima, The 'flying geese' model of Asian economic development: origin, theoretical extensions, and regional policy implications. Journal of Asian Economics 11, 2000, pp.375-401. • Raymond Vernon, "International Investment and International Trade in the Product Cycle." Quarterly Journal of Economics 80 (May 1966), pp.190-207. • Takashi Shiraishi, “The Third Wave: Southeast Asia and Middle-Class Formation in the Making of Region” Peter Katzenstein and Takashi Shiraishi eds., Beyond Japan: The Dynamics of East Asian Regionalism (Cornell University Press, 2006)