90 likes | 106 Views
Hank Harris, Executive Director of Human Resources Michelle Riddell, Assistant Executive Director of Human Resources. Teacher Hire, Assignment, and Transfer (HAT) Process Update 11/8/2010. Agenda:. PPS/PAT Teacher Hire, Assignment and Transfer (HAT) agreement and Recent History
E N D
Hank Harris, Executive Director of Human ResourcesMichelle Riddell, Assistant Executive Director of Human Resources Teacher Hire, Assignment, and Transfer (HAT) Process Update 11/8/2010
Agenda: • PPS/PAT Teacher Hire, Assignment and Transfer (HAT) agreement and Recent History • 2. Report back on our Key Objectives: • Objective #1: Earlier Recruiting and Hiring of External Candidates • Objective #2: Maximizing Mutual Consent in internal teacher transfers • 3. Barriers to Meeting Objectives and Possible Solutions
Definitions: • HAT: Hire, Assignment and Transfer of Teachers. • “Mutual Consent” vs. “Placement” Mutual Consent is when both the candidate and the hiring manager are mutually favorable toward this assignment. Placement is when a teacher is assigned into a vacancy without agreement from either party. Typically these terms are associated with internal transfers/hires, but they could also apply to external hires. • Phase I: Teachers with three of more years of experience may apply; these vacancies are posted for one week only • Phase II - Internal “Interview and Select”: Following Phase I all remaining vacancies (and new as they become open) are posted for five days; we ask unassigned teachers to apply so they can be interviewed and selected; all teachers are eligible to apply (temporary and substitutes may not). • Phase II - External: Vacancies are posted externally in areas where there are no unassigned teachers. Internal and external candidates may apply. Internal candidates have stronger consideration.
PAT/PPS HAT Recent History • Prior to 2008, there was increasing concern that the then-current Hire, Assignment and Transfer (HAT) process was inefficient and problematic. • PAT and PPS met during 2007-08 and agreed to modifications to the HAT Process: • Monetary incentives for early notice of intent to retire or resign ($500 - $1250) • Rationale: More early notices provide better ability to conduct early external hiring • Change in the Process of “Placing” teachers • Rationale: “Mutual Consent” is a superior model to “Placement” • Agreement that after fifteen days prior to the school year, job openings would be filled through already existent candidate pools rather than through an open posting process • Rationale: Late postings encourage late internal transfers which create a destabilizing domino effect. • In 2009, the district had significant success in meeting Objective #2 and limited success in meeting objective #1, largely due to the delay in adopting the budget for FY 2009-10. • In 2010, the district did not experience success in either meeting Objective #1 or Objective #2, largely due to the delay in adopting the budget for FY 2010-11.
Maximizing “Mutual Consent” in Internal Teacher Transfers. • “Placements” increased dramatically in 2010. In 2009, only 23% of our Unassigned Teacher assignments were Placements. This was a significant improvement over 2008. However, in 2010 this number jumped to 55%. • In 2009, 53% of teaching placements were “Mutual Consent.” In 2010 this number dropped to 17%. • “Other” includes Unassigned Teachers who returned to their former positions, took leaves, or left the district
Begin Recruiting Externally by May 1: External Postings by Month:
Barriers to Meeting our Objectives • Budget delays. • HAT process is based on philosophy that mutual consent is advantageous in both external and internal hiring. • HAT process is based on philosophy that teachers in good standing internally should have some degree of precedence over external candidates in hiring. • District philosophy that prioritizes local decision-making regarding allocation of staff. • As in many large school districts, the “pre-staffing” process is much more complex than in smaller districts. (In PPS, the time required to move from budget recommendation to the first Job Postings can be four weeks.)
Possible Solutions • Changes to the HAT Process. This requires negotiation with PAT. • Early offers to candidates not specific to a certain school. • Challenges: • Philosophy of mutual consent • Current economic challenges • Less localized decision-making regarding staffing.