1 / 29

Craft of Research, 1

Craft of Research, 1. Use of research, pubic & private. From the researcher’s point of view - a craft Research is carefully planned: May not know precisely what one’s looking for, but know in general the kinds of materials needed How to find them How to use them

henrik
Download Presentation

Craft of Research, 1

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Craft of Research, 1

  2. Use of research, pubic & private • From the researcher’s point of view - a craft • Research is carefully planned: • May not know precisely what one’s looking for, but know in general the kinds of materials needed • How to find them • How to use them • Assemble them into an acceptable, cogent whole

  3. Value of Research • For the neophyte researcher, helps one understand the material • More distantly, skills of research & of writing will help you in your career … • As a (very modest) researcher, • Helping others gather resources (reference), • Organize them into a cogent whole (BI) • Report reliably and persuasively (as librarian)

  4. Your multiple roles • Understand the production of research: • Writing, research techniques, statistical methods, argumentation, interpretations and alternatives • The referee process • Printed and online versions

  5. Your multiple roles • As a librarian (or other info professional) you should be aware of the physical traits of resource documents on retrieval: • Surrogates, controlled vocabularies, thesauri • Full-text retrieval (“IR”) • Abstracts and abstracting services • How these issues affect one’s ability to retrieval relevant documents • Novel trends in some fields (e.g., bioinformatics, bibliomining)

  6. Your multiple roles • Communication: impact of • Writing styles (on consumer research, recommending research reports, IR) • Expectations by domain (scientific research techniques vs. humanities techniques) • Graphic communication • Statistical communication

  7. Your multiple roles • Learn to critique research: establish a base of perspective and rationale … • Yet be sensitive to the influences & pressures on researchers • Look for alternative interpretations • Encourage others to do the same.

  8. Your multiple roles: • Understand the various applications of research, depending on role and location (and whether the activity really is “research”) • Library administrators • Librarians as faculty • Librarians as practitioners • Other info professionals’ needs • Public (non-academic) • Students (academic libraries)

  9. Thinking in Print (chapter 1) • Why conduct research? • Reliable published research • Write to remember • Write to understand • Write to gain perspective • What do you think?

  10. Connecting with the Reader • Conversations among researchers: • Precise writing reflects the researchers’ judgment about the reader [compare this with the editors’ p.o.v] • Intended audience • Social roles (cf. The library applications mentioned above)

  11. Connecting with the reader • Researchers create their own role (research activities, writer, intentions in sharing the work) • Understand the intended reader: choice of journal to publish the work • Prestige • Intended audience • Expectations of readers’ knowledge

  12. Reader concerns • Readers will want to know the significance of the problem (the “so what” factor) • You want them to accept new knowledge • And to change their beliefs about the issue • Booth provides a checklist for understanding your reader (pp. 26-27)

  13. Asking Questions, Finding Answers • From Topics to Questions - we’ll return to this theme several times • Researchers try to answer a significant question • Actually trying to pose and then solve a problem that others recognize as worth solving • Narrowing the topic to a “researchable problem” is not easy! See pp 37-38. • But research requires an actual question, not a topic

  14. From topics to questions • When reading an article, can you fill in the blanks [p. 44] • The author is studying _______. • Because s/he wants to find out who/how/why ______. • In order to understand how/why/what _____.

  15. From questions to problems • Research should discover, show, explain, and convince. • Turning practical problems into research problems • Is the problem actually significant? • There are two types of research: pure and applied.

  16. Before continuing … • We’ll continue our look at research from the “developing researchers’” perspective; • Keep in mind these points addressed to researchers-as-authors when we examine them as part of the fountainhead of research: reflective inquiry

  17. From Questions to Sources Review Ch. 5 and the Appendix - finding resources in libraries. Sources: • Reference librarians • General encyclopedia and dictionaries • Bibliographic guides • Online catalogues (cards for historical collections) • Domain specific encyclopedia & dictionaries • Specialized bibliographies • Guides

  18. From questions to sources • Assignment 1 emphasizes finding resources in libraries - getting to know the lay of the land

  19. From questions to sources • Librarians • Experts • Other people [subjects] • Printed resources: • Primary • Secondary • Tertiary • [Which has more research ‘value’ and why?]

  20. Using sources • Careful notes! [bibliographic data] • Careful notes, redux! • For accurate summaries and abstracts • Get the context right: • A work cited out of context is suspect • Anticipate claims, supporting claims, warrants, biases & assumptions

  21. Claims & supporting them • Making good arguments • Part of a strategy of persuasion • “good” research makes explicit the cause-and-effect: [you claim x caused y because …] • Consider the readers’ questions (or the librarian patrons’ questions) and how the expression of the claim can be interpreted by human judges & by IR systems

  22. Claims & supporting them • Making good arguments • The warrant • Key to persuasion • Great opportunity to mislead by accident or design • Is the warrant somehow qualified? Should it be? • Does the qualification affect interpretation?

  23. Warrants • Quality of the warrant: • False • Unclear • Inappropriate • Inapplicable • Discuss examples

  24. Qualifications • Does the research qualify the claim? If so, is there a complete, accurate, fair explanation of the: • Rebuttals: • Complete review of all relevant aspects of the problem? Does the author pick-and-choose evidence? • Concessions: • Updated research on the problem • Corrected by other researchers acknowledge?

  25. Qualifications • Limiting conditions • Qualifications affect the generalizability of the research results. • Is the scope of the work also limited?

  26. Preparing to draft, drafting & revising • Before writing, authors try to gather all the evidence: • Warrants • Objections to rebut • [The literature review] • What are your preliminary interpretations? • What are your alternative interpretations? • More importantly, does the research question get answered?!

  27. Preparing to draft, drafting & revising • Main points: • Are the quotes, &c., accurate • Is there a logical structdure to the argument • Don’t be afraid to draft and revise a lot! • Because researchers construct carefully, we can deconstruct carefully.

  28. Communicating visually • (We’ll return to this theme again.) • Visual evidence is intended • To be accurate • To be interpreted quickly • Common, tho, for some outlets to manipulate graphics to lie • See Tufte’s works • More examples to follow from the literature and during the SPSS demo

  29. Recap and conclusions • What’s the main points from the perspective of the: • Researchers • Librarian (as facilitator) • Consumers of research (public and other researchers)

More Related