60 likes | 147 Views
The Importance of Being Important for Question Generation, that is …. Lucy Vanderwende, Microsoft Research (USA). Machine Reading. How do you evaluate machine reading? Ability to answer questions Ability to ask questions
E N D
The Importance of Being Importantfor Question Generation, that is … Lucy Vanderwende,Microsoft Research (USA)
Machine Reading • How do you evaluate machine reading? • Ability to answer questions • Ability to ask questions • Graesser et al. (2005): QG is one salient manifestation of active learning and reveals how deeply the learner has mastered the material
What/what are we developing question generation systems for? • Tutoring systems • Improved answer retrieval • Community question answers (Yahoo!, WikiAnswers, …) • Harabagiu et al. 2005, pre-generating questions to improve QA systems • Information discovery • Question schemas • Machine learning driven by posing questions: Ruminator, Ureel et al. 2005 • Need to identify which questions drive learning, and which are unproductive
Microsoft? • Schwartz et al. 2004, developing automated learning aids, used full parsing + generation + summarization • “limiting/selecting questions created by Content QA Generator is difficult” • There is a tie between summarization and question generation • If you do summarization well, does that carry over to question generation? Is the core task of summarization easier to evaluate in the context of question generation? • Question generation might be a way to engage/entertain users in a search setting • Why are people still so enamored with Eliza-like technology? • What makes questions engaging vs. annoying? • We care about students! • Strongly agree that a shared task enhances visibility of the area and encourages participation from a wider audience • A well-defined shared task can let students shine • We are always looking for interns who have done innovative work
Plea for multi-sentence input • Question Generation shared task could provide a test-bed for other technologies • Anaphora resolution, mention detection, event detection, RST, cohesion, … • Designing the shared task to target these levels of analysis will also provide greater visibility to the NLG community • It is important to understand the phenomena in the test corpus • Vanderwende 2005, what syntax can contribute in entailment