1 / 35

Arts & Humanities Instructional Building

Explore the analysis of roof systems and facade sequencing, waste management, and final recommendations for the Arts & Humanities Instructional Building project in Columbia. Compare green and built-up roofing systems for cost, scheduling, and structural impact considerations. Discover how green roofs can reduce heat gain, rainfall runoff, and sound reflection while discussing the thermal savings in summer months. Learn about the benefits, costs, and installations of sustainable roofing options for this project.

georgehughes
Download Presentation

Arts & Humanities Instructional Building

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Arts & Humanities Instructional Building Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006

  2. Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006 Agenda • Arts and Humanities Instructional Building Project Background • Analysis Areas • Roof System Analysis • Façade Sequencing • Waste Management • Final Conclusions and Recommendations Project Background Roof System Analysis Façade Sequencing Waste Management Conclusion

  3. Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006 Agenda • Arts and Humanities Instructional Building Project Background • Analysis Areas • Roof System Analysis • Façade Sequencing • Waste Management • Final Conclusions and Recommendations Project Background Roof System Analysis Façade Sequencing Waste Management Conclusion

  4. Project Background • Project Name: • Location: • Delivered Method : • Construction Manager : • GMP : • Construction Schedule: Arts & Humanities Instructional Building Columbia, Maryland CM at risk Riparius Construction, Inc. $20 M 22 months Project Background Roof System Analysis Façade Sequencing Waste Management Conclusion Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006

  5. Project Background • Project Size : • 77,000 sq.ft. • Building Use: • Classrooms, • offices, musical • and theatrical • theaters Project Background Roof System Analysis Façade Sequencing Waste Management Conclusion Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006

  6. Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006 Agenda • Arts and Humanities Instructional Building Project Background • Analysis Areas • Roof System Analysis • Façade Sequencing • Waste Management • Final Conclusions and Recommendations Project Background Roof System Analysis Façade Sequencing Waste Management Conclusion

  7. Roof System Analysis Objective: Compare 4-ply built-up roof system vs. green roof system Project Background Roof System Analysis • Considerations: • Cost • Schedule • Structural • Mechanical Façade Sequencing Waste Management Conclusion Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006

  8. Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006 Green Roofs • Green roof systems • Two main categories: • Extensive: 15 psf – 80 psf, typically 4-6 inches deep • Less Maintenance and smaller plants • Intensive: 80 psf – 150 psf, typically 12 inches deep Project Background Roof System Analysis Façade Sequencing • Benefits: • Reduce heat gain in summer • Reduce rainfall runoff impacts • Reduce sound reflection and transmission Waste Management Conclusion

  9. Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006 Roof Systems Green roof system Extensive roof designed to be 24 psf 4 inches of growing medium Plant selection: sedums Project Background Roof System Analysis Façade Sequencing Built-up roof system 4-ply roof 4 inches of rigid insulation Minimum dead load design 5.5 psf, table C3-1, ASCE7-05 Waste Management Conclusion

  10. AHIB Green roof Costs & Scheduling Project Background Roof System Analysis Façade Sequencing Waste Management Conclusion Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006

  11. Costs & Scheduling • Material and Installation Summary: • Built-up roof @ $1.98 / sf = $ 7,223 • Green roof @ $14.43 / sf = $52,640 Project Background Roof System Analysis Cost Difference: $45,417 Façade Sequencing • Installation Productivity: • Built-up roof @ 2,000 sq.ft installed per day = 13 days • Green roof @ 1,800 sq.ft installed per day = 14 days Waste Management Conclusion Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006

  12. W10x12 typ W27x84 typ Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006 Structural Impact Area Analyzed Area over musical theater. Typical bay W10x12 beams, 17 ft W27x84 girders, 40 ft Project Background Roof System Analysis Live load: 30 psf Snow load: 19.3 psf Dead load: 49 psf Green roof load: 24 psf Façade Sequencing Waste Management 1.2D + 1.6L + .5S = 145 psf Conclusion Resizing of structural members is not required • ΦVn ≥Vu • ΦMn ≥Mu • L/240

  13. Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006 Mechanical Impact • Greatest thermal savings of a green roof is in summer months Project Background Roof System Analysis • Green roof expected heat flow reduction is 20% in summer months Façade Sequencing Waste Management Heat flow calculations Built-up roof: cooling qx = (91-68) * 3,648 / 15.89 = 5,280 btu/hr Green roof savings = 5,280 btu/hr * 20% = 1,560 btu/hr Conclusion

