70 likes | 181 Views
Getting to Excellent Student Work. New Technology School of Design. Quality work means…. Rethinking Reworking Polishing. Critique Student work with Protocols. Be kind Be specific Be helpful. http:// digitalartandmedia.org /assets/critique-peer-edit- sheet.docx. Gallery Critique.
E N D
Getting to Excellent Student Work New Technology School of Design
Quality work means… Rethinking Reworking Polishing
Critique Student work with Protocols • Be kind • Be specific • Be helpful http://digitalartandmedia.org/assets/critique-peer-edit-sheet.docx
Gallery Critique • Beginners Gallery Critique • Student work is posted • Students find what impresses them and discuss why • Positive pressure to produce • http://www.hightechhigh.org/projects/?name=HTH%20Structures:%20Critique&uid=62b71eda34c5facd43a5dbe4cfed90a2 • Marisol Franco: Part I, II, III • Dr. Ron Berger http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1znB1ox0_EI • http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J2K75WO7a70
Follow clear and specific guidelines • Begin with the author explaining the goals and ideas behind the work as well as what they are trying to achieve • Critique the work, not the person • Begin with positives, “I like…” • Use I statements. “I am confused by…” • Use question format when possible
In depth critique • Student assignment is one requiring at least 3 drafts • All students look at the work of one student or one group selected by you • The work selected is either of good quality or poor quality • Demonstrates what is good work • Demonstrates what to avoid • Discussion, Discussion, Discussion