1 / 48

Unemployment and the South African labour market

Unemployment and the South African labour market . Hendrik van Broekhuizen Research on Socio-Economic Policy Stellenbosch University 12 September 2013. Concepts, figures, and statistics in this presentation: Primary sources.

guang
Download Presentation

Unemployment and the South African labour market

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Unemployment andtheSouth African labour market Hendrik van Broekhuizen Research on Socio-Economic Policy Stellenbosch University 12 September 2013

  2. Concepts, figures, and statistics in this presentation: Primarysources • CDE. (2011). A fresh look at unemployment: A conversation among experts. CDE Workshop Paper, Centre for Development and Enterprise • StatsSA. (2013). Quarterly Labour Force Survey: Quarter 1 Press Statement. Statistics South Africa. • CDE. (2013). Graduate unemployment in South Africa: A much exaggerated problem. CDE Insight. Johannesburg: Centre for Development and Enterprise. • CDE. (forthcoming). South Africa’s education crises. CDE Insight. Johannesburg: Centre for Development and Enterprise. • OECD. (2013). OECD Economic Surveys: South Africa 2013. OECD Publishing.

  3. Why focus on unemployment? • Unemployment and employmentare measures of a country’s socio-economic health. • Global employment crisis following financial crisis • High and/or rising levels of unemployment are increasingly becoming • cause for concern • the target of policy interventions • The basis for political and ideological division

  4. Figure – Peak-to-trough fall in output and employment (2007 – 2010)

  5. Figure – Total employment in SA (2008 – 2013) 1 000 000 jobs lost 646 000 jobs gained

  6. Why focus on SA labour market? • Engine of economic development • Vehicle of socio-economic change • For good or bad • Features and issues will propagate through entire economy

  7. The South African labour market

  8. 33 million Working-age Population

  9. 33 million Working-age Population 12.7 million NEA

  10. 33 million Working-age Population 12.7 million NEA 13.6 million Employed

  11. 33 million Working-age Population 12.7 million NEA 2.3 million Discouraged work seekers 13.6 million Employed

  12. 33 million Working-age Population 12.7 million NEA 4.6 million Unemployed 2.3 million Discouraged work seekers 13.6 million Employed

  13. Who are the unemployed? 70.7% between 15 - 34 HELP 59.4% have less than matric 65.3% long term unemployed 44% new entrants 49.1% females

  14. The scale of SA’s unemployment crisis

  15. Figure – Official and expanded unemployment rate (2008 – 2013)

  16. The scale of SA’s unemployment crisis I • Official unemployment rate underestimates crises • Excludes discouraged work-seekers • Employment rate may be more reflective

  17. Figure - Employment rate in SA and select countries, 2008

  18. Figure – Official LFP rate and ER (2008 – 2013)

  19. The scale of SA’s unemployment crisis II • Employment rate perhaps more reflective than official unemployment rate, but • Still includes underemployed • Even so, we are lagging behind internationally • To reach international norm of 60% ER • requires 6 million more jobs than the current 13.6 million • How do we create those jobs?

  20. Economic growth and job creation

  21. Employment and Growth I • Economic growth necessary condition for job creation, but not sufficient • Economic growth is not a sufficient condition for job creation • Employment coefficient

  22. Figure – GDP growth versus job creation, 1970s – 2000s

  23. Employment and GrowthII • Why an employment coefficient of <0.4? • Decline related to many factors • Economic, legislative, regulatory pressures • Drive industries and employers toward less labour-intensive and more skill-intensive production • To reach international norm of 60% ER requires • 33 mill + 7% GDP↑ for 15 years • 1.9%↑ in 33 mil + 7% GDP↑ + >40 years • Growth alone, even when rapid and sustained, cannot be a solution to unemployment • How to increase labour intensity?

