280 likes | 412 Views
Middle East Conflict Road to the 6-Day War. 1956-67. Longterm Issues leading to 6-Day War. Unresolved Arab-Israeli Issues Israeli Economics & IR Cold War Issues Water Issues Inter-Arab Issues (Arab Divisions, Palestinian liberation movements). Unresolved Arab-Israeli Issues.
E N D
Longterm Issues leading to 6-Day War • Unresolved Arab-Israeli Issues • Israeli Economics & IR • Cold War Issues • Water Issues • Inter-Arab Issues (Arab Divisions, Palestinian liberation movements)
Unresolved Arab-Israeli Issues • Suez Crisis leaves underlying conflict unresolved • Israel out of Sinai, but UN Emergency Forces (UNEF) remain • Nasser has control of Suez Canal • Prevents intensity of fedayeen
Israel After Suez • Israel back to 1949 lines (inset 1956-57) • Israel improves development of Negev through water • Trade through Gulf of Aqaba • Huge immigration helps economy • Mid 1960’s economic downturn magnified by attacks from Syria & in Golan Heights
Arab Nationalism • Nasser still promoting Arab Renaissance • “Arab Freedom, Arab Socialism, Arab Unity” • Combo of private & public ownership
Radical Arab Nationalism • Exemplified by Egypt & Syria, to some degree Yemen • United Arab Republic 1958 • Egypt maintained control, Syria’s large middle class didn’t like this, or the socialist tendencies • When Nasser tries to nationalize Syrian industry, Syria pulls out 1961
Arab “moderates” • King Hussein of Jordan maintains a more moderate stance toward the West & Israel • Lebanon’s Maronite population keep them somewhat connected to the West • Iraq under Monarch Nuri al-Said (before Revolution of 58 ousts him for Qasim)
Arab Cold War? • Division among Arabs • Conflict over having Nasser be “in charge” • Radical, armed aggression vs. moderate, negotiated settlement w/ Israel • USSR supports Syria, Egypt….US backs Israel, Lebanon
Case Study of Inter-Arab Issues: Lebanon 1957-58 • Lebanon seen as anomaly in Arab world • Pro-west history; port for inland states; banking center for mid-East • Coalition gov’t w/ Christian Maronite (Camille Charoum) as head • Internal divisions not strictly along Christian-Muslim lines
Cold War Enters Again.. • Egypt funding opposition groups; • Iraqi revolution ousts King Said for more radical leaders • Chamoun (Maronite leader) asks for Eisenhower’s Help • Brings in Superpower • Under Eisenhower Doctrine, the US intervenes • ….read… • SHOULD THE US HAVE INTERVENED? • Read Gaddis….
US & Mid-East 50’s – 60’s • US deepens involvement in Mid-East • Supplies sympathetic Arab states – Jordan, Saudi Arabia • Israel demands arms from US to defend themselves from Arab states • US policy seems contradictory • Through 1960’s US sees Arab world as unstable- potential for USSR influence – (already there for Syria, Iraq, Egypt) • Leads to increasing focus on Israel
Water Issues – Israel’s National Water Carrier • Israel & Syria clash over diverting water from headwaters of Jordan R • In 58, Jordan takes H2O from Yarmuk R, Israel from Lake Tiberias (Galilee)- reduces water for Jordan • Done in atmosphere of Is-Syrian conflict & border disputes • UN feels that Is skirts UN rules in order to incite Arab retaliation – justifying accusations of Arab hostility • Syria wants action against Israel NOW!
Arab Response to water Issues 1964 • Arab Summit 1964 brings muted response • Avoids direct confrontation w/ Israel • Makes agreement w/ King Hussien of Jordan & King Faysal of Saudi Ar. • Peaceful mood among Arab states • UNTIL….
Palestinian Question Revived 1964 • Not all Arab leaders agreed on the importance of the Palestinian issue • Nasser in support of Palestinian cause so that he could control it • Nasser doesn’t want to be brought into Eg-Is conflict (unless he’s ready) • Syria (now tense W/ Egypt b/c of UAR breakup in 62) accusing
PLO 1964 – Ahmad al-Shuquayri Egyptian-influenced; recruited from refugee camps all over Arab world Claimed the territory of West Bank (Jordan controlled) and Israel as Palestinian Jordan sees them as threat; Syria sees them as too tame Fatah 1958 – Salah Khalaf, Khalil al-Wizer, Yasir Arafat Gaza/Cairo roots, Syria-backed Free Palestine before Arab unity could happen Philosophy changed according to circumstance by 1965 focus on attacking military installations and terrorism to bring Arab-Israeli tension Arab unity in the face of common enemy PLO vs. FATAH
Fatah & Syria • First Fatah raids on water installations (& in revenge for Israeli attacks on Syrian water installations) • Unclear to Israel if Fatah backed by Jordan or Syria – attacks from Jordanian territory • Jordan gets stuck between Israeli’s and Syrians – unable to stop Fatah raids
Immediate Causes of 6-Day War - Rhetoric • Increasing rhetoric against Israel • Syrian Pres. Nureddin al-Attassi declares support for Palestinian war of liberation
Cause #2: Syrian – Israeli Attacks • DMZ in Golan Heights • Fatah attacks mount • Israel threatens major retaliatory raid if attacks don’t stop
Cause #3: Egyptian Actions - Blockade • Nasser gets false info from USSR that Israel is putting troops along Syrian frontier – he believes it • Sends Egyptian troops to Sinai (May 14) • Withdraws UNEF from Sinai • Blockaded Straits of Tiran; took over Sharm al-Shaykh • USSR officially urging restraint, but Nasser thinks USSR supports him
Israel Prepares Attacks • Prime Minister Eshkol appeals to US for backing • US urges wait; tries to open Straits through diplomatic means • Israeli Generals attack Eshkol as weak • June 4 Defense Minister Moshe Dayan’s plan to attack is approved PM: Levi Eshkol
Results: • Questions remain as to why Egypt closed straits of Tiran giving Israel legal justification to attack • New Territory for Israel includes: West Bank, Golan Heights, Sinai, & Jerusalem • Israel evicts 600 Muslim residents from Magrebhi Quarter, razes the area • 100,000+ Palestinian refugees move from W. Bank to E. bank of Jordan
Longer-term results • USSR cuts diplomatic relations with Israel • Palestinian liberation organizations expand and proliferate • Israel has extreme sense of power • Arab states cut ties w/ US – Egy.,Sy, Iraq, Sud., Alg, & Yemen • UN Resolution 242 creates confusion in negotiations
UN Resolution 242 Read the resolution How do you interpret the reading? Which should come first, peace negotiations or a return of captured territory?
Conclusion • Use of Palestinians by different Arab countries feuled conflict • Backing (or percieved backing) by superpowers fueled conflict • Concrete issues (water) fuel conflict • Longstanding issues (recognition of Israel) fuel conflict • No Resolution of underlying conflict • No proposal for Palestinian issue