60 likes | 81 Views
South East Asian Group. On the Proposed Outline for the Country Studies of Land Watch Asia. Participants. CAMBODIA Sokhan Mech, NGO Forum on Cambodia Ly Rathy, Star Kampuchea INDONESIA Erpan Faryadi, Consortium for Agrarian Reform Tina Napitupulu, Bina Desa PHILIPPINES
E N D
South East Asian Group On the Proposed Outline for the Country Studies of Land Watch Asia
Participants CAMBODIA • Sokhan Mech, NGO Forum on Cambodia • Ly Rathy, Star Kampuchea INDONESIA • Erpan Faryadi, Consortium for Agrarian Reform • Tina Napitupulu, Bina Desa PHILIPPINES • Maricel Almojuela, ANGOC • Jayvee Garganerra, PhilDHRRA • Ernie Lim, AR NOW! • Tony Quizon, ANGOC and CAARD • Nina Somera, ANGOC
#1: What are your comments on the proposed outline? (1) On Legal Framework… • Include international commitments of countries • Include specific sectors among beneficiaries • Rephrase >> from “effectiveness of the laws” to “level of implementation” of the laws (2) On Status… • Include assessment of media and academe on access to land and tenurial security • Surface the disparity of assessments between two similar actors (e.g. two government agencies) • Surface the relation of access to land and poverty & development • Cite examples of “major developments” i.e. concessions, FTAs (3) On Key Actors… • Include actors who are hindering access to land and tenurial security
#2: What process would be relevant in support of existing campaigns?
#3: How can the study contribute to the [national] campaigns? CAMBODIA • The study is an entry point though other interventions are needed to influence policy INDONESIA • The exercise can lead to coalition-building and eventually consensus-building especially among AR groups, IPs, environmental groups
#3: How can the study contribute to the [national] campaigns? PHILIPPINES • Influence legislative agenda (e.g. CARP, IPRA, mining, fisheries code) • Formulation of mechanisms for land conflicts