  24. Drivers of economic growth in SA • Driven primarily by unsustainable ↑ Government spending since 2000 • Local markets small = reliance on exports • Employment growth requires labour-intensive exports and competitiveness • Detrimental factors • High cost of doing business, cost of labour, exchange rate (volatility) • High transport costs • Regulatory burden • No economies of scale

  25. The role of labour market regulations

  26. Employment, labour costs, and productivity • Employment = f(Labour Productivity, Labour Cost) • Labour cost • Wages and benefits (direct) • Training, other benefits, complying with regulatory requirements (indirect) • Risk → increases potential labour cost • ↑∑LC fewer job offers and jobs created • ∆Employment = f(LP/LC) • Employers have two responses to high labour costs: • Pass costs on to consumers • Employ fewer high-cost, low-productivity labourers

  27. Figure – Average changes in productivity and real wages per decade, 1970 - 2009

  28. Unions and collective bargaining • Empirical evidence • Unionised workers’ wages 10% - 20% > non-unionised • Firms covered by collective bargaining have ↑ wage rates ↓ employment • Only third of formal economy covered by centralised bargaining • Sectors concerned among most critical • Provide benchmark for wage ↑ in other sectors • Severs link between productivity and wages

  29. TheCosts of dismissal • Cannot hire low-productivity cheaply, so don’t hire at all • Exacerbated by non-wage costs and risks associated with employment. • The more risky, the less likely to be employed • Young • Unskilled • Inexperienced • Costly and risky to dismiss employees

  30. TheCosts of strikes • Labour regulation in SA perhaps on par internationally • Real crux is ‘militancy’ of SA trade unions • Raise the risk-adjusted wage and non-wage costs of employment • Strike action heavier in public than private sector (in general) • Knock-on effect i.t.o. services protests, disruptions, and further strikes

  31. Figure – Number of working days lost due to industrial action (2005 – 2012)

  32. TheCosts of strikesStrike action in 2012 – scale of militancy • 17.3 million working hours lost due to illegal or unprotected strikes • 99 strikes of which half illegal • 118 200 workers involved, 100 850 in the mining sector • Strikes often accompanied by violence and destruction of property

  33. TheCosts of strikesStrike action in 2013 – implications of militancy • 3-week strike in automotive manufacturing sector • Gained: • Wage increases >>>> inflation • Lost: • 45 000 vehicles, R20bn in potential revenue • GDP, tax receipts, workers pay, employment numbers • Allure as FDI destination • SA motor industry = 30% of industrial output and just under 5% of GDP. • Strikes rob SA of business opportunities – i.e. employment opportunities

  34. Therole of labour market reform • Little agreement on labour reforms between labour and industry • Need to identify reforms that will stimulate establishment of labour-intensive enterprises. • More medium and low-productivity firms with lower employment costs • SA’s ‘missing middle’ • Reforms are on the table, but…

  35. Matching laboursupplyand demand

  36. Social grants and LFP • SA LFP rate low (54.8%) • Historically low among women and blacks • Does social welfare incentivise or disincentivise LFP? • Mixed empirical evidence in SA • Increase in access to social grants coincided with increase in LFP rates • Increases in LFP not commensurately met by increases in employment • Rising unemployment

  37. Figure – Labour force participation rates in 25 countries (2008)

  38. Figure – Social grants versus labour force participation rates (1996 - 2009)

  39. Reservation wages • Reservation wages and LFP • Mixed evidence for SA • However, long job queues suggest not… • Expanded Public works Programme and labour brokering, e.g. • Most unemployed have never been offered a job rather than turning down wage offers • Reservation wages likely to play more of a role at the upper end (skilled labour)

  40. Recruitment practices • Job search affects unemployment and recruitment practices affect employment • Firms screen applicants based on productivity signals • Firms wanting to fill low-skill entry-level jobs may use other selection methods • Experience and in-house recruitment • Mitigates risk • May not advertise jobs • Does not affect # jobs on offer, but makes access to employment more exclusive

  41. Figure – Share of working-age adults employed in informal sector

  42. Skillsandunemployment • Skills shortage and mismatch • SA has skill-biased employment growth • 59% of unemployed • Have never worked • Have never had the opportunity to acquire on-the-job skills • Lack of vital skills and aptitudes for employment central to unemployment • Riskiness of labour market raises appeal of experienced work-seekers

  43. A vicious cycle?

  44. Solving the unemployment crisis • Short-run: ??????? • Lon-run: more skills • Not just more education, but better education • Focus must shift from quantity to quality • Employers look for productivity signals • Is education a good productivity signal in SA?

  45. Developing skills • FET colleges? • Artisanship training? • University? • Support for job-seekers? • Youth employment incentives • Expanded public works?

  46. Figure – Narrow unemployment rate for tertiaries

  47. Figure – Graduate Narrow Unemployment Rate (2008 – 2013)

  48. Thank you

More Related