1 / 27

The Political Economy of Labour Support 1997-2005 David Sanders Department of Government

The Political Economy of Labour Support 1997-2005 David Sanders Department of Government University of Essex, UK. Four Sections:. The objective economy, economic perceptions and political preferences, 1974-2005 A decline in economic voting under New Labour?

ghada
Download Presentation

The Political Economy of Labour Support 1997-2005 David Sanders Department of Government

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. The Political Economy of Labour Support 1997-2005 David Sanders Department of Government University of Essex, UK

  2. Four Sections: • The objective economy, economic perceptions and political preferences, 1974-2005 • A decline in economic voting under New Labour? • Rival ‘political’ and ‘economic’ models of party support 1997-2005 • Empirical results

  3. 1. The Objective Economy, the Subjective Economy and Governing Party Support A model that worked in the 1980 and 1990s: Interest Rates  Personal Expectations  Government Support Govt = a + b1Govt-1 + b2dPexpt-1 + SbkEvents + ut Pexpt = a + b1Pexpt-1 + b2dInterestRatet + SbkEvents + ut A mixed ‘political business cycle’/economic voting model

  4. Economic Expectations and (Poll-of-Polls) Governing Party Support, 1974-2005

  5. Models of Governing Party Support, 1974 -2005 Clear role for lagged changes in Expectations; none for the objective economy

  6. Modelling Aggregate Personal Economic Expectations, 1974- 2005: the impact of changes in interest rates Clear role for (changes in) Interest Rates over 30-year period

  7. A decline in economic voting under New Labour? (a)Change in the political business cycle component: • An immediate decline in New Labour’s ability to manipulate interest rates in line with the electoral cycle – ceding of interest rate control to the Bank of England • Manipulation of taxation burden as substitute?

  8. Changes in Taxation Index, 1997-2005 Taxation index constructed by subtracting RPI from Tax and Price Index

  9. A decline in economic voting under New Labour? (b) Economic success breeds complacency about the economy?

  10. Success breeds complacency?The declining salience of economic issues

  11. Success breeds complacency?The declining salience of economic issues

  12. Success breeds complacency?Governing party support and expectations weighted by salience, 1974-2005 Fit is stronger until mid 1990s; then even weaker

  13. 3. Alternative Models of Party Support, 1997-2005 The dependent variables….

  14. Why the objective economy doesn’t matter: an illustration Labour support and Unemployment: a positive trend relationship in which both trend down

  15. Core ‘Political’ Model Labt = b0 + b1Labt-1 + b2Costs of Ruling + b3Honeymoon + b4Sep2000 + b5Oct2001 + b6Occupation + ut [3a] Costs of Ruling = time trend (-), Honeymoon (+); Fuel Crisis (-); 9/11 bounce (+); Iraq War and Occupation (-)

  16. Additions to Core Political Model [3b] Valence short-cut: Blair’s leader ratings [3c] Government honesty and trustworthiness [3d] Service delivery on health and education [3e] Aggregate Personal Expectations [3f] Labour versus Conservative economic management capabilities [3g] Blair’s ratings plus economic expectations

  17. Labour Support and Blair’s ratings as PM

  18. Labour Support and Government Honesty

  19. Labour Support and Service Delivery on Educations and NHS

  20. Labour Support and Aggregate Personal Economic Expectations Expectations scale adjusted to Labour Support scale

  21. Labour Support and Labour versus Conservative Economic Management Competence Perceptions Economic Management scale adjusted to Labour Support scale

  22. 4. Empirical Results: Labour All the models work, except for Services; Labm has odd dynamics

  23. Empirical Results: Conservative and Liberal Democrat

  24. Conclusions Labour Support affected by: • Costs of ruling • Blair’s rating as PM • Personal economic expectations • Honeymoon, 2000 fuel crisis, 9/11 bounce • Iraq War/Occupation (cost 2.5 points) Conservative Support affected by: • Blair’s ratings as PM • Honeymoon, 2000 fuel crisis Liberal Democrat Support affected by: • Costs of Ruling, • Personal economic expectations

  25. Forecasts of Labour Support, December 2004

  26. Forecasts of Con and LibDem vote share

  27. Long term PM ratings/Expectations Model of Governing Party Support, 1974-2005

More Related