1 / 27

Effectively Progressive Income Tax (EPIT) aka Basic Income + Flat Tax (BIFT)

Effectively Progressive Income Tax (EPIT) aka Basic Income + Flat Tax (BIFT). Richard Parncutt, Uni Graz, 14 June 2009. Progressive income tax in Austria 2005-2009. Net income (k€/yr). Gross income (k€ /yr). Broken line: Extrapolated high rate  BI = 8.5 k€/yr = 708 €/mo.

kaspar
Download Presentation

Effectively Progressive Income Tax (EPIT) aka Basic Income + Flat Tax (BIFT)

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Effectively Progressive Income Tax (EPIT)aka Basic Income + Flat Tax (BIFT) Richard Parncutt, Uni Graz, 14 June 2009

  2. Progressive income tax in Austria2005-2009 Net income (k€/yr) Gross income (k€ /yr) Broken line: Extrapolated high rate  BI = 8.5 k€/yr = 708 €/mo

  3. Progressive income tax in Australia1 € ≈ 1.7 $ 45% Net income (k$/yr) 40% 30% 23 15% 0% Gross income (k$/yr) Broken line: Extrapolated high rate  BI = 23k$/yr = 13.1 k€/yr = 1090 €/mo

  4. Progressive income tax in Canadafederal not provincial; 1 € ≈ 1.6 $ Net income (k$/yr) 11.4 Gross income (k$/yr) Parameter: marginal tax rates Broken line: Extrapolated high rate  11.4k$/yr = 7.28 k€/yr = 607 €/mo

  5. Welfare trapsSozialhilfefalle Zuverdienstgrenze Limited extra income of welfare recipients • welfare is cut suddenly or gradually • rising gross income  constant/falling net income • local implicit tax rate of 100% or more • Suppresses incentive • Reinforces rigid class identity • Generates resentment and class conflict

  6. Basic IncomePhilippe Van Parijs, 2000; Basic Income Earth Network • Features • unconditional • individual • as handout or tax deduction • Questions • citizens? • children? • pensioners? • Advantages • no means test • no welfare traps • less bureacracy • “willingness” not tested • less class stigma • open and honest • freedom • no poverty • more risk taking Disadvantages: reduces incentive, changes wage structure

  7. Flat income taxneo-cons, neo-libs… • Advantages • can be paid immediately • reduces tax evasion/avoidance • promotes economic growth • the “poor rich” don’t feel “discriminated” • Disadvantages • increases rich-poor divide • linked to neo-liberal and far-right politics

  8. My hidden agenda • Centre-left liberal-green • Eliminate poverty • Resolve left-right conflict • Transparency, democracy • Political realism Co-supervision of PhD? • Topic: detailed economic consequences

  9. Basic Income + Flat Tax BIFTaka negative income tax plus flat taxcf. Friedman & Rose (1980); Atkinson (1995); Strengmann-Kuhn (2005) break-even point basic income Arbitrary parameters: BI = 500 €/mo., FT = 50% Could be: BI = 700 €/mo, FT = 40%

  10. Effectively Progressive Income Tax(EPIT) with BI = 500 (€/mo) and FT = 50%

  11. Just one kind of progressivity BI plus progressive tax?  two simultaneous sources of progressivity! Just one progressive system allows for any • level of progressivity • progress toward income equity Combining two progressive systems creates • unnecessary complexity, reduced transparency • opportunities for clever tax advisers

  12. Setting the parameters • Basic income (500…800 €/mo) • high enough to eliminate poverty • poverty line in Austria: 60% median wage ≈ €900 • low enough to maintain incentive • Tax rate (35…50%) • high enough to finance BI etc. • low enough to maintain incentive • Adjustment procedure • left versus right politics • economic models

  13. Basic income for childrenreplaces other comparable benefits • Less than for adults? • lower expectations; less political power • More than for adults? Childcare wage: • 10 hours x 30 days x €10 = €3000/month! • high rate of poverty among single parents • Same BI for adults and children? • less arbitrary; democratic ideology (equality) • Problem • low work incentive for large unemployed families

  14. Special casestypical low income earners • Single parents • BI for parent and each child • free creche, kindergarten, school, university • Pensioners • same BI as everyone else • other pension schemes in addition (taxed) • Disabled • higher rates of BI • BI depends on ability, not willingness to work

  15. Realism and equity in taxation Amount depends on ability to pay • income tax (variable capital) • wealth tax (constant capital)

  16. Flat wealth taxes ...are effectively progressive because only the rich have significant wealth (middle classes have relatively high income but low capital) Example: 0.2% / year

  17. Flat wealth taxes • What about the family farm? • What about Granny’s house? Anyone with wealth • can convert it to other forms of wealth • is better off than those with less wealth • should compete equally in a free market  Treat everyone equally

  18. Flat taxesthat reduce the rich-poor gap • Capital gains tax (incl. income tax) • only progressive with basic income • one flat tax for all people and all income • wages, gifts, inheritance, interest, speculation… • Wealth tax • one flat rate for all all people and all wealth • bank, home, farm, company, yacht…

  19. Flat wealth tax: Advantages • reduces rich-poor gap • accesses large resources • reduces tax evasion • shifting wealth around doesn‘t help • easier to control • total wealth tax α total taxable wealth

  20. Taxing the poorvalue-added tax VAT (MWSt) VAT on basic commodities is regressive VAT on luxury goods is progressive

  21. Problems that BIFT addresses • Poverty • scandalous! • Welfare traps • suppress incentive and class mobility • Inequity, injustice • black markets • tax avoidance, welfare fraud • Inefficiency • complexity  dependence on advice • armies of accountants and bureaucrats • uninformed democracy

  22. BIFT Priorities (1) • More important • gross-net relationship • Less important • terminology for BI and FT • history of terms & ideology • specific levels of BI and FT

  23. BIFT Priorities (2) • More important • reducing rich-poor gap (left politics) • motivating productivity (right politics) • Less important • needs or desires of specific groups • Rules of thumb • “no such thing as a free lunch” • advantage for me = disadvantage for you

  24. BIFT Priorities (3) • Standard of living • no poverty • Freedom • choice, privacy, mobility • Democracy • rights, transparency, people power • Socialism • fair distribution of resources • Capitalism • incentive, production, wealth • Efficiency • waste reduction

  25. Socialists and capitalistscf. humanities & sciences, Palestine & Israel… Like any other major conflict: • strong identities based on difference • ignorance of Other group  prejudice • assumed moral superiority Conflict resolution • mutual recognition • fairness, transparency • reduction of distance

  26. Global inclusive politics: Approach • Global • focus on biggest global problems • rational, co-operative, global solutions • “think globally, act locally” • Moral • universal religious and secular morality • altruism, honesty, human rights

  27. Global inclusive politics: Issues • poverty reduction – local and global • environment, global warming • intercultural conflict, weapons • global distribution of resources • population growth • global democracy

More Related