230 likes | 347 Views
Irene Y.H. Ng swknyhi@nus.edu.sg. Troubled by financial and children troubles: psychological self-concepts of low-income parents in Singapore Social Work Social Development 2012 10 July 2012. Acknowledgements. Ministry of Community Development Youth and Sports (MCYS)
E N D
Irene Y.H. Ng swknyhi@nus.edu.sg Troubled by financial and children troubles: psychological self-concepts of low-income parents in SingaporeSocial Work Social Development 201210 July 2012
Acknowledgements Ministry of Community Development Youth and Sports (MCYS) Community Development Councils Research team: Ho Kong Weng, Division of Economics, NTU Alex Lee, Department of Social Work, NUS Ngiam Tee Liang, Department of Social Work, NUS Nesam Tharmalingam, Department of Social Work, NUS
Today’s Presentation • Poverty in Singapore • Socioeconomic and policy context • Theory: effects on and of parents’ self-concepts • Self-efficacy • Aggravation in parenting • Sample & methodology • Findings • Implications for working with low-income parents
Poverty in Singapore • Wage stagnation despite high economic growth • Widening inequality => Bottom earners of increasing concern
Policy Context • Limited effectiveness for many/majority of recipients • Why? • Poor families seldom struggle with ONLY financial woes
Children problems Model of self-concepts of low-income parents Increased difficult in sustaining work & meeting welfare requirements • Financial hardship • Diminished self-concept
Sample:754 parents with at least one child below 21 years oldat the start of Work SupportMar 2010-Jul 2011
Work Support Government financial assistance programme to help recipients find employment and achieve financial independence through interim financial support and other assistance
Method: Linear probability regression Interaction Parents’ (a) self-efficacy & (b) parenting aggravation
Self-concept 1: Self-efficacy / self-mastery “The extent to which people see themselves as being in control of the forces that importantly affect their lives” (Pearlin et al. 1980, Bandura 1982)
Pearlin Self-efficacy • No way I can solve some of my problems • Little control over things • Often feel helpless • Little I can do to change important things
Self-concept 2: Parenting aggravation “Parenting stress that might result from changes in employment, income and other factors” (Panel Study of Income Dynamics 2010) • Adapted from Parenting Stress Index (Abidin, 1990)
Aggravation in parenting • Being a parent is harder than I thought • I feel trapped by my responsibility as a parent • I find that taking care of my child(ren) is more work than pleasure • I often feel tired, worn out, or exhausted from raising a family
Individual’s characteristics • how many family members or relatives: • they heard from at least once a month, • felt at ease to talk about private matters, and • could call on for help. • Similarly for friends or neighbours • Scale: 0 – 5 (nine or more)
Results: No interactions Standard errors in parentheses. * significant at 5%; ** significant at 1%
Results: With interactions Standard errors in parentheses. * significant at 5%; ** significant at 1%
Results: Another significant factor Standard errors in parentheses. * significant at 5%; ** significant at 1% Model without interactions shown, but results similar in model with interactions.
Main findings • Children’s health aggravated parenting. • Children’s difficult behaviour worsened parenting stress AND parents’ self-efficacy. • Family earnings did not relate to self-concepts. However, lower family earnings • amplified the effects of children’s difficult behaviour on parents’ stress and self-efficacy. • Social support from friends and family improved self-efficacy.
Limitations • Cross-sectional => can’t conclude causality
Implications • limited effectiveness if recipients’ psychosocial barriers to financial independence not addressed • Case-management beyond financial monitoring • Case loads & case-management training • Integration of services • Supportive manner of case officer important • Targeted assessment and intervention • For families with difficult children and • on improving social support. * Evaluation of these suggestions