210 likes | 584 Views
Hormone receptor-positive, HER2-positive breast cancer – which target dominates the phenotype 20 th Annual NOCR meeting Las Vegas, February 28 th 2014. Ruth M. O’Regan, MD Professor and Vice-Chair for Educational Affairs, Department of Hematology and Medical Oncology, Emory University,
E N D
Hormone receptor-positive, HER2-positive breast cancer – which target dominates the phenotype20th Annual NOCR meetingLas Vegas, February 28th 2014 Ruth M. O’Regan, MD Professor and Vice-Chair for Educational Affairs, Department of Hematology and Medical Oncology, Emory University, Chief of Hematology and Medical Oncology, Georgia Cancer Center for Excellence, Grady Memorial Hospital
HER2-positive breast cancers are intrinsically resistant to endocrine therapy • Transfection of ER-positive breast cancer cells with HER2 renders them resistant to tamoxifen • Retrospective analyses of trials in the ER-positive metastatic setting show a worse outcome for cancers that co-express HER2, compared to those that do not • Median progression free survival is less than 6 months for ER+ HER2+ MBC treated with aromatase inhibitors Benz BRCT BRCT 1992, De Laurentiis J Clin Oncol 2005, Kaufman J Clin Oncol 2009, Johnston J Clin Oncol 2009
Outcome for patients with ER+ metastatic breast cancer based on HER2 status HER2- HER2+/- Progression free survival(months) ANAST ANAST LET LET LET Kaufman J Clin Oncol 2009, Johnston J Clin Oncol 2009, Bonneterre Cancer 2001, Moridisen J Clin Oncol 2003, Nahta BRCT 2012
HER2 trumps ER when both receptors are expressed….. But is this true for all HR+ HER+ breast cancers?
Pathologic complete response is consistently lower in ER+ HER2+ breast cancers compared to ER- HER2+ breast cancers Percent PCR T/P T L T/L T L T/L T L T/L T L T P T/P T/L D P P -> FEC FEC -> P EC -> D Reviewed in Nahta and O’Regan BRCT 2012
PCR is prognostic in ER- cancer but not ER+ cancers that co-express HER2 ER-negative, HER2-positive ER-positive, HER2-positive von Mitchwitz et al SABCS 2011
Other evidence supporting a role for ER in HER2+ cancers • In the adjuvant trastuzumab trials, DFS is longer for ER+ cancers compared to ER- cancers (at least up to 4-5 years) • A subset of patients with ER-positive, HER2-positive metastatic breast cancer have prolonged disease control with ER-inhibition alone without HER2-inhibition • Patterns of recurrence differ (ER+ more common in bone) Perez J Clin Oncol 2011, Kaufman J Clin Oncol 2009
Why is this important? • We may (and probably are) over-treating a subgroup of ER+, HER2+ breast cancers in the (neo)-adjuvant setting • This subgroup of patients with ER+, HER2+ breast cancers may suffer late recurrences (similar to what we see with luminal A cancers) • Can we identify this subgroup that is driven by ER?
Likelihood of PCR is inversely related to level of ER expression for HER2+ breast cancers ER expression HER2+/HR- HER2+/ER+ Percent PCR HER2+/ER+++ Bhargava Mod Path 2011, Nahta BRCT 2012
C40601: HER2+ Subtypes by Hormone Receptor (HR) HR-negative HR-positive Normal-like 7% Normal-like 10% Basal-like 15% Lum B 6% HER2-E 18% Lum B 34% Lum A 16% HER2-E 52% Lum A 43% Carey et al Proc ASCO 2013
Prognostic ability of 70-gene signature in HER2+, ER+ cancers: untreated patients (n = 89) 21-gene signature not useful as HER2+ cancers have intermediate or high recurrence scores Knauer et al BJC 2010
Bi-directional cross-talk between ER and HER2 • Signaling through EGFR family including HER2 down-regulates ER • Conversely, inhibition of HER2 with trastuzumab or lapatinib increases signaling through ER • ER signaling is increased in HER2-positive cell lines that are resistant to HER2-directed agents • HER2 expression and activity is increased in hormone-resistant cancers, compared to hormone-sensitive cancers Pinzone Mol Cell Biol 2004, Stoia J Endocrinol 2000, Sabnis Cancer Res 2009, Xia PNAS 2006, Valabrega Oncogene 2005
HER2 signaling decreases ER activation and inhibition of HER2 increases ER-regulated gene transcription TRAST HER1/2/3 HER2 HER2 HER1/2/3 PI3-K PI3-K x x Membrane Membrane TKI Ras Ras AKT AKT FOXO3a FOXO3a FOXO3a MEK MEK ER ER Erk1/2 Erk1/2 Cytoplasm Cytoplasm x ER-regulated gene transcription ER-regulated gene transcription ER ER Nucleus Nucleus ERE ERE Xia PNAS 2006, Valabrega Oncogene 2005
Clinical relevance of this cross-talk • Inhibition of HER2 without inhibition of ER may increase ER signaling allowing ER to act as an escape mechanism • This could contribute to the lower PCR seen in ER+ HER2+ breast cancers and have potential implications in the metastatic setting • There may be a subset of ER+ HER2+ breast cancers where ER inhibition is critical (more important than chemotherapy)
Excellent outcomes for small ER+ HER2+ cancers treated with trastuzumab-based chemotherapy Tolaney SABCS 2013
Response to pre-operative trastuzumab and lapatinib ± letrozole (12 weeks) pCR + npCR pCR 70 60 * 50 48% 56% 53% 40 pCR (%) 40% 30 28% 20 21% 10 0 All ER+ ER- All ER+ ER - * NeoSphere: PCR 6% with dual HER2 inhibition without ER inhibition Rimawi CCR 2013 npCR = < 1cm residual cancer in the breast
TEL trial: Pre-operative Trastuzumab, everolimus and letrozole in HR-positive, HER2-positive breast cancer (PI O’Regan) HER2 + ER+ breast cancer Stratify: ER/PR > 50% ER±PR < 50% Trastuzumab Letrozole (± LHRH agonist) Everolimus 12 weeks* Primary endpoint: PCR *Adjuvant trastuzumab-based chemotherapy at physicians discretion
Case history • 46-year old with recent diagnosis of stage 1A (T1B (8mm), N0), grade 2, ER 90%, PR 90%, HER2+ (FISH+) cancer status post bilateral mastectomies • Wants to avoid chemotherapy • 70-gene signature: good prognosis • Opts not to receive chemotherapy • Receiving trastuzumab and tamoxifen
Conclusions • Although HER2 signaling is associated with intrinsic resistance to endocrine agents, a subset of HER2+, ER+ cancers appear to be driven, at least in part, by ER • Identification of these cancers is crucial: • They may require less aggressive treatment approaches with earlier institution of ER inhibition • May behave like ER+ HER2- cancers with late relapses • Molecular profiling should be looked at in more depth in these cancers