  14. Roof System Analysis Built-up roof system Project Background • Considerations: • Cost • Schedule • Structural • Mechanical • Results: • Built-up roof ($45,417) • Faster installation • No impact • No impact Roof System Analysis Façade Sequencing Waste Management Conclusion Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006

  15. Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006 Agenda • Arts and Humanities Instructional Building Project Background • Analysis Areas • Roof System Analysis • Façade Sequencing • Waste Management • Final Conclusions and Recommendations Project Background Roof System Analysis Façade Sequencing Waste Management Conclusion

  16. Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006 Façade Sequencing Objective: Analyze alternative methods for the construction of the facade Project Background • Considerations: • Productivity • Cost • Schedule • Practicality Roof System Analysis Façade Sequencing Waste Management Conclusion

  17. Why Re-Sequencing? • Façade materials • Curtain wall • Pre-finished aluminum panels • Brick veneer Project Background Roof System Analysis Façade Sequencing Waste Management Conclusion Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006

  18. Façade Sequencing • Original Sequence • 37 week duration Project Background Roof System Analysis Façade Sequencing Waste Management Conclusion Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006

  19. Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006 Façade Sequencing • Four alternatives identified • Alternative A – compress schedule by adding additional crews • Alternative B – compress schedule by adding additional masonry crews • Alternative C – phase sequence of north facade • Alternative D – change aluminum panels to masonry veneer Project Background Roof System Analysis Façade Sequencing Waste Management Conclusion

  20. Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006 Façade Sequencing • Alternative C • Alternative C phases construction of north façade • Later curtain wall activities occur sequentially • 36 week duration Project Background Roof System Analysis Façade Sequencing Waste Management Conclusion

  21. Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006 Façade Sequencing Alternative C Project Background • Considerations: • Productivity • Cost • Schedule • Results: • No loss of productivity • ($13,544) • One week faster Roof System Analysis Façade Sequencing Waste Management Conclusion

  22. Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006 Agenda • Arts and Humanities Instructional Building Project Background • Analysis Areas • Roof System Analysis • Façade Sequencing • Waste Management • Final Conclusions and Recommendations Project Background Roof System Analysis Façade Sequencing Waste Management Conclusion

  23. Waste Management Objective: Develop a waste management plan for the AHIB Project Background • Considerations: • Cost • Accessibility • Practicality Roof System Analysis Façade Sequencing Waste Management Conclusion Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006

  24. Waste Management • Materials • Wood • Concrete • Gypsum board Project Background Roof System Analysis Façade Sequencing • Anticipated recycling • Concrete: 37 tons • Wood: 18 tons • Gypsum board: 7 tons Waste Management Conclusion Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006

  25. Waste Management • Source separated • Construction debris separated at jobsite into • different recycling bins Project Background Roof System Analysis • Costs • Tipping fee • Rental fee • Hauling fee Façade Sequencing Waste Management Conclusion Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006

  26. Waste Management Project Background Roof System Analysis Façade Sequencing Waste Management Conclusion Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006

  27. Waste Management Project Background • Waste Management • Site Utilization Plan Roof System Analysis Façade Sequencing Waste Management Conclusion Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006

  28. Waste Management Waste management plan Project Background • Considerations: • Cost • Accessibility • Results: • ($2,500) • Recycling centers are available Roof System Analysis Façade Sequencing Waste Management Conclusion Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006

  29. Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006 Agenda • Arts and Humanities Instructional Building Project Background • Analysis Areas • Roof System Analysis • Façade Sequencing • Waste Management • Final Conclusions and Recommendations Project Background Roof System Analysis Façade Sequencing Waste Management Conclusion

  30. Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006 Conclusion Recommendations • Construct 4-ply built-up roof • Re-sequence façade construction • ($13,544) • One week faster • Implement waste management plan • ($2,500) • 65 tons diverted from landfill Project Background Roof System Analysis Façade Sequencing Waste Management Conclusion

  31. Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006 Questions Project Background Roof System Analysis Façade Sequencing Waste Management Conclusion

  32. Acknowledgements Howard Community College Riparius Construction, Inc Penn State AE Faculty Family and Friends Project Background Roof System Analysis Façade Sequencing Waste Management Conclusion Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006

  33. Façade Sequencing Project Background Roof System Analysis Façade Sequencing Waste Management Conclusion Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006

  34. Façade Sequencing Project Background Roof System Analysis Façade Sequencing Waste Management Conclusion Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006

  35. Sound Attenuation • Expected sound transmission reduction: 5 decibels • 55 decibels reduced to 50 decibels • Road traffic to office activities Project Background Roof System Analysis Façade Sequencing Waste Management Conclusion Senior Thesis Presentation Noah J. Ashbaugh Construction Management 2006

More Related