Topics of Discussion

1. OARnet Measurement Infrastructure Deployment Experiences Prasad CalyamPaul SchopisPhani Kumar Arava, Dima Krymskiy, Peter Jaegerson, Mukundan SridharanOARnet, A Division of Ohio Supercomputer Center,JTechs|Feb’06, Albuquerque

2. Topics of Discussion • TFN Measurement Project Overview • ActiveMon Measurement Infrastructure Software being developed at OARnet • Two ActiveMon Deployment Case-studies… • Live TFN-Abilene-ADECnet Monitoring Demo • Conclusion

3. Background • The Third Frontier Network (TFN) funded by the Ohio Board of Regents • A dedicated high-speed fiber-optic network linking Ohio colleges and universities with research facilities to promote research and economic development • Over 1,600 miles of fiber has been purchased to create a network backbone in Ohio to connect colleges and universities, K-12 schools, and communities together

4. TFN Measurement Project • Funded by Ohio Board of Regents • Project started in early 2004 • Project Partners • OARnet (Project Lead and Co-ordination) • University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati State, The Ohio State University, Kent State University, Southern State Community College, University of Toledo, Wright State University

5. TFN Measurement Project Objectives • Identify end-to-end performance bottlenecks in the TFN on an ongoing fashion by building a comprehensive Network Measurement Infrastructure (NMI) • Test new and advanced technologies and equipment before wide-scale adoption in the TFN Higher Education communities • Technologies: H.323/SIP based Voice and Videoconferencing, MPEG3, HDTV, Multicast, Bulk FTP • Equipment: Video streaming Caches, Firewalls, Intrusion Detection Systems, Traffic shapers • Bring awareness and train campus-networking professionals to make optimum use of the capabilities of TFN so that their campus network infrastructures can be upgraded suitably

6. TFN Measurement Project Objectives • Identify end-to-end performance bottlenecks in the TFN on an ongoing fashion by building a comprehensive Network Measurement Infrastructure (NMI) • Test new and advanced technologies and equipment before wide-scale adoption in the TFN Higher Education communities • Technologies: H.323/SIP based Voice and Videoconferencing, MPEG3, HDTV, Multicast, Bulk FTP • Equipment: Video streaming Caches, Firewalls, Intrusion Detection Systems, Traffic shapers • Bring awareness and train campus-networking professionals to make optimum use of the capabilities of TFN so that their campus network infrastructures can be upgraded suitably This talk’s focus!

7. “ActiveMon” Open-Source Software http://www.itecohio.org/activemon • “ActiveMon” is a NMI software Framework being developed for deployment on TFN • Development Goal of ActiveMon- “ActiveMon should be an easily customizable and comprehensive NMI software package that a network engineer can setup and use to routinely monitor performance of network-wide paths using active measurements”

8. ActiveMon Architecture

9. ActiveMon Framework Features • Data-Generator Module for an application-specific network measurement toolkit • Central Data-Collector-Sanitizer Moduleto centrally collect and store sensible measurements data; E.g. this module avoids collecting ‘–ve’ Delay or MOS values, etc. • Optimized Database Schema to efficiently store massive amounts of measurement data with minimal redundancy; saves disk space and facilities quicker data mining

10. ActiveMon Measurement Toolkit ActiveMon can be easily enhanced to support other tools as well…

11. ActiveMon Framework Features (2) • Scalable Scheduler Module for handling network-wide on-going and on-demand measurements; scheduling supports regulation and prevents measurement conflicts due to resource sharing • Alarm Generator Module digests, analyzes and generates alarms based on an efficient anomaly detection scheme that aims at minimum false-alarms; alarm notification via e-mail is supported • Easily Customizable Visualization Module with tabular and network health Weather map interfaces; alarm-context sensitive coloring of measurements information is supported • Security Configurations to avoid compromise of measurement infrastructure resources

