1 / 11

Drugs and Criminal Justice in Scotland: Policy Overview

Drugs and Criminal Justice in Scotland: Policy Overview. Scottish Drugs Forum 15 September 2009. Policy Objectives. To provide opportunity for accused/offenders at all stages of the criminal justice system to engage with treatment services;

ivana
Download Presentation

Drugs and Criminal Justice in Scotland: Policy Overview

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Drugs and Criminal Justice in Scotland: Policy Overview Scottish Drugs Forum 15 September 2009

  2. Policy Objectives • To provide opportunity for accused/offenders at all stages of the criminal justice system to engage with treatment services; • Based on premise that by dealing with their addiction it offers potential for positive impact on their associated offending behaviour, particularly acquisitive crime; • Justice agenda to achieve Safer Communities. However, significant secondary outcomes e.g. health improvements, opportunity to contribute to Scottish economy, etc.

  3. Point of arrest: Arrest Referral • Involves arrest referral worker engaging with arrestees whilst in police custody cells and at a ‘point of crisis’ to attempt to persuade them to enter treatment; • Based on voluntary participation; • Evaluation study “generally encouraging”; • Restricted coverage but includes 4 main cities; • Effectiveness dependent on early access to mainstream treatment services;

  4. Point of arrest: Mandatory Drug Testing (1) • Those arrested for certain “trigger” offences (theft and Misuse of Drugs Act) and in police custody required to undergo a drugs test for opiates and/or cocaine; • Involved oral fluid testing; • Those who tested positive required to undergo a mandatory assessment as to suitability for treatment services; • Actual engagement with treatment services on a voluntary basis; • No bearing on due process of law.

  5. Point of arrest: Mandatory Drug Testing (2) • Was piloted in 3 custody suites – Aberdeen, Edinburgh and Glasgow (London Road) – for 2 years; • Subject to external evaluation by MVA Consultancy; • Throughput considerably below original estimates and numbers entering treatment at disproportionate cost; • No further specific funding provided and the pilots have ended

  6. Bail/remand • Considerable work undertaken on possibility of making engagement with treatment services a condition of bail in appropriate cases; • Legal difficulties meant option was not pursued; • Had MDT proved successful next logical step might have been to apply MDT provisions to decisions on bail; • Meantime no intervention at the bail stage.

  7. Sentencing: Probation with drug treatment • Historically courts have been able to impose probation with an additional condition of drug treatment/education; • 341 such orders in 2007-08. Decline in usage by courts e.g. Glasgow reported no such conditions in 2007-08; • Offenders plugged into mainstream service provision – local capacity issues have direct impact on usage by courts; • Will be replaced by new Community Payback Orders – courts will be able to impose a Drug Treatment requirement as part of the order

  8. Sentencing: Drug Treatment and Testing Orders • For high tariff offenders committing large amounts of acquisitive crime e.g. 68% of those on DTTO have more than 10 previous convictions; • Early access to treatment – reflects fact that justice budget pays directly for services; • Unit costs of £10k per annum – high compared with other community penalties but not with custody • 601 orders in 2007-08 – decline from previous year; • 81% reconviction rate over 2 years (but 48% for those who complete orders); • Challenge is to improve throughput and completion rates; • Intention to retain DTTOs.

  9. Sentencing: DTTO Lite • Currently being piloted in most courts in Lothians and Borders; • Two year pilot running to June 2010 will be subject to external evaluation; • Target groups include female and young offenders.

  10. Sentencing: Drug Courts • Currently operate in Glasgow and Fife; • Make extensive use of DTTOs; • Principal distinguishing features compared with DTTOs are the expertise/experience of the drug court sheriffs and pre-review hearings; • Effectiveness in terms of reconviction rates on a par with DTTOs; • Future of drug courts currently under review;

  11. Summary • Significant debate to be had around the extent to which Justice should be paying for mainstream service provision as occurs with DTTOs; • Introduction of Community Payback Orders with provision for a Drug Treatment requirement at same time as retention of DTTOs; • Piloting of use of DTTOs with lower tariff offenders; • Future of drug courts currently under review;

More Related