1 / 26

Updated 5-year Biochemical Relapse-Free Survival after Prostate Brachytherapy

Updated 5-year Biochemical Relapse-Free Survival after Prostate Brachytherapy. Jenny P. Nobes St. Luke’s Cancer Centre, The Royal Surrey County Hospital, Guildford. Introduction. I 125 LDR interstitial prostate brachytherapy BRFS rates from USA equivalent to RP and conformal EBRT

jaxon
Download Presentation

Updated 5-year Biochemical Relapse-Free Survival after Prostate Brachytherapy

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Updated 5-year Biochemical Relapse-Free Survival after Prostate Brachytherapy Jenny P. Nobes St. Luke’s Cancer Centre, The Royal Surrey County Hospital, Guildford

  2. Introduction • I125 LDR interstitial prostate brachytherapy • BRFS rates from USA equivalent to RP and conformal EBRT • Different toxicity profile • Monotherapy or combined modality • NICE guidelines - continued audit and careful clinical governance recommended Kupelian et al, IJROBP 2004

  3. Patient Selection • T1 or T2 • PSA <10 • Gleason 3+3, or low volume 3+4 • Prostate volume <50cc • No prior TURP • Minimal urinary symptoms: IPSS <15 • Qmax >15 ml/sec

  4. LDR Prostate Brachytherapy Results

  5. Sylvester et al, IJROBP 2007

  6. Guildford Results • First 300 patients • 5 year actuarial PSA relapse-free survival - 93% • Low risk - 96% • Intermediate risk - 89% • High risk - 93% Khaksar et al, BJUi 2006

  7. Guildford: Updated Study • 1007 patients treated to date • First 400 patients treated March 1999-Dec 2003 • Prospective database • Patients stratified by risk group and treatment received • Brachytherapy (BXT) 145Gy alone • Neo-adjuvant androgen deprivation (NAAD) + BXT • External beam radiotherapy (EBRT) 45Gy + 110Gy BXT • NAAD, EBRT + BXT • Assessment of BRFS, PSA nadirs and toxicity

  8. Risk Classification MSKCC risk groupings • Gleason score >6 • PSA >10 • Clinical stage >T2b • 0 = Low risk • 1 = Intermediate risk • 2 or 3 = High risk Zelefsky et al, J Urol 2001

  9. Definitions of Biochemical Failure • ASTRO definition – 3 consecutive PSA rises • Sensitivity 51% • Specificity 81% • Modifed ASTRO – 2 consecutive PSA rises • ‘Houston’ – PSA nadir + 2ng/ml • Sensitivity 72% • Specificity 83% • Best surrogate for failure after BXT or EBRT Kuban et al, IJROBP 2006

  10. ASTRO definition 0.8 36m 1.2 42m 1.8 48m PSA: 0.2 Time: 24 4.7 60m 0.2 30m 2.6 54m 36m 33m 51m Radical Prostatectomyfailure Houston +2 Definitions of failure post BXT

  11. Median follow-up 72 months (38-96) Mean age 68 years (44-76) PSA 0-4 21 4.1-10 269 10.1-20 106 >20 4 GS 0-4 58 5-6 270 7-10 72 Stage T1c 172 T2 a/b 149 T2c 66 T3a 13 Risk Low 197 Intermediate 144 High 59 Guildford: Patient Characteristics

  12. Treatment Received • BXT 167 (42%) • NAAD + BXT 155 (39%) • EBRT + BXT 12 (3%) • NAAD, EBRT + BXT 64 (16%)

  13. Low-Risk Group • n = 197 (49%) • BXT alone 122 • NAAD + BXT 72 • EBRT + BXT 0 • NAAD, EBRT + BXT 3

  14. Intermediate-Risk Group • n = 144 (36%) • BXT alone 38 • NAAD + BXT 75 • EBRT + BXT 5 • NAAD, EBRT + BXT 24

  15. High Risk-Group • n = 59 (15%) • BXT alone 7 • NAAD + BXT 8 • EBRT + BXT 7 • NAAD, EBRT + BXT 37

  16. Biochemical Failures - nadir + 2ng/ml • n = 28/400 (7%) Risk Group • Low 9 • Intermediate 14 • High 5 Treatment • BXT 6 • NAAD + BXT 15 • EBRT + BXT 1 • NAAD, EBRT + BXT 6

  17. 5-year Biochemical Relapse-Free Survival 92% 5-year PSA RFS

  18. 5-year Biochemical RFS by Risk Group Low 95% Intermediate 88% High 90%

  19. Low-Risk Group BXT Alone NAAD + BXT 98% 91%

  20. Intermediate-Risk Group BXT 89% NAAD + BXT 87% NAAD, EBRT + BXT 92% EBRT + BXT 80%

  21. High-Risk Group NAAD + BXT NAAD, EBRT + BXT 88% 88%

  22. PSA Nadirs • 4 years - 228 values PSA ≤ 0.5 83% (n=189) PSA ≤ 0.2 57% (n=130) • 5 years - 128 values PSA ≤ 0.5 86% (n=110) PSA ≤ 0.2 77% (n=98)

  23. Deaths • Total deaths = 11 • Prostate cancer deaths = 2 • Age 69 T2b, GS 8, PSA 9.8 NAAD, EBRT + BXT Failed at 10 months, died at 4 years • Age 61 T2c, GS 5, PSA 6 BXT alone, Failed at 13 months, died at 4 years

  24. Toxicity Urinary • Acute retention 7% (28) • Urethral stricture 8% (32) • TURP 2.5% (10) Erectile dysfunction • 226 (57%) potent at baseline (IIEF > 11) • 71% remain potent at 2 years (60% with PDE-5i)

  25. Summary • Prospective UK results consistent with US data • Well-tolerated radical treatment option • Toxicity similar to published series • ED likely to improve with technique modifications • Post-implant CT-based dosimetry essential (D90≥140Gy correlates with PSA control) • Importance of continued local appraisal of dosimetry and outcomes

  26. Acknowledgements • Professor Stephen Langley • Dr Robert Laing • Dr Sara Khaksar • Dr David Lovell • Dr Julian Money-Kyrle • Professor Ian Wells • Mr Prasanna Sooriakumaran • Mr Alistair Henderson

More Related