12. Is ActiveMon fully developed and available as open-source? • An alpha version of the software with several of the above features has been developed and deployed on a measurement testbed • Based on the deployment experiences, the alpha version is being enhanced to provide better and more consistent functionality • To obtain the alpha version of ActiveMon, please contact- Prasad Calyam pcalyam@oar.net

13. Measurements Testbed • Goal-1:To study end-to-end network performance measurement data reported by various tools to empirically correlate network events and measurement data anomalies in a routine monitoring infrastructure “Do measurement tools actually detect significant network events?” • Goal-2: To analyze long-term network performance trends via statistical analysis of active and passive measurement data collected at strategic points on an ongoing basis “What can be understood from long-term network measurements?” • Goal-3: To use findings obtained from fulfilling the above Goals 1 and 2, to comprehensively compare performance at campus, regional and national network backbone levels and hence to quantify end-to-end network performance stability in typical hierarchical network backbones “How does it matter where I measure the network?”

14. Testbed spanning Hierarchical Network Backbone Levels – Campus, Regional, National Campus - Level Path Only OSU Campus Backbone Routers were present along the path Regional - Level Path Only OARnet Backbone Routers were present along the path National - Level Path Only OARnet Backbone Routers, Abilene Routers, NCNI Routers were present along the path

15. Case Study - I(July 2004 – December 2004 Measurements Data) • Delay Variations • We found that combined one-way delays (A→B+B→A) along a path with ends A and B are comparable to round trip delays (A↔B) in all the three paths • Significant anomalies due to route changes (each time!) • Short-lived dips and peaks due to miscellaneous temporal network dynamics; Magnitudes based on hop-count

16. Case Study - II(July 2004 – December 2004 Measurements Data) • Bandwidth Variations • Router mis-configuration anomaly with three distinct trends • Regional path was the least congested and most provisioned path • National path traffic spanning multiple-ISPs experiences most congestion events

17. ActiveMon Related Publications (2005) • Prasad Calyam, Dima Krymskiy, Mukundan Sridharan, Paul Schopis, "TBI: End-to-End Network Performance Measurement Testbed for Empirical-bottleneck Detection", IEEE TRIDENTCOM, 2005. • Prasad Calyam, Chang-Gun Lee, Phani Kumar Arava, Dima Krymskiy, David Lee, “OnTimeMeasure: A Scalable Framework for scheduling active measurements”, IEEE E2EMON, 2005. • Prasad Calyam, Dima Krymskiy, Mukundan Sridharan, Paul Schopis, "Active and Passive Measurements on Campus-level, Regional-level and National-level Network Backbone Paths", IEEE ICCCN, 2005. • Prasad Calyam, Chang-Gun Lee, Phani Kumar Arava, Dima Krymskiy, “Enhanced EDF Scheduling Algorithms for Orchestrating Network-wide Active Measurements”, IEEE RTSS, 2005. Above papers are available at - http://www.osc.edu/research/networking/publications.shtml

18. Live TFN-Abilene-ADECnet Monitoring Demo http://activemon.oar.net

19. Thanks! • ActiveMon Scripts Development, Deployment and Data Analysis • Prasad Calyam, Phani Kumar Arava, Dima Krymskiy, Peter Jaegerson, Mukundan Sridharan • Project Management • Steve Gordon, Paul Schopis, Pankaj Shah • OSU Border and Dept. Deployment • Prof. David Lee, Dave Kneisly, Arif Khan, Weiping Mandrawa, Mark Fullmer • UC Border and Dept. Deployment • Prof. Jerry Paul, Prof. Fred Annexstein, Bruce Burton, Bill Bohmer, Tom Ridgeway, Michal Kouril, Diana Noelcke • TAMU Deployment • Chris Norton • UToledo Deployment • Denis Logan • SSCC Deployment • Dennis Griffith • NC-ITEC, Abilene Tests • John Moore, Jeff Boote

20. Questions? TFN Measurement Project Reference: http://tfn.oar.net/measurement