1 / 13

Controlling for Baseline

Controlling for Baseline. David A. Kenny. Variables. Outcome variable Y Baseline measure: Y 1 Follow-up measure: Y 2 Causal variable X measured at time 1 The question is how to measure the effect of X on Y 2 and control for Y 1. Equation. Y 2 = a + b Y 1 + bX + e.

jael-newton
Download Presentation

Controlling for Baseline

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Controlling for Baseline David A. Kenny

  2. Variables Outcome variable Y • Baseline measure: Y1 • Follow-up measure: Y2 Causal variable X measured at time 1 The question is how to measure the effect of X on Y2 and control for Y1.

  3. Equation Y2 = a + bY1 + bX + e X and Y1 as predictors

  4. Comparable Analyses Analysis of Covariance with Y1 as a covariate. Control for Y1, but make the outcome change or Y2 – Y1 Residualized change (or gain) score analysis Regress Y2 on Y1 and compute residuals Regress X on Y1 and compute residuals (usually not done) Regress the first residual on the second Reduce df by 1. (usually not done)

  5. b

  6. Measurement Error in Y1 Assume Y1 mediation of the Z (the assignment variable) to Y2. The measurement error in Y1 attenuates (pushes it toward zero) b. The estimated b equals br where r is the reliability of the pretest (controlling for X). Not enough of the “gap” is subtracted.

  7. Solutions to the Measurement Error Problem Known Reliability Solutions Lord-Porter Correction Williams & Hazer Strategy Reliability Estimation Solution Latent Variable Analysis with Multiple Indicators

  8. Known Reliability Reliability or r must be known. Perhaps use an internal consistency estimate. Lord-Porter uses the reliability of Y1 controlling for X not the reliability of Y1. Must adjust r by (r - rXY12)/(1 - rXY12). Williams & Hazer uses the reliability of Y1 so no adjustment is necessary.

  9. Lord-Porter Correction Reliability or Y1 controlling for X or r must be known. Regress Y1 on X (and covariates) and compute the predicted score (P) and the residual (R) Compute: Y1ʹ = P + rR (r is the reliability) Regress Y2 on Y1ʹ and X Hardly ever done, but does not require a SEM program.

  10. Williams & Hazer Error variance of for the T1 latent variable is fixed to sY12(1- r) where r is the known reliability of Y1. b

  11. Latent Variable Multiple indicators of latent Y at each time Set up a Latent Variable Model Test to see that the loadings are the same at each time. To be safely identified, need at least 3 indicators at each time. Correlate errors of the same indicator at different times.

  12. b

  13. More Technically need only a Time 1 latent variable and no Time 2 latent variable. If latent variables at two times, do not necessarily need temporally invariant loadings though you do with CSA.

More Related