1 / 9

Rational Choice

People make choices that maximize benefits and minimize costs to themselves Favors a “get-tough” approach to crime—Make crime cost more. Rational Choice. Rational Choice. Deterrence

issac
Download Presentation

Rational Choice

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. People make choices that maximize benefits and minimize costs to themselves Favors a “get-tough” approach to crime—Make crime cost more Rational Choice

  2. Rational Choice Deterrence Since humans calculate costs versus benefits, you have to make punishments severe enough to make crime cost more than the benefits. • Dimensions of punishment: • Certainty • Celerity • Severity • The only one that appears to consistently be effective is certainty.

  3. Rational Choice General Deterrence Make the punishments severe enough for banned behaviors so that people in general will avoid those behaviors. • Research indicates this approach does not work. • Juveniles typically do not consider punishment before acting. • Juveniles are more deterred by fear of getting caught. • Most effective is fear of loss of approval of family and friends.

  4. Rational Choice Specific Deterrence Punish identified offenders enough so that they will not violate rules again. • Research indicates this approach does not work. • Incarceration does not reduce recidivism • Incarceration actually increases criminal involvement • Radical nonintervention • (Warehousing criminals does keep individuals off the streets, but systems that produced them may keep producing more.)

  5. Rational Choice Situational Crime Prevention Identify situations that make crime more likely, and “harden” and observe the target more. Related to “Broken Window Theory” • Works best of all to deterrence methods to prevent crime. • Rests on Routine Activities Theory of Crime

  6. Getting Away from Rational Choice Routine Activities Theory • Admission that social structure plays some role in crime. It is not just product of individual's behavior. • To get crime you need: • A suitable target • Lack of a Capable Guardian • A Motivated Offender (According to rational choice, aren't we all motivated?)

  7. Psychological “Bright Spot” Agnew, Page 133, Ways to prevent delinquency traits (how if they are inherited?) • Develop strong emotional bonds with kids • Provide clear rules for behavior • Monitor behavior • Consistently sanction deviance in an appropriate manner • Model and reinforce conventional behavior In other words, foster a “conventional” mental map.

  8. Psychological “Bright Spot” Cognitive Behavioral Therapy I call this the “stop, drop, and roll!” approach to delinquency. You can train delinquents to avoid crime and status offenses by teaching them to behave more conventionally. Kids learn to: • Identify problem situations • Think through various reaction strategies • Proceed with the most conventional behaviors

  9. Getting Away from Rational Choice People are “Lazy Thinkers” Human choice-making is “boxed in” by these cognitive restrictions: • Routine thinking, verification • Short-cuts to causality • Categorical Thinking, philosophical inconsistency • Change new information to fit pre-set categories • People must belong to others • Bad Memories • Salient Stimuli • Obsessed with self/self bias Education is partly an effort to overcome many of these restrictions to make people rational. Think back to “stop, drop, and roll!”

More Related